Excalibur [Endgame]

[Varsoon]

@Gamma: I think you horribly misunderstand the rules. The sword doesn't cycle. Once a townie gets it, they're BP. They'll never be lynched either, because they can just claim sword-holder and so long as Merlin is alive, Merlin can confirm.

I'm always going for sword here, anyway.

[Firebringer]

ummmm yes, actually.

it actually isn't.
and i wrote a huge long post of why, but i don't think its worth getting into.

let me for a second pretend your point has merit: (because really i think you saying i am baiting is gross but maybe we can talk about that somewhere else)

do you think I am scum for "baiting" lld?

FTR. I was trying to bait LLD to get her more upset because she was annoying me.
But I didn't start baiting her until after she started mocking me heavily.

So I just find the insinuation that I started shit to be gross. Not if I did it or not, cause I definitely was poking her.

[Dunnstral]

do you think I am scum for "baiting" lld?

Actually I didn't even mean to direct this towards you, I'm just defending my position when you say you aren't anger baiting.

People were talking about how they were sticking up for you 'standing up to lld' or something and that's why I pointed to that in the first place

[Dunnstral]

Elsa what do you think of LLD and UT rn?

Lady is just one of those guys I lynch because I dont like the personality sometimes. Like how we lynched BEF for floundering super hard.

I'd personally challenge thee wielder if they are shitty enough. You don't get to keep the sword if you hurt the game.

Why would town vote for potential scum as opposed to an Innocent Child?

Well I don't know. You tell me.

But you really think people are going to lynch confirmed town?

If They are shitty and hurting the game, yes.

I'm not asking what you think is ideal

Do you actually THINK that as a collective, the town will come together and lynch the confirmed town, even if they're atrocious? I don't think they would

[Firebringer]

do you think I am scum for "baiting" lld?

Actually I didn't even mean to direct this towards you, I'm just defending my position when you say you aren't anger baiting.

People were talking about how they were sticking up for you 'standing up to lld' or something and that's why I pointed to that in the first place

that post wasn't anger baiting her though. it literally wasn't me trying to anger bait her.
saying it is anger bait is grossly missing the point.

[Firebringer]

ughhh

lets drop it.
this is a dumb argument.

[Auro]

FTR. I was trying to bait LLD to get her more upset

You literally said here you were baiting her to get her more upset

[DVa]

@Gamma: I think you horribly misunderstand the rules. The sword doesn't cycle. Once a townie gets it, they're BP. They'll never be lynched either, because they can just claim sword-holder and so long as Merlin is alive, Merlin can confirm.

the cycling of the sword referred to probably meant non-arthurs taking shots and dying, thus making the sword available again

[Elsa Jay]

I'd personally challenge thee wielder if they are shitty enough. You don't get to keep the sword if you hurt the game.

Why would town vote for potential scum as opposed to an Innocent Child?

Wouldn't*, sorry.
I don't think any reasonable town would vote the IC just because "shitty" lol.

Let's say Lady gets the sword and the first thing she does is challenge me day 2 so town will never get the option to do anything. You lynch me because I'm not the sword wielder. Lady gets her way.

Lady does the same thing day 3, and again, she wins since she has the sword. Day 4, guess what, she does the same thing.

I will forever hang a shitty town if it means the rest of the player base has fun.

[Firebringer]

FTR. I was trying to bait LLD to get her more upset

You literally said here you were baiting her to get her more upset

NOT THAT POST. READ CONTEXT

[Untrod Tripod]

Lynching confirmed town seems I dunno kinda scummy?

[Varsoon]

Town intentionally killing itself so that town can eventually get a Vig that'll more often than not just kill more town is an awful idea.

[DVa]

ughhh

lets drop it.
this is a dumb argument.

Dunn is this a town tell for Fire in your opinion? does he drop dumb arguments as scum? I don't remember anything like this in Witches Ball

[Dunnstral]

On another note, Firebringer roasting Lady and keeping calm doesn't earn town points, but gets respect.

FTR. I was trying to bait LLD to get her more upset because she was annoying me.
But I didn't start baiting her until after she started mocking me heavily.

So I just find the insinuation that I started shit to be gross. Not if I did it or not, cause I definitely was poking her.

[Dunnstral]

ughhh

lets drop it.
this is a dumb argument.

Dunn is this a town tell for Fire in your opinion? does he drop dumb arguments as scum? I don't remember anything like this in Witches Ball

Well I read him wrong in Witch's Ball anyway

[Firebringer]

i have no town tells. stop trying to find a method to my madness Dva

[Elsa Jay]

Town intentionally killing itself so that town can eventually get a Vig that'll more often than not just kill more town is an awful idea.

This was the entire reason I wanted merlin to claim it amd be done with it. Atleast he'll be bulletproof and know someone to trust. But again, spec talk is on hold for now.

[Dunnstral]

And for your question I don't know

[DVa]

Let's say Lady gets the sword and the first thing she does is challenge me day 2 so town will never get the option to do anything. You lynch me because I'm not the sword wielder. Lady gets her way.

Lady does the same thing day 3, and again, she wins since she has the sword. Day 4, guess what, she does the same thing.

I will forever hang a shitty town if it means the rest of the player base has fun.

lol you must think LLD really is RC

[Firebringer]

Dunnstral, can we drop the subject. I am feeling very uncomfortable with the topic.

[Gamma Emerald]

The issue Gamma is if everybody claims the Fallen don't have to bother, and therefore they never instant-die because of that

the Request for holly Excalibur is done via PM, so we don't know whom of the noble circle has requested to extract it from the rock, only that it has been claimed, and even than not by whom.

there’s a 1/4 chance we get a dead mafia n1.

There's 0% chance scum claim the sword Gamma don't shake my read on you

Fucking read further instead of knee-jerking

[Gamma Emerald]

He said in his next sentence, "Of course this crumbles if Maf don't go for it, which is the probable case"

Yeah it's just weird seeing Gamma spew out a weird theory only to immediately dismiss it tbh

That’s not my weird theory for fucks sake

[Dunnstral]

Elsa Jay I'm not trying to argue whether you believe it's right to lynch them

I'm saying it will never happen, you'll never get a majority to vote out the innocent child, not even - no, especially not the scum

[DVa]

Fucking read further instead of knee-jerking

Why did you write a paragraph of "oh yeah but scum never does this" anyway

[Dunnstral]

Dunnstral, can we drop the subject. I am feeling very uncomfortable with the topic.

oooookkkkkkk