Starcraft Mafia -- Game Over!

[Creature]

Creature how are you feeling about Nancy?

Love

[the worst]

Yeah good point.. we all love her
how about her alignment?

[the worst]

@Xtoxm couple of things
1) is your name a Tom variation? it's distracting me
2) do you think you're easy to read? => do you think it should be easier to read you after having a look at your past games?

[Nauci]

I knew I forgot some people while haphazardly making that list at my ophthalmologist appointment lol

Varsoon is lean town

Creature is as utterly unreadable as ever to me, so null

Irrelephant's claim I was skeptical of so I had as lean town until the flavor claim had me thinking about it some more I am now more confident in it

I wonder if SKrelephant would do something like this though

Also if he is town I hope scum don't have a shot of bp and murder him anyway because I'd be a sad panda!

I need to case mitillos's scum games but the way he's been approaching this game just feels town to the core

[Nauci]

The bad juju for saudade is because he post >600 times in the game I modded where he was town and he's only popped in here once!

[Irrelephant11]

Oh no I didn’t even think of that

[Nancy Drew 39]

What's the difference between town/scum Nancy? I haven't seen her scum games.

I'm literally not sure. She posts HEAPS and has the same kind of off beat solving as scum, she had me 100% duped in Heroes Wanted.

we only caught her because Sakura Hana YOLO suicide-dayvigged her

What “solving” if any, did I do in that game?

What solving did anyone do in that game? I read like 40% of it but everything I saw up until the day Sakura was turned to stone, you were totally in sync with the townblock and seemed to be solving pretty much in line with the way you solve as town

do you think I'm misremembering? gimme something to look for in your Heroes Wanted iso which is a point of contrast from your towngame? I will not re-read HW but I'm happy to do some homework

Look harder, what REAL solving did I do, outside of mainly mechanical speculation? Did you ever really see me trying to seriously sort anyone like I did for example, in Labrynth or CoH? Did I ever try really hard to get deep nuanced reads on anyone? If you had been paying attention, you would already know the answer to that. Not criticizing or anything, you wouldn’t have thought to look for that at the time. Ank did and no, she wasn’t getting her read on me from any “astral plane” , she just instinctively knew what to look for. The main reason, some people think I’m “unreadable”, is because I never fake my emotions and I derp as either alignment, so you can’t read me based on that. As town, I go to bat for my hard townreads. As scum, I really only go to bat for any town slot, that I think will futher my game. Otherwise, I don’t care.

[AlmostNancy]

What's the difference between town/scum Nancy? I haven't seen her scum games.

I'm literally not sure. She posts HEAPS and has the same kind of off beat solving as scum, she had me 100% duped in Heroes Wanted.

we only caught her because Sakura Hana YOLO suicide-dayvigged her

What “solving” if any, did I do in that game?

What solving did anyone do in that game? I read like 40% of it but everything I saw up until the day Sakura was turned to stone, you were totally in sync with the townblock and seemed to be solving pretty much in line with the way you solve as town

do you think I'm misremembering? gimme something to look for in your Heroes Wanted iso which is a point of contrast from your towngame? I will not re-read HW but I'm happy to do some homework

Look harder, what REAL solving did I do, outside of mainly mechanical speculation? Did you ever really see me trying to seriously sort anyone like I did for example, in Labrynth or CoH? Did I ever try really hard to get deep nuanced reads on anyone? If you had been paying attention, you would already know the answer to that. Not criticizing or anything, you wouldn’t have thought to look for that at the time. Ank did and no, she wasn’t getting her read on me from any “astral plane” , she just instinctively knew what to look for. The main reason, some people think I’m “unreadable”, is because I never fake my emotions and I derp as either alignment, so you can’t read me based on that. As town, I go to bat for my hard townreads. As scum, I really only go to bat for any town slot, that I think will futher my game. Otherwise, I don’t care.

[AlmostNancy]

Sorry mod, please don’t modkill me.

[AlmostNancy]

Creature how are you feeling about Nancy?

Love

Yeah good point.. we all love her
how about her alignment?

He crossed it out, though. A50 wasn’t lying to you about my D1 play. Like you, he is basing this on what he’s seen of my play. You probably don’t remember but I think I waited until 10 days to post anything meaningful in Labrynth. And other then Necromancer, what games of mine, have you seen me participate in RVS? Games heavy on mechanics or alternatve setups don’t count. I don’t avoid RVS in those. The fact is if you can’t see that I’m town here, there’s really not much more I can say or do to convince you, is there? I’m not going to apologize for being good as scum, that doesn’t change the fact that I’m still town here.

[AlmostNancy]

The A50/Nancy posts a couple of pages ago really don't resonate with me at all. :S

Creature how are you feeling about Nancy?

I adore you but I’m not going to repeatedly continue to bang my head against a brick wall, trying to convince anyone. I think it should be obvious to you what my alignment is but for some reason it’s not and I don’t even understand why but it’s becoming somewhat disheartening. :/

[AlmostNancy]

Yeah I'm starting to feel like A50 is leaning on Nancy's more focused contributions to make the slot look active and just sticking around memeing because he likes our company/doesnt want to be seen as lurking if that makes sense

yeah this is kinda exactly what i'm feeling like rn
like he's using the memes to act like he's doing something when he isn't really (that's what he did the entire first day of jungle republic)

he isn't someone i really want to be wrong on tho

and nancy's contribution is also feeling very fluffy ('i like this playerlist!' and 'i remember being wrong on the worst in that game'); very little of it is solve-y

Yeah, I am not being uberserious but that is never AI for me. And I do like this playerlist. That makes me scum how exactly?

Because there's a paucity of townposts accompanying the memeposts. And i didnt call you scum for it, but rather said i wasnt townreading you for it, which is not at all the same thing

I asked A50 why he is being so memey and he said, he plays differently every game, so he can’t be read based on meta. I hope that doesn’t get us mslynched at some point.

[AlmostNancy]

Because there's a paucity of townposts accompanying the memeposts. And i didnt call you scum for it, but rather said i wasnt townreading you for it, which is not at all the same thing

This is probably me atm. looking at both A50's and Nancy's reactions to being scumread I actually think they both vibe town but I also don't think I'm going to get this read right and confident on day one this time

What's the difference between town/scum Nancy? I haven't seen her scum games.

I'm literally not sure. She posts HEAPS and has the same kind of off beat solving as scum, she had me 100% duped in Heroes Wanted.

we only caught her because Sakura Hana YOLO suicide-dayvigged her

What “solving” if any, did I do in that game?

What solving did anyone do in that game? I read like 40% of it but everything I saw up until the day Sakura was turned to stone, you were totally in sync with the townblock and seemed to be solving pretty much in line with the way you solve as town

do you think I'm misremembering? gimme something to look for in your Heroes Wanted iso which is a point of contrast from your towngame? I will not re-read HW but I'm happy to do some homework

Yes, you probably aren’t going to figure it out on D1. I can’t give you specific posts - only tell you what to look for, or if your pressed for time reread why Ank was scumreadong me. HINT: She said she didn’t think I was really trying to sort her.

[Irrelephant11]

I would like Nancy to stop towncasing herself now (if A50 is also doing that I would like that to stop as well)
Please and thank you <3

VOTE: Keyser

[Irrelephant11]

Oh wait I’m on a wagon I like already
VOTE: xtoxm

[Irrelephant11]

But my second vote is on Keyser in spirit

[Mewtaph]

Quickly skimmed

Survey says...

Paranoid gut off feelings here VOTE: skitter30

Here we go again ᕕ( ᐛ )ᕗ

@Nauci: Can you talk about what you saw here a bit more? What was paranoia pinging you about skitter and where are you on them since then?

______

VOTE: shosin

I was already getting scum vibes from calling a bunch of different people town for no reason and campaigning for a policy lynch is just a dick move

@Xtoxm: Were/are there any townreads from Shoshin that you disagreed with specifically?

______

VOTE: Xtoxm

Strikes me a possibly disgruntled scum, like Shoshin said, pissed at the townblock.

@AlmostNancy: Why do you think Xtoxm has come off as disgruntled scum? How do you think he has been pissed towards the townblock?

______

Willing to thought dump on mostly everyone that's been active so far at this point, some more extensively than others - so feel free to ask.

[Irrelephant11]

Dumb thoughts on Nauci!
Annnnd Creature
Annnd AlmostNancy

[Irrelephant11]

And mitillos

[Xtoxm]

@Xtoxm couple of things
1) is your name a Tom variation? it's distracting me
2) do you think you're easy to read? => do you think it should be easier to read you after having a look at your past games?

1. Mm
2. No, not really. What I said really only applied to A50 uniquely. This game has been fairly different to any of my 'meta' I feel. And I haven't played for like 2 years. Probably part of why I'm really struggling to get any reads in this game.

[Creature]

Creature is as utterly unreadable as ever to me

If I'm posting whatever comes from my mind I'm town

[Irrelephant11]

Dumb thoughts on Nauci!
Annnnd Creature
Annnd AlmostNancy

Dump

Mobile posting is less fun

[Nauci]

I would like Nancy to stop towncasing herself now (if A50 is also doing that I would like that to stop as well)
Please and thank you <3

VOTE: Keyser

All of my thoughts on Keyser are based on his lack of posting—the grandstanding about having a wacky theory and never getting around to posting it.

I think that his alignment is only determinable with posts so I'm just throwing this one on the back burner for now.

What do you think of xtoxm's somewhat meatier new posts?

[Nauci]

@mewtaph it was as I had mentioned: a gut feeling from early pages because she wasn't as casual as I expected

I previously have mind melded with skitter's views and reactions to the point of creepiness so I just assume that if she's town I will do so again. Until then, she remains in my null group (the implication being that I've not had tons of mind melding thus far).

How far are you caught up?

[Shoshin]

Willing to thought dump on mostly everyone that's been active so far at this point, some more extensively than others - so feel free to ask.

Who do you scumread?