A Story Revisited (Anything uPick): Day 6

[jjh927]

It's possible

sure but its also possible that there's only 1 or 3. Your belief that the claimed babysitter AND some unknown rolebloker are both scum is a pretty informed conclusion.

This is a terrible argument on so many levels and it makes no coherent sense. You're suggesting I "know" there are 2 scum left, which is a convenient misrep of what I said. Nobody has claimed the babysitter because that would be dumb. The roleblocker is blatantly scum based on the people who have claimed to have been roleblocked. If it was an "informed conclusion", then I would have to also be scum as well as both of those roles, meaning your argument doesn't even have self consistency.

[Vecna]

So far it seems all roles have max 1 activated ability, and anything extra is like passive stuff. Im gonna keep that assumption in this post.

More or less confirmed stuff (That -might- still have added abilities we dont know about, but most likely only passive stuff if my assumption is correct)
The MEME Men - Double voter Parity cop stuff
Northsidegal Townclear, Question Mark
Profii Townclear, Questionmark + resurrectionstuff?
Vecna Town JK
jjh927 - Vote shit, death proof guy
Creature - flavour cop

Unknown stuff:
Gamma Emerald Question Mark
Porkens message stuff + ?
Lady Angel ?
Jingle ?
Nero Cain ?
randomidget Aristophanes ?
Shoshin Bodyguard claim

What we know must be in the unknown-stuff pool:
-Roleblocker
-Vig/SK type role
-Nurse

NOT TRYING TO GET ANYONE TO CLAIM WITH THIS

[Nero Cain]

it's like not at all impossible that you are lying about your role and you do have a roleblock.

[jjh927]

That said I'm sure one day something will get past me but it's not today

this coming from the person that hard defended Mastina all game...

Just gonna point out I was still right about her role so yeah

Just happened that she was scum playing very sub-optimally, the degree of which being one of the main reasons I locktowned her

[jjh927]

it's like not at all impossible that you are lying about your role and you do have a roleblock.

How the fuck did I freeze the votes if I was lying

[Nero Cain]

Jingle is a pizza vendor and LA is a claimed 1 shot dreaming God

[Vecna]

it's like not at all impossible that you are lying about your role and you do have a roleblock.

He'd be the sole exception to my assessment that people generally only seem to have a single activated ability in this setup.

[Vecna]

I thought pizza vendor was a eufemism for a hidden role?

[Gamma Emerald]

Mechanically, needless to say the roleblocker is scum but I'm pretty sure the babysitter can be too

What utility is there for scum babysitter?

[Nero Cain]

it's like not at all impossible that you are lying about your role and you do have a roleblock.

How the fuck did I freeze the votes if I was lying

it's like in addition to. You aren't this dumb...well I guess you could be, idk.

[Vecna]

it's like not at all impossible that you are lying about your role and you do have a roleblock.

He'd be the sole exception to my assessment that people generally only seem to have a single activated ability in this setup.

Note to self; assumption is the mother of all fuckups

[Vecna]

Mechanically, needless to say the roleblocker is scum but I'm pretty sure the babysitter can be too

What utility is there for scum babysitter?

Protection against the SK killing people for inactivity ~

[Nero Cain]

it's like not at all impossible that you are lying about your role and you do have a roleblock.

He'd be the sole exception to my assessment that people generally only seem to have a single activated ability in this setup.

Note to self; assumption is the mother of all fuckups

Its actually kinda a point I like though.

[jjh927]

Mechanically, needless to say the roleblocker is scum but I'm pretty sure the babysitter can be too

What utility is there for scum babysitter?

Let's say there's a town vig or an SK

If the scum babysitter can predict a scum player going to be killed by them, then they protect them.
If the scum babysitter is the one likely to be killed, then they target a town player and go 1 for 1



Their targets have been highly questionable so it makes sense with that logic

[Vecna]

So yeah, im keeping that Jingle and LA claim out of my list since I have no idea wtf its supposed to do, or how we go about confirming that nonsense. Doesnt really appear to make any difference in solving shit, if we do go down that rabbit hole.

[jjh927]

Well yeah I'm pretty sure Jingle's ability does something but all I can do is confirm it gives out pizza

[Vecna]

I mean, if you assume scum babysitter + scum roleblocker you can solve the setup to a pretty high degree now. Someonw could probably do a setup overview, comparing the team strengths to see what is plausible/balanced.

Im certainly not gonna be the person doing all that busywork though. Someone do that stuff, and ill judge it on its merits.

[Gamma Emerald]

Mechanically, needless to say the roleblocker is scum but I'm pretty sure the babysitter can be too

What utility is there for scum babysitter?

Let's say there's a town vig or an SK

If the scum babysitter can predict a scum player going to be killed by them, then they protect them.
If the scum babysitter is the one likely to be killed, then they target a town player and go 1 for 1



Their targets have been highly questionable so it makes sense with that logic

Look at the targets again though: hasn’t like 3 different people claimed protection? That means at least one of them is town right? Why would scum babysitter target town?
Pull your head out of your ass and think critically instead of assuming weird = scum.

[jjh927]

Oh also if Creature ever wants to check me out

I got 1 A in DIO, Evil Mastermind

And 3 As in role- 1 in deathproof, 2 in vote paralyzer

[jjh927]

Gamma don't you fucking dare tell me to think critically again when you're clearly lacking in that department by what you just said

[Nero Cain]

jj and think don't go together.

[Gamma Emerald]

Btw take care of your modding commitments ò_ó

[jjh927]

jj and think don't go together.

This is more scumposting okay but I'm not gonna get wound up

[Nero Cain]

Vecna, I don't think Pork ever claimed. Did you get a message when you targeted him?

[Nero Cain]

jj and think don't go together.

This is more scumposting okay but I'm not gonna get wound up

I mean, I asked you to engage me about why I was scum and so far you've failed to do so.