Mini 2039: uPicketyPicketyPick Mafia Endgame

[Nibbui]

@Gamma was NSG actively engaging Radiant on the hood?

[Elbirn]

[*] I can't die so I don't need to worry about getting nightkilled.

Feel free to ignore me if explaining is anti-town. How is this? RC claimed some things I didnt quite follow and if you could dumb it down for me like I'm 5 that could help me a LOT

Because while I see nothing in Maria's play that's scummy, I certainly see her trying to claim potential death proof as a CC to you being death proof, so that explains RC's scumread on her.

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: NSG
That was the dumbest night kill and seeing NSG try to take advantage of it right away speaks volumes.
People who were in RCs poe don't just kill RC to conf his said poe.(At least I wouldn't and I don't think people are dumb enough to do that) So it came from people not in said poe or enough scum outside it

I dont think it was the worst.

@NSG and Gamma: is this the post in question?

I dont know that I see this as AI. Why does scum make this post? How proud to you have to be to defend your own nightkill?

Yes

[Gamma Emerald]

@Gamma was NSG actively engaging Radiant on the hood?

Not really. RC suspected NSG for not posting much in the hood iirc

[northsidegal]

Feel free to ignore me if explaining is anti-town. How is this? RC claimed some things I didnt quite follow and if you could dumb it down for me like I'm 5 that could help me a LOT

I suppose I can be lynched (theoretically of course), but I can't be nightkilled (or, to my knowledge, targeted by anything at all during the night).

@Gamma was NSG actively engaging Radiant on the hood?

Not really. RC suspected NSG for not posting much in the hood iirc

i think this is a pretty bad characterization

the question isn't "was i active in the hood or not" because i was inactive for this game entirely for period of time (periods of time during which, i might add, there were times i posted in the hood and didn't post in the thread)

the question is was i talking to RC in the hood or not. and i mean, not to be rude, but i wasn't talking to you all that much in the hood – it was almost all with RC.

[Gamma Emerald]

Wait a second why do MariaR and NSG have the same utility

[MariaR]

hers is dif from mine.

[MariaR]

Talking about the nk. Maria what's your read on me

I don't really have a good read on you we know it's hard for us to read each other. I somewhat want to tr you given people have you in there poe for almost no reason. I have no real reason to tr you besides that though

[northsidegal]

Wait a second why do MariaR and NSG have the same utility

i'm only unkillable because of RC.

[Nibbui]

spicy, but Radiant said as well that people wouldn't be able to target NSG.

I can be wrong here but since you can't be night killed, it woudn't be anti-town to reveal a bit more of that role right?

It's a bit weird for a town role to be honest, but I only have a very low-resolution idea of it.

[MariaR]

VOTE: NSG
That was the dumbest night kill and seeing NSG try to take advantage of it right away speaks volumes.

People who were in RCs poe don't just kill RC to conf his said poe.(At least I wouldn't and I don't think people are dumb enough to do that) So it came from people not in said poe or enough scum outside it

Let's consider the last line here (I have things to say in response to the rest of the post, but I'll leave them for later).

I don't think what you're saying makes sense. Let's consider that scum are in RC's PoE. What's the best way to stop that from being pushed and silence someone who would push that PoE? Obviously it would be to kill the person who has it – the effects of someone being alive to actually push and talk about something are

far, far

more dangerous to scum than simply killing someone to "confirm" their PoE.

I think this is common sense and nearly indisputable: in basic mafia games like mountainous, a

lot

of scum's power comes from being able to silence the good townies or the people they don't want speaking. Far, far less people are inclined to consider a dead townie's reads than they are to consider the reads of someone alive and actively pushing something.


I mean, let's even consider the start of this day already: it's possible I'm overlooking something, but as far as I can remember I am the only person to independently bring up his reads, and any other discussion about it has simply been responding to me (don't mean to come off as arrogant or anything here or say i'm somehow better, just trying to prove a point). In fact, a lot of people have come in with reads that run directly

counter

to what RC's reads were – in practice, what you're saying has pretty much already been proven wrong.

I think the fact you're thinking about it so basically is the part that makes me dislike this so much but I'm leaning on this dislike being just that and not scummy.
Killing RC to conf his poe pool when anyone who knows RC knows he can flip his reads in an instant is just bad play. Also if his poe has scum outside it you should see why they kill him 100% of the time here. I can get your point somewhat on how killing RC makes it to get rid of the problem but you should be able to see how you're wrong at the same time. It goes both ways

[northsidegal]

spicy, but Radiant said as well that people wouldn't be able to target NSG.

I can be wrong here but since you can't be night killed, it woudn't be anti-town to reveal a bit more of that role right?

It's a bit weird for a town role to be honest, but I only have a very low-resolution idea of it.

it's not part of my role. there's no more information that i know that i can tell you other than i cannot be killed at night.

[Gamma Emerald]

hers is dif from mine.

Wait a second why do MariaR and NSG have the same utility

i'm only unkillable because of RC.

Well I’m stupid.

[MariaR]

So, you think I'm scum, Maria?

Eh

[MariaR]

VOTE: Chibi
I could do NK15 Nico too

[Nibbui]

But for example, he said that you couldn't be investigated for the rest of the game independent of him being alive or not NSG?

Is that due to Radiant or a third party as well? Or is that part of your own role?

[northsidegal]

i think it's just that rather than being bulletproof, it's something like i commute at night and just can't be targeted at all

[northsidegal]

VOTE: MariaR

[MariaR]

I would preach that I would never kill RC to high heaven if I was able but I stand by NKA being shit so I can't use that argument here weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee. (It's ironic because I proved the point of the nk being NAI)

[MariaR]

spicy, but Radiant said as well that people wouldn't be able to target NSG.

I can be wrong here but since you can't be night killed, it woudn't be anti-town to reveal a bit more of that role right?

It's a bit weird for a town role to be honest, but I only have a very low-resolution idea of it.

Why do you find hers weird but not mine.

[MariaR]

Also whoever tried to do that last night you're real cute.

[Nibbui]

Hmmm, I feel there's bussing going on here right now but I don't know who are the scum.

[Nibbui]

spicy, but Radiant said as well that people wouldn't be able to target NSG.

I can be wrong here but since you can't be night killed, it woudn't be anti-town to reveal a bit more of that role right?

It's a bit weird for a town role to be honest, but I only have a very low-resolution idea of it.

Why do you find hers weird but not mine.

because hers seemed to be a primary role, and added to the fact of being unkillable, RC said not even investigative roles could target her.

As a whole her role is pretty different from yours, and you seemed to need a PT to activate it as well.

[MariaR]

I'm salty that some peoples second effects seem super easy to unlock and mine is like.
Near impossible to do weeee

[MariaR]

Put me in a pt with nico or nk15 please ty