Spoiler: Cheeky's stubborn shallow Profii+DLA bromance case
In post 308, profii wrote:my approach to the game is that if we catch a scum somewhere, everyone will get excited and try and work out if that player was behaving in an unusual way in how they dealt with any given player, to try and make a case that there is a link between the 2 dudes, because that means we will catch the 2nd scum and win obviously.
So I am anticipating that scum will just ignore the otherscum for now, and consider lynching them later, reflecting upon the win cons:
I think Profii is offering WIFOM here. At this point he's backed into a corner and starts throwing random ideas out there. I'd be more inclined to believe he interacted with scum but didn't really push on them.
He pushed both Dunn and Wisdom as scummy and when the pressure mounted he starts talking about DLA but doesn't vote there. Which reminds me...
In post 65, profii wrote:Cheeky went: PP, Elbirn, Clem, DarkLightA (yotta late arrival)
Then I went: DarkLightA, PP, Wisdom
Gonna go PP
VOTE: PenguinPower
Scum are basically serial killers here, so logically going for people on both wagons as no real idea how to sort this game
I would just as easily go DLA tbh
I asked him why PP over DLA and he never responded. According to his reasoning DLA would've been a decent vote too. Then there's these weird interactions:
In post 76, profii wrote:No we should lynch the other scum first, do me later
Both scumplained:
In post 308, profii wrote:and the fact there is no night kill this means scum have to achieve 8 mislynches without getting caught - that's pretty tough!
In post 83, DarkLightA wrote:I may be missing something but it seems like over 2/3 chance town win, no?
My signature in 2018-2019:
Fun Fact: This is a fact. Burger king foot lettuce isn't.
Fun Fact: The above fact is a fact.
My thoughts on my signature in 2018-2019:
What in the world even is "Burger king foot lettuce"?
I know what Burger King is but what is foot lettuce?
Is it lettuce made out of feet? Geez, I'm so different than how I used to be.
My signature in 2018-2019:
Fun Fact: This is a fact. Burger king foot lettuce isn't.
Fun Fact: The above fact is a fact.
My thoughts on my signature in 2018-2019:
What in the world even is "Burger king foot lettuce"?
I know what Burger King is but what is foot lettuce?
Is it lettuce made out of feet? Geez, I'm so different than how I used to be.
Spoiler: Cheeky's stubborn shallow Profii+DLA bromance case
In post 308, profii wrote:my approach to the game is that if we catch a scum somewhere, everyone will get excited and try and work out if that player was behaving in an unusual way in how they dealt with any given player, to try and make a case that there is a link between the 2 dudes, because that means we will catch the 2nd scum and win obviously.
So I am anticipating that scum will just ignore the otherscum for now, and consider lynching them later, reflecting upon the win cons:
I think Profii is offering WIFOM here. At this point he's backed into a corner and starts throwing random ideas out there. I'd be more inclined to believe he interacted with scum but didn't really push on them.
He pushed both Dunn and Wisdom as scummy and when the pressure mounted he starts talking about DLA but doesn't vote there. Which reminds me...
In post 65, profii wrote:Cheeky went: PP, Elbirn, Clem, DarkLightA (yotta late arrival)
Then I went: DarkLightA, PP, Wisdom
Gonna go PP
VOTE: PenguinPower
Scum are basically serial killers here, so logically going for people on both wagons as no real idea how to sort this game
I would just as easily go DLA tbh
I asked him why PP over DLA and he never responded. According to his reasoning DLA would've been a decent vote too. Then there's these weird interactions:
In post 76, profii wrote:No we should lynch the other scum first, do me later
Both scumplained:
In post 308, profii wrote:and the fact there is no night kill this means scum have to achieve 8 mislynches without getting caught - that's pretty tough!
In post 83, DarkLightA wrote:I may be missing something but it seems like over 2/3 chance town win, no?
the role PM literally says "you know x is the other mafia and you have your pt here"
why would they have a pt by themselves anyway
they obviously share it, that's the point of the game
No it does not say that
Spoiler: Red Mafia goon
Welcome to Joint Operation Mafia you are a Red Mafia goon
Powers: You are aware that XXX is the Blue mafia goon and you have your own pt to talk in here besides that goodluck
In post 198, DarkLightA wrote:I actually noticed while reading the role PMs before that the links to the PTs are different. Even with this I assumed it was just a mistake and that one was used actively.
Do you guys buy this? Like who looks at the links?
In post 78, Dunnstral wrote:@Mod Are mafia required to submit their kill in their pt that they both share, or can they message you during the night?
This was the other post that feels like scum townslipping. I forget if I mentioned it before.
Why would you specify "pt that they both share"? Who says that?
It's like saying "I'm going to sell my car that I own" rather than "I'm going to sell my car"
You're all free to disagree but I think scum #2 would be on the wagon. This is why I think that...
- As scum I would feel pressured to look good or at least deter scrutiny by being on a correct wagon.
- There would be no reason to save my opponent. In fact I think it would be advantageous as there would be less of an associative trail.
I think Dunnstral, PP and maybe Wisdom are town, so that leaves DLA for me.
Ooo ninja'd
I actually don't like this post. It's taking basis in a "relatively" arbitrary measure of people on the wagon and using PoE, which is not exactly sound logic. Oh well, there's plenty of more scummy people.
My signature in 2018-2019:
Fun Fact: This is a fact. Burger king foot lettuce isn't.
Fun Fact: The above fact is a fact.
My thoughts on my signature in 2018-2019:
What in the world even is "Burger king foot lettuce"?
I know what Burger King is but what is foot lettuce?
Is it lettuce made out of feet? Geez, I'm so different than how I used to be.
