Newbie 1910: Aerial Photography [Game Over!]

[Junk]

VOTE: the_worst

[brassherald]

Junk has town slotted so many people...

[Junk]

I'm halfway through page 6 and I'm bored

I'll play tommorow again

Junk Nineja *
computerfan0 **
YyottaCat moonythedwarf **
GrandWazoo
YellowSnow JoeyG177
JunkoChan
GuiltyLion (SE) *
brassherald ceejayvinoya (SE) **
the worst (IC)

First guy is me - town
computerfan - good target to lynch
moony - town
GW - town
YellowSnow - town
JunkoChan - hmmm
GL - town
brassherald - I don't remember any of his posts, but now I do, he had a gnome avatar I think. His posts didn't give me any impression. Could that mean he's scum?
the_worst - i think scummy

[Junk]

Junk has town slotted so many people...

There are 7 town from 9 players, buddy

[Junk]

brassherald - I don't remember any of his posts, but now I do, he had a gnome avatar I think. His posts didn't give me any impression. Could that mean he's scum?

That was the other guy ceeejivbonnyoa or something

[Junk]

VC 1.09

votes

[4] GrandWazoo

:

computerfan0 87, brassherald 223, YyottaCat 256, JunkoChan 270

[2] Nineja

:

the worst 195, GrandWazoo 216

[1] YyottaCat

:

GuiltyLion 18

[1] computerfan0

:

YellowSnow 160

[1] Not Voting

:

Nineja 124

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch

The Day 1 deadline is in

: (expired on 2019-01-07 04:02:59)

Mod Notes

: Originally I didn't intend on this game having mostly coastal-themed aerial photos, but I liked how it looked so much that I've just been sticking with it. Hope you all enjoy!

Gulty Lion votes me

brasssomethingsomething guy also votes me

[brassherald]

If you only got to page 6, I haven't replaced in. And Rivers Cuomo is not a gnome.

[Junk]

So the votecount is

4 votes for me by : the worst, GW, GL, brassherald
3 votes for GW by: computerfan, yottacat (who are they?), junko (but they unvoted soon)
1 vote for computerfan by yellowsnow

[Junk]

Hmm okay I lied when I said I'm bored, I was curious and skimmed very little of some of the last pages

I saw Junko making big walls with colored text and stuff, and also GL townreading her

I'd say she might be townie (coupled with my townread on her annoyance at replacements)

So my pool for people I think are scummy is : (brassherald, computerfan, the_worst)

No reason to scumread brassherald, I'm just townreading everyone else

[brassherald]

Junk has town slotted so many people...

There are 7 town from 9 players, buddy

And no one is above suspicion. So, every one is scum in my book until they prove otherwise.

I don't trust this many town reads but I can't say its not just play that disagrees with mine.

But, like this catch up is so bad.

[Junk]

Junk has town slotted so many people...

There are 7 town from 9 players, buddy

And no one is above suspicion. So, every one is scum in my book until they prove otherwise.

I don't trust this many town reads but I can't say its not just play that disagrees with mine.

But, like this catch up is so bad.

What is bad about it

I disagree, I think that's your subjective opinion

And the OBJECTIVE truth is that: you are bad, buddy

[GrandWazoo]

Whoa. I need to go to the beach more often. Need to eat & process all that's happened.

[Junk]

Whoa. I need to go to the beach more often. Need to eat & process all that's happened.

You go to the beach during winter? Isn't it cold?

[brassherald]

Junk has town slotted so many people...

There are 7 town from 9 players, buddy

And no one is above suspicion. So, every one is scum in my book until they prove otherwise.

I don't trust this many town reads but I can't say its not just play that disagrees with mine.

But, like this catch up is so bad.

What is bad about it

I disagree, I think that's your subjective opinion

And the OBJECTIVE truth is that: you are bad, buddy

This reads like a homework assignment, you saw you had to find 7 townies and barely justify it, so that's what you did.

And you have read basically nothing from me, and you're attacking me?

No, this is a bad catch up, its either fake, or you really are deluded enough to think you can game solve day 1.

[Junk]

or you really are deluded enough to think you can game solve day 1.

Well that's pretty rude

You seem like an unpleasant person

[brassherald]

or you really are deluded enough to think you can game solve day 1.

Well that's pretty rude

You seem like an unpleasant person

You should hang out with my ex, she also didn't like when people say what they think.

[Junk]

No wonder she's your ex, buddy

[Junk]

But the point is

What does "solve the game on day 1" even mean, buddy?

I'm giving a read on every player

How does that translate to: "I, Junk, have solved the game day 1, and I'll never reevaluate my reads"

You think those two are the same thing, which is pretty weird buddy

[the worst]

the fact you just replaced in and like randomly decided people's alignments with no reasoning in a way which pushed the agenda you like...replaced into the thread with...has me like

[the worst]

i'm pretty sure that catchup doesn't come from town. either way like..lol, i'm happy with my vote here.

[Junk]

the fact you just replaced in and like randomly decided people's alignments with no reasoning in a way which pushed the agenda you like...replaced into the thread with...has me like

I didn't randomly decide people's alignments, I gave reads on all of them

" in a way which pushed the agenda you like...replaced into the thread with...has me like "

What agenda? Can you elaborate?

[Junk]

I think the_worst's last two posts are just ... the worst

You guys should vote him, he's scum

[the worst]

so i don't necessarily hate your reads but like

1) grandwazoo is towny. your reasoning for this is his first 3 posts are towny to you. you haven't really explained what's going through your mind here; just said you think they come from town. like his rvs post, requesting a vc and the thing about junko's join date are 1% towny at least but i preferred junko taking a stance that they were wolfy. these aren't AI factors yet you're happy to write grandwazoo off as town--this feels like you have TMI.

2) junko is scum until you catch up enough you realise she's not a viable mislynch; you then proceed to unvote her and define your read on her as "meh". this is more positioning than a genuine read fmpov.

3) you scumread me because... you do? you think i might be bussing junko who you no longer scumread? you think i'm aligned with computerfan? like there's virtually nothing on me in your ISO and yet you think i'm scum. this doesn't feel like someone pushing a scumcase against an active player who has scumcased their slot within the last couple of pages. (oh yeah spoiler: i scumcased nineja just before you rep'd in)

4) you think computerfan0 is scummy yet...have nothing to explain about it..

5) you write GuiltyLion off as town for literally no reason


like i know i'm missing things here but like. when i see a catchup i get excited in case it's town because town quite often show that they are working through a genuine process of solving; they second guess themselves, drop down exactly what they're thinking in case they agree/disagree with upcoming posts and in case anyone missed anything. sure, i don't expect a 100,000 word essay from someone who's new to the site. but something somewhat like this is instinct to a townie who needs to find scum and solve the game.

i'm not seeing like, literally any of this thought process from you. the closest thing to it is your trajectory on junko (going from pushing her as scum to nullreading her) but even this isn't town-indicative. it's been talked to death in the thread and i can see it coming from either alignment in a heartbeat.

[Junk]

1) There isnt much to say at GW's first 3 posta at start of game. I think his attitude is towny. His attitude kept staying the same throughout page 6 (where I left off)

2) This isnt really an opinion. This is an assumption (that im scum), you arent actually giving any opinion/read yourself

3) I think you're scummy because you are sitting back and not doing much. I'd expect the IC to be more active and forceful if they were a townie

4) There isnt much to say about computerfan's posts. But its not impossible to give a read on them. Moony also barely posted, but she was pretty towny. Computer's posts I find scummy and theres nothing much to expect

[Junk]

I dont think its scummy that I didnt explain why I think GuiltyLion is townie

I read his posts, and I thought he's townie, and I said so