Prey Mafia - Game Over

[Xtoxm]

VC 1.7

[2] Enter:

Persivul, BrightEyedFish

[2] redtea:

skitter30, Robert2424

[2] Robert2424:

Papa Zito, implosion

[1] skitter30:

minhyukwithagun

[1] Persivul:

Enter

[1] BrightEyedFish:

Chara

[4] Not Voting:

Almost50, redtea, Varsoon, mcqueen

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch

The Day 1 deadline is in

: (expired on 2019-02-01 18:00:00)

Mod Note:

No prods have been needed yet! Good work!

Spoiler:

[BrightEyedFish]

this early i find it good practice to attack most things that i see. but you're basically close to what i was thinking. it's too demonstrative of confidence and it looks like he's trying to project towniness without it feeling real. could be personality, could be scummy, but it's enough for me to press.
you do make a good point about it looking worse in ISO, but even in context it looks like baiting that lacks either a desire to understand Enter's position or to scumread it; it simply discredits it.

if this helps to add context, at the same time as these post, enter and I were in a somewhat RT discussion in our Neighborhood PT, all of a sudden he jumps to the game thread and votes me and then I follow up his vote with post 48.

[Enter]

Are we allowed to quote neighborhood?

I agree w/ chara right now. BEF responded weird.

[Xtoxm]

Are we allowed to quote neighborhood?

You are not allowed to quote from any PTs.

[Enter]

Are we allowed to quote neighborhood?

You are not allowed to quote from any PTs.

Aye.

BEF have you played scum before?

How comfortable do you feel playing scum?

[BrightEyedFish]

Are we allowed to quote neighborhood?

You are not allowed to quote from any PTs.

Aye.

BEF have you played scum before?

How comfortable do you feel playing scum?

go meta me if you want

[redtea]

You could still paraphrase, unless you feel it pointless.

[Chara]

i'd like to hear it in your own words, Fish.

[BrightEyedFish]

ok, here is my synapsis

Player X: Which of you is scum?

Me: Why must one of us be scum.

Enter: Hey, I found scum
(Proceeds to vote me in Game Thread)

Me: You really SR for that?

Enter: No, I will tunnel you for reactions.

Enter: Yay, chara agrees with me, I can die happy.

Remember this is a paraphrase.

[BrightEyedFish]

Also,
I wrote player X because I don't know if that player outed themselves about being the the neighborhood yet.

[Varsoon]

VOTE: Fish
Why would you be worried about a co-ordinated in-PT push that was fabricated solely for reactions?
If anything, it serves 2 purposes:
1. If scum really is in the PT, then they'd hear from their PT-mate and react in a 'proper' way
2. Town who had no clue would react in a genuine way

It seems like it could provide good info, maybe. Why would you oppose that?

[Persivul]

VOTE: Fish
this is more fun, actually. for 48 and the next three posts in his ISO.

What do you think of 50?

That post is IMO the key to the interaction, but I have additional insight from the hood.

[Persivul]

Why would you be worried about a co-ordinated in-PT push that was fabricated solely for reactions?

Where does Fish look worried?

[Varsoon]

Here.

ok, here is my synapsis

Player X: Which of you is scum?

Me: Why must one of us be scum.

Enter: Hey, I found scum
(Proceeds to vote me in Game Thread)

Me: You really SR for that?

Enter: No, I will tunnel you for reactions.

Enter: Yay, chara agrees with me, I can die happy.

Remember this is a paraphrase.

[Persivul]

If you were in the hood, you'd read that as fish kinda mocking enter, not fish worried about enter. I noted in hood that 66 shows that fish isn't worried about enter. You'd get it if you were in there. Enter's all like

I'm getting people riled up and they don't know how to react

, and we're like

No, that's not really happening

.

[Papa Zito]

As the neighborhood seems to serve little purpose, I suggest we simply don't use it so that there's no confusion about what's being said where.

[Enter]

If you were in the hood, you'd read that as fish kinda mocking enter, not fish worried about enter. I noted in hood that 66 shows that fish isn't worried about enter. You'd get it if you were in there. Enter's all like

I'm getting people riled up and they don't know how to react

, and we're like

No, that's not really happening

.

You and zito are the only two people who seem to think fish don't look worried.

[skitter30]

i think you might be scum here tbh

Tell me something new.

ok you know how sometimes i can jsut, like, tell that you're town? rn you're kinda doing the opposite. i'm getting like none of the townvibes, but a lot of the scumvibes.

==

i think redtea is kinda scummy tbh

==

VOTE: Fish
this is more fun, actually. for 48 and the next three posts in his ISO.

why are you pushing fish for this now, and not, say, when these posts actually happened and when enter was pushing him over them?

also i think 53 is kinda townie. i'm not really getting a projection of confidence, it feels kinda townie to me; i also don't really see baiting here

==

VOTE: Fish
Why would you be worried about a co-ordinated in-PT push that was fabricated solely for reactions?
If anything, it serves 2 purposes:
1. If scum really is in the PT, then they'd hear from their PT-mate and react in a 'proper' way
2. Town who had no clue would react in a genuine way

It seems like it could provide good info, maybe. Why would you oppose that?

i'm not entirely sure that bef, like, thinks about the game like this; he also doesn't really seem worried to me; more confused in like a nonchalant sort of way
i don't really like any of your not-votes tbh

==

You and zito are the only two people who seem to think fish don't look worried.

you can add me to this tally

[Chara]

i don't think Fish looks worried either.
as for why i didn't bring it up earlier: i didn't really take notice at the time, it came up on a reread.

[Persivul]

As the neighborhood seems to serve little purpose, I suggest we simply don't use it so that there's no confusion about what's being said where.

That's fine by me. This he said/she said is a pain.

[Persivul]

VOTE: minhyuk

[Chara]

VOTE: Fish
this is more fun, actually. for 48 and the next three posts in his ISO.

What do you think of 50?

That post is IMO the key to the interaction, but I have additional insight from the hood.

i'm assuming you find Enter scummy for it? it looks overeager, but i don't see the scumminess.

[skitter30]

i don't think Fish looks worried either.
as for why i didn't bring it up earlier: i didn't really take notice at the time, it came up on a reread.

ok what did you think of enter's push on fish as it was happening then

[Persivul]

i'm assuming you find Enter scummy for it? it looks overeager, but i don't see the scumminess.

No, the point is that I think it explains fish's posts to an extent. Enter's coming on like a bsd, and fish isn't having any of it.

In general scum don't start out like enter has, hence my change in vote. BUT, a bsd (or wannabe ) might, so I need to check his scum meta when I have time.

[Chara]

overeager, like the rest of his play.
if the softclaim ends up being nothing i'd be more amenable to Enter scum, but the way i'm reading it (and Persivul's description of the talk in hood) looks like Enter is trying to *do things* and it feels awkwardly town.

pedit: what's a bsd?