I did, it just didn't add up to me. If I'm scum and Salami is also scum, then why would he vote to lynch me? Why would he come in, "lay down the law" only to find that his scum partner was giving him a hard time?
It doesn't necessarily have to be me or him, I just don't see why it's me
In post 191, MaryJoLisa2 wrote:I think even if there's a mislynch, the remaining scum member performs a nightkill.
Yes, but the information we gather will all be based on hunches. I'm not really sure what the best course of action is.
Your logic is all over the place and makes no sense
I just don't feel that we have enough information to work with. A lynch (any lynch) would start to provide some context for what we've been saying and the cases we've been trying to build.
That's wrong though, while a lynch is usually preferable to no lynch for town they can be very harmful if chosen unwisely, we can't just pick
In post 208, Salami wrote:That's wrong though, while a lynch is usually preferable to no lynch for town they can be very harmful if chosen unwisely, we can't just pick any lynch. We have to figure out which is the scum
In post 191, MaryJoLisa2 wrote:I think even if there's a mislynch, the remaining scum member performs a nightkill.
Yes, but the information we gather will all be based on hunches. I'm not really sure what the best course of action is.
Your logic is all over the place and makes no sense
I just don't feel that we have enough information to work with. A lynch (any lynch) would start to provide some context for what we've been saying and the cases we've been trying to build.
That's wrong though, while a lynch is usually preferable to no lynch for town they can be very harmful if chosen unwisely, we can't just pick
any
lynch. We have to figure out which is the scum
Is this in the wiki or something? I don't know why you think this. If this is your second game ever, you should be feeling the game out like the rest of us. And if this is actually your second game ever and you're that intuitive and confident in your moves and those moves are correct, then you probably shouldn't be in a newbie game.
In post 207, MaryJoLisa2 wrote:I did, it just didn't add up to me. If I'm scum and Salami is also scum, then why would he vote to lynch me? Why would he come in, "lay down the law" only to find that his scum partner was giving him a hard time?
It doesn't necessarily have to be me or him, I just don't see why it's me and him.
My reads are based on how you have acted. It doesn't necessarily mean I think you and salami are scum partners, more that I think both of you are behaving scummily. It's slightly hard to explain.
Mafia sometimes vote their own buddies in order to distance themselves so if one is found the other isn't immediately scrutinised for defending and agreeing with them before.
I did, it just didn't add up to me. If I'm scum and Salami is also scum, then why would he vote to lynch me? Why would he come in, "lay down the law" only to find that his scum partner was giving him a hard time?
It doesn't necessarily have to be me or him, I just don't see why it's me
In post 191, MaryJoLisa2 wrote:I think even if there's a mislynch, the remaining scum member performs a nightkill.
Yes, but the information we gather will all be based on hunches. I'm not really sure what the best course of action is.
Your logic is all over the place and makes no sense
I just don't feel that we have enough information to work with. A lynch (any lynch) would start to provide some context for what we've been saying and the cases we've been trying to build.
That's wrong though, while a lynch is usually preferable to no lynch for town they can be very harmful if chosen unwisely, we can't just pick
any
lynch. We have to figure out which is the scum
Is this in the wiki or something? I don't know why you think this. If this is your second game ever, you should be feeling the game out like the rest of us. And if this is actually your second game ever and you're that intuitive and confident in your moves and those moves are correct, then you probably shouldn't be in a newbie game.
Yeah it's in the Wiki. I feeling the game out and changing my views as new information comes out. I trust my intuition but of course, it can be wrong like any other player. I'm a bit tired about my experience as my player being questioned so can you please drop it? This is my second game.
Imo, questioning people's experience doesn't get town anywhere unless they are using it to cover up mistakes e.g. "oops, i didn't mean it like that. I'm new so that's why i did it" and only then if their experience is suspect
