So, I want Lich lynched. I'm putting the vote back up and going to make my case.
VOTE: TemporalLich.
First, we have the obvious, confusing play and some odd wordings. Im not going to belabor this one, since it has been much discussed already.
Second, we have the continued waffling. This hasnt been hit as much.
115 says CatStar's the scummiest, and
117 explains as an active lurker. But
198 moves CatStar to a lean NAI without explanation -- CatStar's rate of posting hadn't increased (about 5% of posts 120-180; about 4% of posts 10-120, with about the same level of interaction).
Third, which is both related and to me most telling, I see no effort to solve at all. At no point does Lich investigate any of his suspects -- I dont see questions directed to CatStar or Skellen. It seems almost as if he knows their alignment, and is seeing what sticks. The lack of desire to solve -- investigate or justify his reads with specific reactions to specific posts just comes across as not towny.
Fourth, and the most compelling point for scum!good, is Birdy's
78. I saw this as a potential partnership play, of accelerating the wagon that was tied with Lich and hopefully redirecting attention to another slot.
Finally, I think we learn the most from flipping Lich. His near-lynch wagon (roomy-skellen-me-Urap-
Clem's intent
) would almost certainly contain one scum if he flips green. This information would force me to reevaluate the townblock I am willing to form to PoE this game with Roomy, Skellen, and URAP.
I conclude by reminding the board this is L-1