Mini Theme 2077 - Restless Spirits Mafia [ENDED]

[ConManMick]

You know what? I'm going on Clemency. I dislike RAS' out. I don't think comparisons to Nancy's exit are in good faith. I don't see anything in Clemency's posts that screams town. I see some filler posting (which you guys have a problem with from Titus) and I see a VERY convenient "oh I guess the lurkers are scum " list. And I don't like that this is being gotten away with.
VOTE: Clemency
PEDIT what

[ConManMick]

Also I'm willing to give the Clemency slot some time to post and such. RAS was doing a fair bit of flailing but I could see it coming from town too.

Clemency has had time to post. What do you say now?

[Montosh]

You know what? I'm going on Clemency. I dislike RAS' out. I don't think comparisons to Nancy's exit are in good faith. I don't see anything in Clemency's posts that screams town. I see some filler posting (which you guys have a problem with from Titus) and I see a VERY convenient "oh I guess the lurkers are scum " list. And I don't like that this is being gotten away with.
VOTE: Clemency
PEDIT what

I don't feel it's entirely the same though. Titus appears to be posting to appear active while saying comparatively little despite being in the game since it started. Clemency doesn't appear to be doing that. They just seem to be lurking more, and RAS was contributing in what I thought was good faith despite the way they exited later.

I honestly don't see them as being all that similar.

Also I'm willing to give the Clemency slot some time to post and such. RAS was doing a fair bit of flailing but I could see it coming from town too.

Clemency has had time to post. What do you say now?

I could see Clemency's lurking coming from town. I think lurking is scummy but I think Titus' active lurking is more scummy.

[Almost50]

If Ras is town, scum is probably in the people who voted Ras after I started posting.

Damn, I missed another chance of obv!scumming. Can we retake this scene, boss?

[Montosh]

As a follow up CMM. If it were just Clemency I might be voting with you here but RAS seemed towny in the way they were approaching the arguments to me. That makes me hesitate. I can't ignore my read on the previous player despite whoever currently occupies the slot.

[Elbirn]

Mastina do you have a reason for declaring RAS/Clemency "town as town can be" or what?

Reason implies singular. I have several, so it's plural.

That's splendid! Please share these reasons when you're feeling up to it.

[Nero Cain]

if Titus is scum I get credit for gut scum reading her 11

[ConManMick]

You know what? I'm going on Clemency. I dislike RAS' out. I don't think comparisons to Nancy's exit are in good faith. I don't see anything in Clemency's posts that screams town. I see some filler posting (which you guys have a problem with from Titus) and I see a VERY convenient "oh I guess the lurkers are scum " list. And I don't like that this is being gotten away with.
VOTE: Clemency
PEDIT what

I don't feel it's entirely the same though. Titus appears to be posting to appear active while saying comparatively little despite being in the game since it started. Clemency doesn't appear to be doing that. They just seem to be lurking more, and RAS was contributing in what I thought was good faith despite the way they exited later.

I honestly don't see them as being all that similar.

Also I'm willing to give the Clemency slot some time to post and such. RAS was doing a fair bit of flailing but I could see it coming from town too.

Clemency has had time to post. What do you say now?

I could see Clemency's lurking coming from town. I think lurking is scummy but I think Titus' active lurking is more scummy.

To be clear I'm not directly comparing them based on that trait. The point I'm trying to make is that if x behaviour is being called scummy in person a, why is it being ignored in b?

PEDIT: That's fair. Question above still stands, will take another look at RAS. I am concerned you're being very lenient though.
PEDIT EDIT I'm not sold on Titus scum

[Elbirn]

if Titus is scum I get credit for gut scum reading her 11

It was tonally awkward but I thought that was because she was trying to hint something to me. I have since put in 0 effort to deduce what that is.

[Montosh]

To be clear I'm not directly comparing them based on that trait. The point I'm trying to make is that if x behaviour is being called scummy in person a, why is it being ignored in b?

Because it's not x behaviour in both. I see active lurking as very different from lurking. It's lurking with the intent of appearing to look like you're not. I get a much stronger sense of active lurking from Titus.

[ConManMick]

Ok, consider this: is that just down to the timescale each has been in the game?

[Almost50]

I am ready to end the day.

Wait. What? We didn't even get the chance to fake claim

scum

masons together!

[Almost50]

@CMM: Since you're obviously on now and I'm still catching up.. did you post anything that's AI for you yet? If so.. can you point it out?

[Montosh]

Ok, consider this: is that just down to the timescale each has been in the game?

To some extent yes. Like I said if it was just Clemency in that slot the whole game I might vote with you right now. But my read on RAS still stands. I ISOed them in a previous post and came away with town vibes.

[Montosh]

@CMM: Since you're obviously on now and I'm still catching up.. did you post anything that's AI for you yet? If so.. can you point it out?

Also lol

[Elbirn]

I could see a scum being on the gamma wagon. I'd bet Titus or (less so) Elbirn if I had to.

Explain why you think me + gamma wagon = scummy plez

[ConManMick]

@CMM: Since you're obviously on now and I'm still catching up.. did you post anything that's AI for you yet? If so.. can you point it out?

Have you? All I'm seeing is "look guys I'm reading the thread, we're all pals Ecks dee"

[Almost50]

What if I said that by the end if page 12 I am thinking 2 scums are in LUV/CMM/Elbrin

[Flavor Leaf]

Ras was scummy independently of the replace out. Don’t vote him for the replace out.

[Almost50]

Say, who did skitter replace again?

[Montosh]

I could see a scum being on the gamma wagon. I'd bet Titus or (less so) Elbirn if I had to.

Explain why you think me + gamma wagon = scummy plez

For some reason I thought you were later on the wagon. I grouped you in there because I'm getting slight active lurking vibes, less so than Titus though. I wasn't a big fan of the gamma wagon overall since it seemed kinda clear that gamma just wasn't onsite at that point. The string of naked votes there felt off to me.

It's some gut feeling there. It's not super strong. I would ISO you more closely if I intended to vote you.

[Montosh]

Say, who did skitter replace again?

Go home A50, you're drunk

[Almost50]

OK.. NVM.. I should learn to READ THE NAMES rather than just glimpse at the avis.

[Montosh]

What if I said that by the end if page 12 I am thinking 2 scums are in LUV/CMM/Elbrin

Also, maybe/no/maybe

pedit: lol no worries

[Almost50]

So many lurkers and nonvoters

Said the

only

guy

not voting

at the time.