Detective Penguin & City of Fogport [Game Over]

[chennisden]

tbh from an objective standpoint im not most scummy/lynch target for next 3/4 days

i would put them on 3 other players over me

imo more scummy players than me are DOL, chenn and bingle

my scum read on pops has all but gone now

Why is this objective

[chennisden]

Dude Craog do you actually think u can get away with shitraeding me like this

[chennisden]

Alright, here's the deal:

I want each and every player here to state whether they would be willing to vote me today or not.

I'll keep the list public for ease:


[*]ofrhz
[*]PenguinPower
[*]Croag
[*]Pine
[*]Kagami
[*]Bingle
[*]Day One Lynch
[*]Vecna
[*]chennisden
[*]Marquis
[*]popsofctown
[*]Chandra Nalaar
[*]Flavor Leaf

no way

[chennisden]

i think kagami is a better lynch today

[chennisden]

Kgamai's iteractions wit croag are bad like in a way that could be kagami/croag but like kagami is more scummy

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

this inquisition of whether wed want to lynch you is actually improving my willingness to lynch you.

do something usefull instead of measuring hiw badly you need to work in a strong fakeclaim or whatever it is youre hoping to accomplish here.

Just bloody answer the bloody question and leave the "intentions and motivations" to me.

Note: What bloody fake claim? I am a bloody 1-shot Doctor of unknown sanity and there are 3 other players to confirm this to be a mod-confirmed fact in the PT opening post. Are you out of your mind??

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

NVM, I'll just put Vecna as a confirmed yes.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Alright, here's the deal:

I want each and every player here to state whether they would be willing to vote me today or not.

I'll keep the list public for ease:


[y?]ofrhz
[N]PenguinPower
[Y]Croag
[?]Pine
[?]Kagami
[Y]Bingle
[N]Day One Lynch
[Y]Vecna
[N]chennisden
[y?]Marquis
[N]popsofctown
[Y]Chandra Nalaar
[N]Flavor Leaf

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

In fact, I am also going to preemptively mark ofrhz as a yes. She's already voting me so there's no way she backtracks on this.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Alright, here's the deal:

I want each and every player here to state whether they would be willing to vote me today or not.

I'll keep the list public for ease:


[Y]ofrhz
[N]PenguinPower
[Y]Croag
[?]Pine
[?]Kagami
[Y]Bingle
[N]Day One Lynch
[Y]Vecna
[N]chennisden
[y?]Marquis
[N]popsofctown
[Y]Chandra Nalaar
[N]Flavor Leaf

[chennisden]

can we just fucking lynch scum please

[chennisden]

i do think croag would have the general unawareness to scumread me as scum so that doesnt make me tr her

the fact she's playing is a plus

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Fine by me

VOTE: kagami

[chennisden]

VOTE: kagami

[Bingle]

I don't hate that lynch and the wagon company is mostly sexy.

[Marquis]

jfc this wagon is fine but I want FL blood

[Marquis]

I think d1L is town genuinely trying to learn and figure things out

think the same of croag but more strongly

JJD is insufferable

if there's a deepwolf in my scumreads it's Vecna but he's still a better town pick than the others

I can now see Pine being scum it felt strangely like scum whining moreso than town whining. Like the kind you do when talking and bitching about the gamestate is your chosen form of relatable content. I do feel inactive scum would come in assuming it's a relatable thought that the gamestate is a mess when honestly I think we're all feeling pretty good about one scum being down and a pretty decent selection of likely town players. I also think putting a parity cop in a hood with two scum is such a fuckin Fakegod thing to do.

I want to rip FL's head off.

My best bets for town based on play and discussion and trying to discern motivations would be Chennis, Chandra, Croag, then D1L and Vecna. Or put Vecna at the top idk. Right now Vecna is making catch-up posts that kind of give me the vibe they're just for the sake of catch-up. I still think he's town. But I'm starting to think Bingle is getting to be a stronger townread. Oh yeah put Bingle somewhere there too. Oh wait I remembered hood discussion on Fish yeah Vecna is def town. I was going to lynch Fish today Vecna convinced me...

[Marquis]

my townlean on Croag is partially because I've felt their posts as very relatable and sounding like what I'd have said in their position (it kind of was what I said myself when inactive and getting run up),

I very much agree, Here's proof:

554 500+ posts in and "I didn't read shit". That's rich.
562 So you helped with the catch up. Can you also help me read the setup?
1503 1000 posts later: I am going to catch up. Why would I lie to you?
1557 I am not making a statement that could be used against me later. I love this fence.
1559 I am doing the same thing I did as scum but here I am not scum. Scouts honour.
1562 Am I outed yet?
1563 I will soft defend but leave the room open.
1568 Genuine responses are genuine. Right?
1570 I'm tired of this BS. Someone explain (but I am in the process of catching up, I promise)
1571 I have no idea so I'm just going to throw in an unsubstantiated guess with no reasoning at all.
1576 Can Mafia be in the same hood, so we can lynch them all once the first of them exposed?
1829 I am doing too much already, so let me quote myself.
1830 I won't repeat what I "didn't say". Take a wild guess.
1831 A stance. YAY! I know it goes against what I was preaching, but you should be grateful I voted.
1843 Read? Who does that?
1844 I can pull reads out of my arse. I just haven't done it yet.

Oh, GOD! I got both pissed and bored by the time I got to this point. Someone please pick up from there and help me demonstrate how relatable Croag's ISO is. Please and thank you.

croag's d2 posts were relatable to me because i was in the same situation and feeling the same way d1, I just had the luxury of a good claim post that dissolved the stupid lurker wagon on my slot.

if you are ever playing the game of mafia assuming town players are always playing perfectly or all playing at the same commitment level as you, you are playing the wrong game. that's what I want to say to you if you're town here.

like this was a total waste of your time my time everyone's time. 100+ words that only amount to an "ackshually" and it really pisses me off when people on this site speak with such a fucking condescending voice. get real.

[Flavor Leaf]

Im conf town

[Croag]

Yall we don’t lunch kagami here

[Vecna]

why not?

[Day One Wagon]

Yall we don’t lunch kagami here

You are free to propose different lynch, if you disagree, but you'll need some compelling arguments too

[popsofctown]

I'm kind of indifferent about Kagami. Some stuff he says seems a little townie, but in Starry Night he seemed even townier.

Also he was so townie in that game the mod told everyone he was town. It was very impressive.

[chennisden]

Yall we don’t lunch kagami here

Show work

[chennisden]

Kagami is saying a bunch of obvious things and then hinting at some little things prolly in an effort to stay alive because "ooh we can get info if we let him live" or something