Detective Penguin & City of Fogport [Game Over]

[Bingle]

Maybe it is Marquis/JJD and I've been wrong about Marquis this whole time.

Then you lynch Marquis FIRST and then we see, because -according to how the game went- chenn is the CPR Doctor and he DID NOT ACT ON N1.

Why would we lynch Marquis first when the only way he can be scum is WITH you?

[Flavor Leaf]

From this list, i honestly don’t think Croag is scum.

Why not?

Because when I replaced into Guns N Roses, Croag was as subtle as an elephant trying to catch up to run with the giraffes.

I’m seeing the same genuine town ness from her here.

And that’s how I picked up on Chennisden inno, which you guys confirmed I was correct about.

[Flavor Leaf]

Town never does that in this scenario because it’s game over.

No it's not. I dunno about game over, but it's certainly the correct town play here to sacrifice an effectively caffeinated VT slot for a Cop who can still act tonight (so will have to be shot still if Town). Unless if course he Naive and Craog is the scum Sane Doctor (which can't be the case because of chandra's flip)

So, I am willing to eat rope over EITHER Cops here. 100%

Neither of the cops can act. They already checked Chennis

[Flavor Leaf]

I’m also conf town because of my confirmed Gook kill, unless you legit think scum get multiple kills.

Which is a reason I don’t trust Marquis. Something’s fishy with his 2-shot Vig claim

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Marquis: 2 shot compulsive vig.

IF that claim is true then FL

must be

a 1-shot SCUM Vig. Why would the mod give Town 3 different Vigs, presumably with 4 shots collectively (I say presumably because it was never confirmed Pelican was 1-shot)

[PenguinPower]

Still don’t buy that completely btw.

And you just saying meta doesn’t really answer the question especially without a comparison that makes sense.

[Flavor Leaf]

Vecna, Marquis, Bingle, have you guys all full claimed?

Can we have one post that states exactly all three of your roles?

Bingle: Miller Quadvoter who loses a vote every day until he only has one.

Vecna:

Starts Caffeinated

Triplevoter who loses a vote every day until he only has one.

Marquis: 2 shot compulsive vig.

Collectively: Reflexively Roleblocking Vanillaizing Neighborizors who give this modifier to anyone who targets them.

AFAIK, that is the full claim of everyone in my hood. Vecna never actually retracted the obvious lie, but it was obvious, so...

Yeah, it’s just JJD/Marquis.

Marquis claimed 2 shot Compulsive Vig to save A50’s ass on the Fish Monger CPR doc kill, and now A50 is trying to make it seem like Chenn is the CPR doc.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Town never does that in this scenario because it’s game over.

No it's not. I dunno about game over, but it's certainly the correct town play here to sacrifice an effectively caffeinated VT slot for a Cop who can still act tonight (so will have to be shot still if Town). Unless if course he Naive and Craog is the scum Sane Doctor (which can't be the case because of chandra's flip)

So, I am willing to eat rope over EITHER Cops here. 100%

Neither of the cops can act. They already checked Chennis

Are you for real?? The bloody DOCTORS are 1-shot. The Cops are not!

[PenguinPower]

I’m also conf town because of my confirmed Gook kill, unless you legit think scum get multiple kills.

Which is a reason I don’t trust Marquis. Something’s fishy with his 2-shot Vig claim

I’m conf!town unless you think that scum also has a role that I think this other player could be.

What’s it like in your head?

[PenguinPower]

Town never does that in this scenario because it’s game over.

No it's not. I dunno about game over, but it's certainly the correct town play here to sacrifice an effectively caffeinated VT slot for a Cop who can still act tonight (so will have to be shot still if Town). Unless if course he Naive and Craog is the scum Sane Doctor (which can't be the case because of chandra's flip)

So, I am willing to eat rope over EITHER Cops here. 100%

Neither of the cops can act. They already checked Chennis

Are you for real?? The bloody DOCTORS are 1-shot. The Cops are not!

He has been making inaccurate statements for awhile now and when corrected he ignores it.

[Flavor Leaf]

Lol, also, only scum legit pushes 2 Vig claims as both Mafia.

[Bingle]

Oh, Marquis is a miller too.

We never did figure out why there are millers in the untargetable thread.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

@FL: Regardless of your alignment (right no you're like 99% scum to me) but you need to go eat a banana. You sure deserve/need that more than I do, mate.

[Flavor Leaf]

Still don’t buy that completely btw.

And you just saying meta doesn’t really answer the question especially without a comparison that makes sense.

Well, Croag’s Town. :shrug:

She hasn’t pushed a scum agenda at all really, and she’s been genuine.

[Vecna]

JJD and PP should be in a 1v1,

Yeah, if that's the case I'd vote myself 10 times out of 10. However, YOUm Sir are scum here.

And that’s why this is indirectly a scum slip.

Town never does that in this scenario because it’s game over.

I don’t think its even being considered lynching outside of you today, tbh, just trying to get all the pieces.

You keep saying this, but its 6v2 atm

Theres at least two town not caffeinated, so how is it over tomorrow?

Like I said, you keep either spreading false arguments, or you know more than you should.

[Flavor Leaf]

I’m also conf town because of my confirmed Gook kill, unless you legit think scum get multiple kills.

Which is a reason I don’t trust Marquis. Something’s fishy with his 2-shot Vig claim

I’m conf!town unless you think that scum also has a role that I think this other player could be.

What’s it like in your head?

Yeah, Im generally thinking you’re town here too

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Oh, Marquis is a miller too.

We never did figure out why there are millers in the untargetable thread.

THIS is one MAJOR reason why I don't trust you/Marquis and I'm POSITIVE one of you must be scum.

[chennisden]

Fl, the thing is, im not inclined to forgive you for your hammer given that you did the exact same thing during our scumgame in ank's (prematurely ended) mini theme.

[Flavor Leaf]

JJD and PP should be in a 1v1,

Yeah, if that's the case I'd vote myself 10 times out of 10. However, YOUm Sir are scum here.

And that’s why this is indirectly a scum slip.

Town never does that in this scenario because it’s game over.

I don’t think its even being considered lynching outside of you today, tbh, just trying to get all the pieces.

You keep saying this, but its 6v2 atm

Theres at least two town not caffeinated, so how is it over tomorrow?

Like I said, you keep either spreading false arguments, or you know more than you should.

End of tomorrow. If 2 scum live into tomorrow, it doesn’t really matter. They get two kills if there is scum in you, Bingle, Chennisden, so no matter what, if 2 scum go into tomorrow, scum win in that scenario.

It’s really protection against youScum mainly

[Flavor Leaf]

Which kind of bodes well that you don’t see it, but I’m next level, so it makes sense

[Flavor Leaf]

Fl, the thing is, im not inclined to forgive you for your hammer given that you did the exact same thing during our scumgame in ank's (prematurely ended) mini theme.

So?

That’s literally my thing dude.

I hammer when it gets to L-1 regardless of alignment.

There’s literally the FL catchphrase of

“did somebody say L-1?”

You’ve heard of RKO outta nowhere? This is FL outta nowhere.

I recently said this, but i forget where. Might not be able tot all about the game i said that in yet.

[chennisden]

But... from A50 pov i am confirmed to be CPR doc...

[Flavor Leaf]

But... from A50 pov i am confirmed to be CPR doc...

And you believe that 100%?

[Flavor Leaf]

Can you explain how it was discovered?

[Vecna]

Bingle, whats your profession?