Open 769: Venrob's PYP X/Y (Town Wins)

[Something_Smart]

@SS don't care for your shading here dude, I don't trust Kerset so I'm going to get a dialogue going. you can flick back to all of the questions I've gotten to try and gauge mindsets so far. This is one of the less odd ones. What's bugging you about it?

Jeez you don't need to get all prickly, I don't mean any ill will by it

It just seems odd to ask someone with a role that loses 100% of its utility once claimed why they didn't claim it before massclaim, when they weren't under any pressure.

[Wooper]

mhm I sure did

[Kerset]

SKITTERTIME

why did you go for commuter and why not claim it earlier kerset?

Watcher with only one shot has such low chance to reveal anything useful, that is just a particle of tracker power, who is not even the best investigator. On other hand, I was heavily townreaded on my previous games so i decided that ability to dodge kills will be handy for me. Previously nobody was interested in lynching me, which greatly raises chance of being NK during the game.
By earlier do you mean 2349 or earlier in the game? I live in EU and I was sleeping when adorable claimed.

[Wooper]

Preferably on page 1

[Something_Smart]

I'm not following you wooper

[Wooper]

it's ok, we're waiting for skitter to check in. fmpov commuter is a +scum equity pick over watcher so i guess i just want more out of kerset :s

[Wooper]

if concerned abt getting NK'd i'd have thought pgo would be a more intuitive pick and stuff
their explanation feels overexplainy

[skitter30]

i'm gunsmith
(my second pick was n2 vig)

n1 - aaron; has no gun
n2 - ss; no result

[skitter30]

If for whatever reason I am alive for the night aaron should investigate me

You'll either get a result on me or a flip on a controversial slot

um no

[skitter30]

(town) commuter should be claiming early imo
i'm not sure that town picks commuter in the first place either tho

[Luca Blight]

Conditional Commuter means limited in some respect, right?

If so maybe Kerset could go into more details about this, when they commuted etc.

[Luca Blight]

So Frost has no gun, does that mean he's clear?

[Luca Blight]

Unless Skitter/Frost happen to be partners.

[skitter30]

he didn't have a gun n1 and he's now claiming backup cop

i think if i'd have checked him last night he'd have showed up with a gun

as far as i'm aware, scum only don't show up as having a gun if they're also a doctor and i think that {aaron being maf doc who claimed backup turned cop} is probably not super likely?

[skitter30]

so basically yeah i think he's clear

that's why i wasn't really interested in him yesterday

[Luca Blight]

Yes, I know he'd have a gun now but that's irrelevant.

Frost was one of the first to claim, so from your perspective he should be conf-town pretty much.

[Luca Blight]

so basically yeah i think he's clear

that's why i wasn't really interested in him yesterday

Yes, I was curious on your Frost flip. Makes sense now, I guess.

[skitter30]

yep

[Luca Blight]

Something-Smart, over to you.

[Something_Smart]

i think if i'd have checked him last night he'd have showed up with a gun

Actually, no. It's not a normal gunsmith, it only detects killing abilities.

[Something_Smart]

Where was your crumb?

[skitter30]

huh, i could have sworn it got guilties on cops too

i dont' really do crumbs

[Luca Blight]

Doesn’t specify cops in the op though, looking back at it.

It’s risky not to crumb when if you were NK Frost could easily have been lynched the following day.

[skitter30]

i feel like it would have been obvious after i flipped given how i dropped the aaron read like a hot potato

[Luca Blight]

Anyway, SS, Let's have your claim, please.