Mainstream Mafia II: D&D Edition [FIN]

[Miss Lane]

I would like to point out that there is no

Q+

button on MafTiger, but I refuse to stop using it in protest.

Read G5’s post.
He states I said to G5 and G6 Interaction “Your both Town!”
As well as G6 and G4 Interaction “Your Both Town!”
And I wasn’t wrong on that.

I am, in fact, aware, that you town read most of the players that were not actively scum reading you. In addition, when either of those players was scum reading you, you were also scum reading them.

Your statement about being right on most of your town reads and wrong only on some of your scum reads is highly indicative of bad reads. Every player in the game of mafia will always be right on most of their town reads, because most of the game is town. By believing this is a symptom of good reads, you buy into a fallacy.

I really like those two as names.

Titus made some earlier posts that pinged me. I think Amrun was onto something, which I am shocked about.

You know Amrun and have played with her before?

[Nero Cain]

Whats a read haired elf

an elf with red hair, menas character

[EspressoPatronum]

Can u poison dave firewoofer?

P sure davesaz is town. Didn't you say he was null earlier?

[Firebringer]

You know Amrun and have played with her before?

no, I just had a really poor first impression of her in the beginning of this game and haven't yet shacked my initial impression of her.

[Menalque]

Whats a read haired elf
Vote Titus

It’s a me! Also the person who chem body guarded against the orcus kill last night

[pisskop]

maftiger is a real trip, but really dont use it. It'll put your eye out.

[Miss Lane]

You know Amrun and have played with her before?

no, I just had a really poor first impression of her in the beginning of this game and haven't yet shacked my initial impression of her.

Understand all.

[Menalque]

Can u poison dave firewoofer?

P sure davesaz is town. Didn't you say he was null earlier?

Idk maybe? But he moved up to a scumlean

[Cephrir]

@Fire if I had a vig right now here's where I'd be looking and why
It should be noted I am a conservative vig and only rarely attempt hero shots

03. Wooper- Duck is very capable, so where is he?
06. Iconeum- both useless and scummy
12. TrueSoulEnergy- to improve the quality of the game
18. Gamma Emerald- both useless and scummy
19. Pink Ball- claimed 3p, so why not?
21. Dr Easy Bake- honestly? i've only seen this person a couple times and i already think they should be policy vigged. they should also stop signing up for mafia games they have no intention of playing.
24. davesaz- possibly scum, though i am not good at reading this person
37. Flavor Leaf- this would be my hero shot

[Nero Cain]

if Dave is now a scumlean for you mena why wasn't he on your list?

I’d like to gate him to shoot within (vork, titus, TSE, wooper, kori, chenn, pine, zor)

[Firebringer]

@Fire if I had a vig right now here's where I'd be looking and why
It should be noted I am a conservative vig and only rarely attempt hero shots

03. Wooper- Duck is very capable, so where is he?
06. Iconeum- both useless and scummy
12. TrueSoulEnergy- to improve the quality of the game
18. Gamma Emerald- both useless and scummy
19. Pink Ball- claimed 3p, so why not?
21. Dr Easy Bake- honestly? i've only seen this person a couple times and i already think they should be policy vigged. they should also stop signing up for mafia games they have no intention of playing.
24. davesaz- possibly scum, though i am not good at reading this person
37. Flavor Leaf- this would be my hero shot

hmmm okay.

Do you think Titus is town?

[Menalque]

I would like it if we could not vig slots that will be replaced

[Menalque]

if Dave is now a scumlean for you mena why wasn't he on your list?

I’d like to gate him to shoot within (vork, titus, TSE, wooper, kori, chenn, pine, zor)

Bc I was trying to get a list that we could agree on and didn’t think he’d be agreed on?

[Cephrir]

@Fire if I had a vig right now here's where I'd be looking and why
It should be noted I am a conservative vig and only rarely attempt hero shots

03. Wooper- Duck is very capable, so where is he?
06. Iconeum- both useless and scummy
12. TrueSoulEnergy- to improve the quality of the game
18. Gamma Emerald- both useless and scummy
19. Pink Ball- claimed 3p, so why not?
21. Dr Easy Bake- honestly? i've only seen this person a couple times and i already think they should be policy vigged. they should also stop signing up for mafia games they have no intention of playing.
24. davesaz- possibly scum, though i am not good at reading this person
37. Flavor Leaf- this would be my hero shot

hmmm okay.

Do you think Titus is town?

Not especially, but I don't think she needs vigging on account of her being in the spotlight right now

If she slipped back under the radar I would consider it

[Nero Cain]

So you put a guy on your list that has a hider check on him but you wouldn't put a mainly inactive player on there, got it.

[Menalque]

So you put a guy on your list that has a hider check on him but you wouldn't put a mainly inactive player on there, got it.

I don’t know who the second person is but I think the first is zor?

[Menalque]

Jesus Christ Nero, I actually think you’re town so I’m trying to be patient with you but Christ it’s frustrating

[Nero Cain]

the one with a hider check is zor, the mainly inactive player is Dave.

[Nero Cain]

Jesus Christ Nero, I actually think you’re town so I’m trying to be patient with you but Christ it’s frustrating

Sorry? I don't really think you are that town and I'm not really sure why you are upset. I think it's a fair criticism to question why you have not mafia Zor on your list and not a guy that you had a scumlean on. If you want to argue that Zor and Ali are scum together then fine, that's fair. You say that you were trying to put out a vig list that everyone would agree with which is political and a play I could see scum making. I mean maybe I'm overly paranoid but I don't think this is something to get angry over. Also, you've pushed a false slip and run up a maybe town vig so rn I'm not overly impressed with your scumhunting.

[Menalque]

I’d forgotten that zor was the hider check, dave had been active but seemed to be picking up and also I’m p sure there were people TRing him so I didn’t think there would be consensus to have him in the vig pool

[Nero Cain]

Also, I think lynching/vigging scummy inactive players to improve the gamestate is a perfectly valid strategy

[Menalque]

I’m finding it frustrating because thinking I would intentionally put zor on my list with a hider check on him as mafia is just dumb. I’m not gonna just pop someone who’s got a check on them and then claim whoops as scum. Like it’s possible I forget as scum, but trying to make this out as scummy is weird. Obviously not a list that everyone would agree with but which would receive broad agreement. Of those who are active, in p sure that dave was being TR by at least some and I don’t feel strongly enough about it to fight to have him on the list, and also don’t think the vig list should be determined by any one individual person

I don’t see how pushing a maybe town vig is scum!indicative for me at all, and I haven’t pushed a false slip I’ve pointed out that it’s weird and then not pushed you over it

[Nero Cain]

I don’t see how pushing a maybe town vig is scum!indicative for me at al

I'm not saying it is but if he's town then both of the lynches you've championed for have been on town so at the very least you've been an ineffective scumhunter.

[Menalque]

Who’s the other lynch I championed? Drew? That was much more led by others, I just didn’t believe the PGO claim as it was always gonna be unverifiable

[Nero Cain]

eh ok