BooneyToonz UPick: Boon There, Done That [END]

[jjh927]

@Kakeguri: it is strongly my belief that alignment is not randomised prior to role creation, and that someone who wanted to be scum could influence role allocation by picking scum only roles for the Booneytoonz list, or quotes from players from games where they were scum, etc.

Your strong belief is wrong. Undivulged non-randomness is bastard. Alignment is assumed to be randomised.

Upicks are inherently non random.

UPick ROLES are inherently non-random, but this does not include alignment

[jjh927]

hi nomnom
from what ive seen i like your playstyle, im excited to play with you
VOTE: krazy

Cool

Krazy Katz is hard town already

It's page 4
Meta shit will be unreliable and confbiasy at best and you're both wrong for voting each other. We don't even know it's Krazy

Looks like Vecna can be town too

@JJH odds of everyone posting on page5 being town?

Actually pretty reasonable

I'm town
You're town
Auro is looking nice and towny
Chronos could go either way considering this is a regular reaction that people have when they play with me for the first time
And then Nom posted after you said it, and Nom is town too even if they are wrong

Actually, I do think the stances JJH are taking a little too confident.

VOTE: JJH

Could you explain your Vecna and Nomo townreads me for me please, JJH? You will be rewarded with many galaxies and my personally favourite asteroid.

-Cosmic

Nom's thought process is clear and believable. Vecna is also evidently thinking things through, and I believe I first started townreading him after he pointed part of something I'd noticed out regarding KK.

[The Fonz]

@Kakeguri: it is strongly my belief that alignment is not randomised prior to role creation, and that someone who wanted to be scum could influence role allocation by picking scum only roles for the Booneytoonz list, or quotes from players from games where they were scum, etc.

Your strong belief is wrong. Undivulged non-randomness is bastard. Alignment is assumed to be randomised.

Upicks are inherently non random.

UPick ROLES are inherently non-random, but this does not include alignment

What happens if someone picks Traitor, Framer, SK as their picks? How can they possibly end up town?

[jjh927]

What's interesting it that nobody has ever given a shit about me explaining things in detail before. Because it's kinda dumb to think town!me isn't gonna give a full explanation for something when there os one and there's someone asking for an explanation, and there's no downside to me explaining it. I'd like those who think that post I made was weird to read it with context and explain why they think it's weird outside of this idea that I can explain my thought process.

Dave has played with me before. He doesn't get a free pass.
VOTE: davesaz

[jjh927]

What happens if someone picks Traitor, Framer, SK as their picks? How can they possibly end up town?

You design roles creatively. Personally I try to avoid making the extremely obvious roles out of picks, so if people picked actual mafia roles in a upick there is 0 chance of them getting exactly them regardless of what they rand.

I could design a town role based on any one of those 3 things as flavour.

[Vecna]

If he was scum who could "cancerously millerize" town and neuter cops, why even claim it?

Although this is not a great argument, my spreading virus does in fact not tell the infected people what it does. Just that they have to spread it.

[Vecna]

Vecna is your millerizing flavored as cursing?

Its probably a mistake to say this since there might be some role that benefits from knowing it, but its a virus

[Vecna]

Anyways, the two people I chose will get notified they recieved a virus. They can then also confirm theyre not actually informed what it does, and that they have to spread it.

[Xtoxm]

is there anything in your role description that suggests it may be desired for you to infect specific roles/players, or is it just an indiscriminate compulsive millerizer?

[Xtoxm]

@Kakeguri: it is strongly my belief that alignment is not randomised prior to role creation, and that someone who wanted to be scum could influence role allocation by picking scum only roles for the Booneytoonz list, or quotes from players from games where they were scum, etc.

Your strong belief is wrong. Undivulged non-randomness is bastard. Alignment is assumed to be randomised.

Upicks are inherently non random.

incorrect; standard procedure is to randomize align before making roles

@Kakeguri: it is strongly my belief that alignment is not randomised prior to role creation, and that someone who wanted to be scum could influence role allocation by picking scum only roles for the Booneytoonz list, or quotes from players from games where they were scum, etc.

Your strong belief is wrong. Undivulged non-randomness is bastard. Alignment is assumed to be randomised.

Upicks are inherently non random.

UPick ROLES are inherently non-random, but this does not include alignment

What happens if someone picks Traitor, Framer, SK as their picks? How can they possibly end up town?

with a little thought above level 1. sk could be vig, etc.
boon certainly got creative my my pick
i didnt get what i was "aiming" for

[BooneyToonzExpert]

well, unless you decide to lynch me d1 ofcourse. Which might prevent like, a global pandemic.

But itll make the game a lot more boring.

Yep.

Yep

Shouldn't we want to prevent a "global pandemic"?

[BooneyToonzExpert]

is there anything in your role description that suggests it may be desired for you to infect specific roles/players, or is it just an indiscriminate compulsive millerizer?

I also think it might be a spin on the sticky fruit vendor BT role with the "pass it along" aspect. Also, does the effect last for the entire game or just the night they catch the virus.

[Vecna]

I dno Booney, would you prefer to have a guaranteed mislynch over just handling it smartly?

Having two extra millers on designated persons aint that big of a deal most likely.

Regardless, this topic is already starting to bore me. If you wanna lynch me, convince people im scum

[Vecna]

VOTE: Xtoxm

[BooneyToonzExpert]

I dno Booney, would you prefer to have a guaranteed mislynch over just handling it smartly?

Having two extra millers on designated persons aint that big of a deal most likely.

Regardless, this topic is already starting to bore me. If you wanna lynch me, convince people im scum

I don't wish to lynch you, Vecna. I just want to make sure I understand your role.

[Titus]

@Vecna/chkflip chkflip said he couldn't let Vecna's role live but then doesn't vote Vecna. Vecna doesn't comment on it. What the? It's an odd interaction.

[chkflip]

Blatant misrep,

lawyer

. Try again.

[Titus]

I'm not comfortable with letting Vecna live. Who knows what that virus actually does, hm? "It makes you a miller" smells like bullshit to me. Boon doesn't throw millers all over the place for the lulz. There's a reason for it, which has been "hinted" to Vecna, but it seems like he knows more about it than he's letting on. But that's just a hunch. We'll see where it goes.

True or false is your vote on Vecna on or after this comment?

[Chronos]

As your appointed lawyer, I suggest you plead the fifth on that one Mr Flip.

[Auro]

VOTE: Titus

[chkflip]

You said I said I couldn't let him live.

That isn't what I said, sunshine. That's called misrepresentation.

[Titus]

I'll let the words speak for themselves. If the collective says I am wrongfully interpreting not comfortable with Vecna living as Vecna can live, I'll live with the fallacy they present.

Chronos, why did you appoint yourself Flip's laywer?

[Auro]

I'm not comfortable with letting Vecna live. -snip-

But that's just a hunch. We'll see where it goes.

Context.
Also, do you actually expect people to constantly be voting their latest stated scumread?

[chkflip]

She's doing in her post what I did in mine.

>_>
<_<

[Titus]

I'm not comfortable with letting Vecna live. -snip-

But that's just a hunch. We'll see where it goes.

Context.
Also, do you actually expect people to constantly be voting their latest stated scumread?

There's a difference between latest scumread and I don't want it to live.