BooneyToonz UPick: Boon There, Done That [END]

[Krazy Katz]

Dave being much lazier than usual is damaging my read of him but I don't know if it makes him scum

[Krazy Katz]

VOTE: jjh

I think amrun's early game hot takes have all been right so far so I guess I can try this and see how much combo power her rvs reads hold

-K

[davesaz]

Dave being much lazier than usual

This is more than baffling to me. What exactly is lazy about trying to have conversations with almost everyone who is posting?

[chkflip]

We've just had 2-3 pages of activity, wtf is this?

Please tell me what you think BTE is trying to do that's so good.

Compare today's activity with the last two phases and you'll clearly see what I'm talking about.

I'm obviously questioning my reads and BTE is using wagon analysis to move the game forward.

It's pretty cut and dry, bud.

[Krazy Katz]

I mean more you seem inattentive. There's been like two or three times where you've missed like bef outing his main, asking one or two other kinda basic questions that could get answered by rereading

so not lazy but like, missing some things that I'd expect you to notice

[Krazy Katz]

Titus's reaction to nom's guilty might suggest bte/titus not same pt, if bte is not town I'd expect traitor/3p rather than groupscum

-K

[davesaz]

another reason to mc and get the ball rolling on a mech solve

No, you don't MC until

after

a bunch of actions. MC prematurely allows scum to prepare answers that they shouldn't have, or sidestep actions. And I wouldn't put the chances high of having even a single vanilla player. There may be significant gates like non-consecutive, even/odd, or blockers like the sticky fruit, but I'd bet every single one of us has some form of action.

[davesaz]

I mean more you seem inattentive. There's been like two or three times where you've missed like bef outing his main, asking one or two other kinda basic questions that could get answered by rereading

so not lazy but like, missing some things that I'd expect you to notice

The "who is BEF" bit? I prefer people to be referred to by the name they're playing the game by. You can look at a few of my very early games on site if you want evidence.

[davesaz]

BTE is using wagon analysis to move the game forward

If the so-called wagon analysis gives answers that are implausible, it's rubbish.
That might just be me being offended that missing a wagon I've clearly said I'm willing to join puts me in a POE.

[davesaz]

I'm waiting on a VC, and

perhaps get a bit more agreement on how to handle the SF.

Read between the lines.

[davesaz]

@chk, what's with the bud thing btw. Haven't been rude to anyone today so I'm your chance?

[Krazy Katz]

Actually, it is kind of concerning how everyone is ok with RCE getting lynched while he isn’t even here.

Got a question for you -- who started the RCE wagon and why?

I guess I didn't like the question because I think I started the RCE wagon mostly because he was lowest in PoE when I was thinking about the game at that moment and no one has really disagreed or towncased him. Actually I'm more willing to move off rereading Mechanic's three posts than RCE.

I could really use a recap of everyone who has received the virus.

This also was kinda ?? since it's just me and chk and we both confirmed it couldn't be sent on since otherwise I would have sent it to chk last night

Actually not that many bad questions and you can easily be town, just hard to really feel confident in reading you as town if that makes sense

-K

[chkflip]

Didn't realize I'd said it more than once. Sorry, chief.

[sore feet]

another reason to mc and get the ball rolling on a mech solve

No, you don't MC until

after

a bunch of actions. MC prematurely allows scum to prepare answers that they shouldn't have, or sidestep actions. And I wouldn't put the chances high of having even a single vanilla player. There may be significant gates like non-consecutive, even/odd, or blockers like the sticky fruit, but I'd bet every single one of us has some form of action.

disagree completely, early mc is underrated. and we DO have 2 nights of actions.
theres value in locking scum to claims early. and we already have a whole bunch of claims/partial claims. allowing scum to drift through and be last to claim after viewing all the info is the worst possible scenario.
and yeah - currently most people are pissing in the dark without a good idea where to put it.

[davesaz]

Titus's reaction to nom's guilty might suggest bte/titus not same pt, if bte is not town I'd expect traitor/3p rather than groupscum

-K

This is the kind of dense writing thing that causes me in trouble in my technical writing sometimes in RL.
I'll break it down to see if my interpretation is right.

If Titus and BTE were groupscum together, Titus should know that a SF is coming, and therefore be better prepared to handle a guilty by saying right up front "nuh huh, SF so you're lying". Since Titus didn't seem to be prepared to handle the guilty with a SF argument, she presumably didn't know that there was SF, therefore BTE can't be groupscum.

There is an inherent assumption here, that BTE is telling the truth that SF go to everyone. We're also making an assumption that barbs crumbling mean that SF is disabled, where in fact the people saying that may never have been targeted with a SF at all.

I think I agree that the interaction points to BTE town or 3p more than scum, and you did say suggest, so I think it boils down to the same conclusion.

[Conspire]

Actually, it is kind of concerning how everyone is ok with RCE getting lynched while he isn’t even here.

Got a question for you -- who started the RCE wagon and why?

Not sure if this is a rhetorical question but I’ll answer anyway

It was pretty obviously me. And I voted RCE because I don’t remember seeing anything townie from him. I feel like he’s playing like Titus where he’s there and kind of giving opinions, but not really

~Esper

[davesaz]

I guess I didn't like the question because I think I started the RCE wagon

Check the previous VC.

[Krazy Katz]

I think there should be at least one in rce, fonz, and dave. VOTE: rceB

-k

Boon missed 3496

[Conspire]

Yeah we understand Nancy, have you talked with Shiro to carry for a while?

-K

Yeah, he promised he would but that’s on Shiro time . . . so . . .

I will it is just day 1 are never my strong point.

Cookie please?

See, get Shiro. Thread is in Greek.

@Auro, Nancy Shiro and I go way back. Like years.

@Shiro, I need a cookie.

@Titus: Do you think their townread of you for that post is legitimate, then?

I think so. I wouldn't lock town them but they're one of my strongest TRs. They tend to know how I think. The biggest concern is Shiro's lack of cookie posting. I hard town Nancy, lean town Shiro.

@Titus: Do you think their townread of you for that post is legitimate, then?

I think so. I wouldn't lock town them but they're one of my strongest TRs. They tend to know how I think.

The biggest concern is Shiro's lack of cookie posting

. I hard town Nancy, lean town Shiro.

Is Shiro known to low post as scum or what does -bolded- mean?

Basically even when Shiro low posts, I expect a Cookie gif. It goes back to our cookie hydra.

This feels like Titus pocketing Shiro tbh

-K

@KK 3741: Ok I agree. Even without this though, I was thinking Titus was pocketing VM because of their townlocking of each other D1. Scum probably don’t act like that.

[Krazy Katz]

I’m pretty sure barbs just cancel out fruit and then crumble based on what people said yesterday. KK’s no result I’m slightly suspicious about but I guess roleblock could be an explanation. My bad on the macho thing since i reread Titus’ role and it never said *at night*

I had Chronos as townie from their VM/Titus interaction ages ago and with Titus!scum, that still seems fine. My strongest SRs are RCE/George. Don’t remember either of them being townie

VOTE: RCE

@BTE, were you aware you had to send out sticky fruit to everyone N1? If so why would you stay silent on it?

yeah my vote was first so I should have been the front of the wagon, the vc was actually inaccurate

[Conspire]

Huh ok.

Anyway I don’t think I’ve put enough effort into this game so I’ll read through some ISO’s later.

People I’m willing to write off for now:
chkflip/chronos/VM/fonz/George/Dave/KK

~Esper

[Conspire]

Also I don’t think massclaim would *solve* anything today. Not a good idea imo?

~Esper

[davesaz]

I think there should be at least one in rce, fonz, and dave. VOTE: rceB

-k

Boon missed 3496

Thanks for pointing this out.

[davesaz]

mostly because he was lowest in PoE when I was thinking about the game at that moment and no one has really disagreed or towncased him.

So, um, you had

me

in your poe? Not the really strong kind of poe I'd expect from either head...

[Krazy Katz]

I mean I had you in the 'higher' poe pretty much right before you were nk'd in the shakespeare game

I haven't played vs your scum iirc so it's hard to say I have a really strong grip of your range

So yeah you're kinda in poe and some of your posts like 3707 I was not a big fan of

maybe you're town and george is scum, but maybe it's good for you to know that the way you're pushing him rn makes my read of you degrade more than it does for him if that makes sense

Anyway, I'm not pushing you rn really. Has your read of jjh changed at all much recently?

-K