BooneyToonz UPick: Boon There, Done That [END]

[Auro]

Pagetop!

[Auro]

Shiro is aware the game began right? Like even if nancy is taking a break the slot should not be silent?

Boon PM'd you along with the hydra acc?

[Nancy Drew 39]

ego

[GeorgeBailey]

a presumably policy vote on TSE

That was actually my RVS. I kinda know the guy so I wanted some sort of reaction from him. I switched after nothing really happened with him.

followed by a vote on someone who's not here

Ye, what's wrong with voting people who havent even posted yet? I like to sort people after everyone has atleast posted a few times.

[Venus and Mars]

Fyi Xtoxm, my best friend just died, so I’m way too numb to be really into to mafia rn. I will try my best regardless.

~Mars

[Krazy Katz]

Shiro is aware the game began right? Like even if nancy is taking a break the slot should not be silent?

Boon PM'd you along with the hydra acc?

You know he actually did even though I never explicitly said it was me even though I mean yeah probably safe bet

-K

[Venus and Mars]

Shiro is aware the game began right? Like even if nancy is taking a break the slot should not be silent?

-K

Have you forgotten MG already? Fyi, I think you might be town but this is bad reasoning on your part.

~M

[Krazy Katz]

Yeah we understand Nancy, have you talked with Shiro to carry for a while?

-K

[Krazy Katz]

Shiro is aware the game began right? Like even if nancy is taking a break the slot should not be silent?

-K

Have you forgotten MG already? Fyi, I think you might be town but this is bad reasoning on your part.

~M

"Where is shiro" isn't really reasoning it's more a question

-K

[Venus and Mars]

a presumably policy vote on TSE

That was actually my RVS. I kinda know the guy so I wanted some sort of reaction from him. I switched after nothing really happened with him.

followed by a vote on someone who's not here

Ye, what's wrong with voting people who havent even posted yet? I like to sort people after everyone has atleast posted a few times.

It’s only problematic if it’s a serious vote because unless you have actual meta on a player that’s AI, it’s probably NAI. However, I nai read that vote.

~M

[Venus and Mars]

Yeah we understand Nancy, have you talked with Shiro to carry for a while?

-K

Yeah, he promised he would but that’s on Shiro time . . . so . . .

[Venus and Mars]

It's D1 page 10 ffs. Fine.

Tonally, I'm comfortable enough with Fonz and dave to properly pin them as town. I'll be able to actually sort Titus when she really gets into it. I haven't played with the rest of you (that I can recall?) so that won't come as swiftly.

It should've been pretty clear that I was full of shit when I cited you, Auro, as the champion for my sheep vote when you hopped not 5 posts later. But hey, ass out of you and me for assuming, right?

I'm not comfortable with letting Vecna live. Who knows what that virus actually does, hm? "It makes you a miller" smells like bullshit to me. Boon doesn't throw millers all over the place for the lulz. There's a reason for it, which has been "hinted" to Vecna, but it seems like he knows more about it than he's letting on. But that's just a hunch. We'll see where it goes.

Auro, you seem like one of those types where townies better town post or else!!1! And I'm sorry but I don't have the time, energy, or give a fuck to wall until a sufficient amount of people think I town slipped. Did that last game and Nancy fucking bombed me for it.

Never again.

This is my one and only long post.

I bombed you because you kept insisting on derailing my questioning over Bambi’s unexplained no results thing and you were ironically defending scum in that, so if you don’t want negative consequences, I recommend you don’t do that in the future.

[Venus and Mars]

So far, I like KK, Auro and Nom.

~M

[The Fonz]

a presumably policy vote on TSE

That was actually my RVS. I kinda know the guy so I wanted some sort of reaction from him. I switched after nothing really happened with him.

followed by a vote on someone who's not here

Ye, what's wrong with voting people who havent even posted yet? I like to sort people after everyone has atleast posted a few times.

It's low effort and unlikely to move the game forward. It means you're not picking up on anything happening in thread, which can speak to lack of town motive. *Shrug* I don't really see scum anywhere else yet, mostly people throwing their (presumably) usual playstyles at each other in a way that seems largely boring and NAI to me.

[Vecna]

Thats an odd post Fonz. Youre harping on George for not picking up on anything in the thread, yet he's your only scumread? And you dont see anything elsewhere yourself?

How can he pick up on anything if he's the only one doing anything noteworthy scummy according to you? You want him to scumread himself?

[Venus and Mars]

He has zero base on that. It's just a thing he said. Fonz is fun like that. The Nacho quote was from a game I didn't counterclaim his doc claim until the next day when the cop cleared me and guiltied his partner. I was railing into him pretty hard that phase. To his credit he almost got a newb to side with him.

VOTE: Kakeguri Addicts

Sheeping the og vote on this wag.

I don't have zero base. I have not much base, what with it being page one and all, and don't get me wrong it was a fun vote coming from a place of love.

But after the last BT, plus your behaviour in that dead thread, I absolutely do not believe you want to be town in a game with Titus and Nancy (and TSE, though he wasn't there) if you have the chance to influence things otherwise. So I do think you are more likely than random to have made picks that are scum-only or often scum.

Sorry, bro. Guess you better catch scum early if you're town.

Sorry, bro.

@chk, serious question, why did you decide to play despite Titus and myself playing? Are you no longer pissed off at us? @Fonz, just because he was rooting for RCE, doesn’t necessarily follow he’d automatically select a scum role/flavour.

[Venus and Mars]

@jjh, refresh my memory, what alignment did you roll in RC uPick?

Thanks.

~M

[Venus and Mars]

hi nomnom
from what ive seen i like your playstyle, im excited to play with you
VOTE: krazy

Cool

Krazy Katz is hard town already

While I think you might be right about KK, nothing specifically in that post exactly screams “hard town” to me. Why couldn’t scum have made that post?

~M

[Venus and Mars]

hi nomnom
from what ive seen i like your playstyle, im excited to play with you
VOTE: krazy

Cool

Krazy Katz is hard town already

While I think you might be right about KK, nothing specifically in that post exactly screams “hard town” to me. Why couldn’t scum have made that post?

~M

Wait, Xtoxm made that post NOT KK. Are you sr Xtoxm, is that the basis for your hardtown read on KK?

~M

[The Fonz]

Thats an odd post Fonz. Youre harping on George for not picking up on anything in the thread, yet he's your only scumread? And you dont see anything elsewhere yourself?

Eh, if his vote had been premised on everyone else being null at worst, that would be fine, that would be a stance he'd taken. I've done "Most of the active players seem like town with theory disagreement and egos, I suspect a high concentration of lurking scum" before. A naked vote on an inactive is basically the least useful thing a town player can do, so it speaks to a potential lack of town motive. He's also not participated in any form of mech chat.

How can he pick up on anything if he's the only one doing anything noteworthy scummy according to you? You want him to scumread himself?

This is silly. There's conversation happening, I'm just getting a mixture of NAI and weak town vibes off of it. In that scenario, I vote for someone not doing much. This is also why I'm not actively defending the couple votes on me - as it happens, I'm struggling to get into the game, but "just struggling to get into the game" is a thing that is exhibited by scum >random.

[Venus and Mars]

i only sent in one pick, and it was from a time i was scum

Why would you do that? Were you hoping you’d be scum in this game?

~M

[Venus and Mars]

Hello folks

~Shiro

[Venus and Mars]

@Kakeguri: it is strongly my belief that alignment is not randomised prior to role creation, and that someone who wanted to be scum could influence role allocation by picking scum only roles for the Booneytoonz list, or quotes from players from games where they were scum, etc.

Your strong belief is wrong. Undivulged non-randomness is bastard. Alignment is assumed to be randomised.

Upicks are inherently non random.

incorrect; standard procedure is to randomize align before making roles

@Kakeguri: it is strongly my belief that alignment is not randomised prior to role creation, and that someone who wanted to be scum could influence role allocation by picking scum only roles for the Booneytoonz list, or quotes from players from games where they were scum, etc.

Your strong belief is wrong. Undivulged non-randomness is bastard. Alignment is assumed to be randomised.

Upicks are inherently non random.

UPick ROLES are inherently non-random, but this does not include alignment

What happens if someone picks Traitor, Framer, SK as their picks? How can they possibly end up town?

with a little thought above level 1. sk could be vig, etc.
boon certainly got creative my my pick
i didnt get what i was "aiming" for

Interesting, I got the exact role and flavour I wanted, even the specific flavour name.

~M

[Venus and Mars]

VOTE: Xtoxm

Bad reasons for votes, excessive reliance on mech talk and doesn’t really appear to be solving.

~M

[Venus and Mars]

Yeah we understand Nancy, have you talked with Shiro to carry for a while?

-K

Yeah, he promised he would but that’s on Shiro time . . . so . . .

I will it is just day 1 are never my strong point.