SIR Disease Mafia - Game Over!

[Quick]

Tin foil or Scum? I don't get this question at all.

? What do you mean? It looks to me like Creature only posted once he was called out that he needed to be prodded, but it was so quick it was like he'd been reading along with the thread and just not posting. What else is there to get?

I wasn't disagreeing with what you posted, but instead, your tone because you made a very fast post almost word salad to say the same thing.

Huh?

"Creature is Scum."

Does it need to be more complicated than that?

I don't understand what your point is. I was directing that at Creature and asking him to respond.

Has he responded yet?

VOTE: Creature

[EspeciallyTheLies]

Tin foil or Scum? I don't get this question at all.

? What do you mean? It looks to me like Creature only posted once he was called out that he needed to be prodded, but it was so quick it was like he'd been reading along with the thread and just not posting. What else is there to get?

I wasn't disagreeing with what you posted, but instead, your tone because you made a very fast post almost word salad to say the same thing.

Huh?

"Creature is Scum."

Does it need to be more complicated than that?

I don't understand what your point is. I was directing that at Creature and asking him to respond.

Has he responded yet?

VOTE: Creature

That doesn't explain your point of asking me if it was tinfoil or scum..?

[Auro]

auro, Quick doesn't know what he's doing

@ETL

That's not a fair thing to say about anyone. It looks to me like he's trying at least. Knowing what to do and how to do it are two different things. I don't expect everyone to be amazing, I only expect them to try.

I don't really feel like he's putting in any thought.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

auro, Quick doesn't know what he's doing

@ETL

That's not a fair thing to say about anyone. It looks to me like he's trying at least. Knowing what to do and how to do it are two different things. I don't expect everyone to be amazing, I only expect them to try.

I don't really feel like he's putting in any thought.

Why? And what does that mean for you?

[Auro]

He's saying that instead of asking "are you going to post when you're named in thread, Creature" or something to that effect, you could/should have just said "Creature is scum" directly, I think.

[Auro]

Why? And what does that mean for you?

Low-confidence lean town.

[Quick]

Tin foil or Scum? I don't get this question at all.

? What do you mean? It looks to me like Creature only posted once he was called out that he needed to be prodded, but it was so quick it was like he'd been reading along with the thread and just not posting. What else is there to get?

I wasn't disagreeing with what you posted, but instead, your tone because you made a very fast post almost word salad to say the same thing.

Huh?

"Creature is Scum."

Does it need to be more complicated than that?

I don't understand what your point is. I was directing that at Creature and asking him to respond.

Has he responded yet?

VOTE: Creature

That doesn't explain your point of asking me if it was tinfoil or scum..?

Sure, but I would really like to know if you are willing to back up what you are saying with a vote on Creature.

Why not vote him so he can show up temporarily so you can unvote him? That is all I am asking here.

[Auro]

His progressions in the last few pages have been bizarre

[davesaz]

Page 50. Making a note that Quick started vote hopping after being accused of being an opportunistic vote follower. Not claiming this as a causal relationship but it is an important observation.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

He's saying that instead of asking "are you going to post when you're named in thread, Creature" or something to that effect, you could/should have just said "Creature is scum" directly, I think.

That's not how I operate. It depends on the situation and the person. I wanted to interact with Creature directly.

Why? And what does that mean for you?

Low-confidence lean town.

I think that's a fair assessment.

Sure, but I would really like to know if you are willing to back up what you are saying with a vote on Creature.

I think you're mistaking my questioning him as a scumread. I'm not ready to make that leap yet. One scummy thing doesn't = scum. It depends on 1) how scummy that thing actually is and 2) the rest of the person's in-game post history.

[davesaz]

daves unvoted and doesn't vote anyone he is suspicious of???? Why no pressure on any of the spots your suspect dave?

I watched episodes of 4 different Star Trek series last night. Today there were 20+ pages to read. Answer: because I've been absent.
Self meta: If you bother to read any of my games you may find

entire days

that I don't vote anyone. Granted those are often days that are quick lynches, but in any case it's not hard to find at all.

[davesaz]

Oh btw, bottom of 52 and I kinda agree with Alchemist votes. Another 9 pages to catch up before I decide what to do.

[davesaz]

These can go at this point:
Jake
5G
Hactoc
Creature
Ari

Okay, that's not a bad list rn.

Interesting your list doesn't include the player you just voted.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

These can go at this point:
Jake
5G
Hactoc
Creature
Ari

Okay, that's not a bad list rn.

Interesting your list doesn't include the player you just voted.

It's his PL list

[davesaz]

@Vecna: Also, as scum the whole "be nice and rational" strategy doesn't really work here because being widely townread makes it harder to justify not being infected.

If infected don't know each other or the mafia then that blows this whole idea out of the water.

[davesaz]

There's only one pro here and I dont see you having the mark of brilliance above your profile picture

I can do without arrogance in the thread quite nicely.
One moment of brilliance does not a great player make.

[Auro]

@Vecna: Also, as scum the whole "be nice and rational" strategy doesn't really work here because being widely townread makes it harder to justify not being infected.

If infected don't know each other or the mafia then that blows this whole idea out of the water.

Why so? Being infected will always be an independent argument, in that "you're a universal townread and therefore likely infected" can hold regardless of infected/mafia knowledge.

[davesaz]

Not Voting (8): Creature, 5G Tower, Jake the Wolfie, Aristophanes

Making a note that the absence of numbers in parenthesis means the slot has

not voted in the game at all

, if the count is working correctly.

[Tchill13]

do you scumread me or what more content from me tchill13

sr you

[Alchemist21]

When I have time tonight I’m going to look through Auro’s ISO because I feel like I should be able to have a read on him by now and I just don’t so maybe I’ve missed something in his posts but I do think it’s kinda weird his alignment isn’t jumping out at me.

[Miss Lane]

I recognize that there have been thirty-two pages added in ~24 hours. How enthralling.

[Auro]

That's odd. You didn't townread me in the mini normal game we played recently, yeah?

[Quick]

I recognize that there have been thirty-two pages added in ~24 hours. How enthralling.

Congrats, you are Town.

[Alchemist21]

That's odd. You didn't townread me in the mini normal game we played recently, yeah?

I can’t really remember about D1. I think I had a Townlean there, but now that we’ve argued in a previous game I feel like I should have a better enough idea of how you play to have a better read this time.

[Quick]

There's only one pro here and I dont see you having the mark of brilliance above your profile picture

I can do without arrogance in the thread quite nicely.
One moment of brilliance does not a great player make.

LOL. That was a pretty deep burn and I'm willing to say these two are most likely not SvS because of it.