Grand Idea GPick [Game Over]

[Quick]

My internet is spotty right now, but I will try to cover all the bases so far and come back tomorrow.
I don't think I misread, as the card came in a separate message from my role card. I don't know why I'd get an impossible color, I didn't realize it was supposed to be impossible.

@Hoctac -

Spoiler:

I'll gladly take a clear. I'm a Coconut Townie. (page 144)

I think if Titus or Ircher were scum here, they would have kept quiet and jumped onto the "lynch boring" wagon. Chateau, TSE, and Quick feel tied for scummiest today. Chances are, they're all not-town.

Quick handled his lynch with a neutral tone, so I think he knew he wasn't going to die. I don't know enough about setups to tie these thoughts to an alignment based on lynchability, I just think he's scum based on actual game play.

I know there are absentee players, but I don't like the "lynch lurkers" policy. I'd rather they either play or get replaced.

I've gotten lynched D1 a lot so I try not to care until D2 or so.

[TemporalLich]

VC 2.3

Titus (4) - Hoctac, hellbooks, farside22, Quick
boring (2) - Chemist1422, Chateau Lobby
ManateeDude (1) - Titus
Chateau Lobby (1) - ManateeDude
Ircher (1) - TrueSoulEnergy
Iconeum (1) - Ircher

Not voting: boring, Two Girls One Vote, Pigman, Battle Mage, Saladman27, Doctor Drew, Iconeum

With 17 alive it takes 9 to eliminate.

Day 2 will end in (expired on 2020-06-03 02:15:00) or when an elimination is reached.

Pigman is V/LA until May 26th, 2020

Pigman is V/LA until May 26th, 2020

[Quick]

And... Manatee is a double voter... or what?

[TemporalLich]

And... Manatee is a double voter... or what?

Votecount error fixed.

[Chateau Lobby]

VOTE: Chateau Lobby

their whole iso is just a mess of non-commital votes and reads

if im reading this right youre voting me for thinking out loud bc I dont think thats inherently scummy

[Saladman27]

VOTE: Titus

[ManateeDude]

VOTE: Chateau Lobby

their whole iso is just a mess of non-commital votes and reads

if im reading this right youre voting me for thinking out loud bc I dont think thats inherently scummy

I'm not boting you for thinking out loud, I'm voting you because you give me the vibe of scum thinking out loud.

You are writing typical things that could be placed at the start of any day in any game.

[Chateau Lobby]

VOTE: Chateau Lobby

their whole iso is just a mess of non-commital votes and reads

if im reading this right youre voting me for thinking out loud bc I dont think thats inherently scummy

I'm not boting you for thinking out loud, I'm voting you because you give me the vibe of scum thinking out loud.

You are writing typical things that could be placed at the start of any day in any game.

Now you have to vote Quick and then Boring. And then we are square.

[Iconeum]

rawr! catching up

[Iconeum]

fun fact: for some reason this is only my 2nd post this entire game

[Iconeum]

so eh for ya'll who are pinged by that, it's time to settle it :p

[farside22]

Town Guesser

Each night, may submit 2

Guesses

of the exact roles of two separate players.
You will be told if 0, 1, or both of your guesses are correct. You will not be told which guess is correct for the case you get 1 correct.
You may not submit a guess for the same player more than once in the game.
For each correct guess, you receive a

One-Shot Doctor Heal.

Heals can be stacked, and multiple can be used in the same night along with the guesses.
You may self-target with a heal no more than once during the game.

Okay, so Titus is scum.

Can you ELI5?

@mod I've been away for the holiday weekend with very limited access. I'll be back in town Tuesday.

I would detest playing as conftown, therefore I am scum.

Or your scum who doesn't want to be caught lying.

My internet is spotty right now, but I will try to cover all the bases so far and come back tomorrow.
I don't think I misread, as the card came in a separate message from my role card. I don't know why I'd get an impossible color, I didn't realize it was supposed to be impossible.

@Hoctac -

Spoiler:

I'll gladly take a clear. I'm a Coconut Townie. (page 144)

I think if Titus or Ircher were scum here, they would have kept quiet and jumped onto the "lynch boring" wagon. Chateau, TSE, and Quick feel tied for scummiest today. Chances are, they're all not-town.

Quick handled his lynch with a neutral tone, so I think he knew he wasn't going to die. I don't know enough about setups to tie these thoughts to an alignment based on lynchability, I just think he's scum based on actual game play.

I know there are absentee players, but I don't like the "lynch lurkers" policy. I'd rather they either play or get replaced.

That is some fun OMGUS reasoning you have there.

[Titus]

Or your scum who doesn't want to be caught lying.

I can't disprove that. That's why I am accepting my lynch if you don't believe me.

Just use as much of the time as possible if you do decide to lynch me.

I can't sub out because that's clearly a strategic subout. I detest being conftown due to its exhausting nature and enjoyment > winning.

So if I get lynched, at least I'll try to get as much fun as I can.

[Titus]

My role is actually verifiable.

P.S. Farside, how's Ircher doing?

[farside22]

My role is actually verifiable.

P.S. Farside, how's Ircher doing?

Curious why you did that?

[farside22]

If you want to know. He finds mantee scummy and i don't know why. Very tight lipped

[Titus]

My role is actually verifiable.

P.S. Farside, how's Ircher doing?

Curious why you did that?

Why not? The goal is to put us in the best possible situation and I can't self target. Risk < Reward.

[Titus]

If you want to know. He finds mantee scummy and i don't know why. Very tight lipped

Manatee is, but I asked less for the answer but more to prove I have zero intent of changing my claim. Since that's the concern.

I just ask you don't out me.

[Ircher]

Why shouldn't we out you Titus?

[Ircher]

Also the Titus wagon, if it's based primarily on Hoctac's claim and Titus's refusal to become conftown, is bad, and the people on it should be ashamed that they think Titus's stance is a scum stance.

[Hoctac]

It's not "conftown" though. That's why I don't buy her excuse. Being cleared from my check is very, very different to being a town tree stump to which she's comparing it to.

What did she do to you/farside? Is whatever she did on average town or scum if you search for the ability in the Grand Idea page?

[Hoctac]

Also, I have been noting down everyone's claims. I'll be picking the two I think are best on a variety of factors. Won't be saying who going into the night obviously.

[Ircher]

About 50/50 from a brief search, but I question why town would use it on us. And I guess that is a good point, but still don't think that's lynch-worthy by itself.

[farside22]

My role is actually verifiable.

P.S. Farside, how's Ircher doing?

Curious why you did that?

Why not? The goal is to put us in the best possible situation and I can't self target. Risk < Reward.

Risk??? I want a rationale for the risk. Wouldn't you want scum reads targeted instead? If not im going to want to know why.

If you want to know. He finds mantee scummy and i don't know why. Very tight lipped

Manatee is, but I asked less for the answer but more to prove I have zero intent of changing my claim. Since that's the concern.

I just ask you don't out me.

Why is manatee a scum read. Last i checked it had to do with quick.

About 50/50 from a brief search, but I question why town would use it on us. And I guess that is a good point, but still don't think that's lynch-worthy by itself.

[farside22]

It's not "conftown" though. That's why I don't buy her excuse. Being cleared from my check is very, very different to being a town tree stump to which she's comparing it to.

What did she do to you/farside? Is whatever she did on average town or scum if you search for the ability in the Grand Idea page?

I want to see what titus says before i decide if outting the role is beneficial.