In post 2773, Dunnstral wrote: In post 1062, Birds and the Boys wrote:okay i haven't read this game at all yet but as the protagonist I need to make an entrance in act 1 so we can do cool things in act 2 and 3 without seeming like a deus ex machina
-oka #1
In post 1063, Birds and the Boys wrote:anyways I have a pretty sick way to catch scum on d1 if you guys need my help
algorithm says its chemist1422
alright cya in 2 weeks
-oka #2
In post 2288, Birds and the Boys wrote:now i haven;t really been paying attention to this game but everyone seems to be chill and happy so ill let you be
-okapoka
Are these Okapoka's only posts?
How can he think anything about Mastina/Chemist, let alone think that they're both scum? What is he basing his read off of?
I'll concede that I'm probably the least informed of all the players in the list, but I have very valid reasons for my reads and how I formed them. I'll concede that maybe some of my points are hypocritical and lean heavily into my meta experiences with both Mastina and Chemist, but nonetheless I do like my reads, however I'm not going to push my reads that hard because well, I don't deserve the podium since I haven't had a presence this game.
Anyways, I find Mastina is scum for one main reason - and one main reason only, she simply does not have the same town!mastina presence that you would expect from a town!mastina. Now I'm not saying its out of the realm of possibility that Mastina has just been lower presence due to RL issues, but odds are - this isn't town Mastina because she doesn't have the same grasp of self-referential meta she usually does. Town!Mastina has a very clear and somewhat linear gameplan to how she operates, she tries to townclear herself and make her voice known by staying active and present throughout the thread, and meta is a very very easy route to accomplish this self clear. The fact that Mastina is being shaded atm by a lot of the playerlist and hasn't been nightkilled in a playerlist that does not include mastina haters is evident of something huge - mastina simply has not cleared herself this game. From the what I've read - albeit not the game in its entirety, she has not actively tried to town clear herself through presence of game and meta. On a very very superficial level, mastina has some similitarities with her town games - she does weird meta reference that literally nobody understands and she locks it in, and the size of her posts seem like a town!mastina post size ~BUT~ AND THIS IS HUGE~ there isn't the same weird detective work/train of though present in her body of work that you will see in mastina town games, its actually very face up and doesn't seem to have a pervasive detective work that is renowned for how controversial it is.
ok chemist has had redemption arc as town recently, he kinda reverting back to old and familiar chemist meta we use to know, but the new chemist aint like this, regression to old meta is usually scum