Grand Idea GPick [Game Over]

[boring]

I forgot to say earlier, but thank you Bingle for explaining the abusable by town bit.

I think we've gotten all we can out of today without objective information. We just need to give Iconeum a chance to claim.

p-edit: I'm on it.. let me update it.

[Doctor Drew]

Who was it that posted the list of all the claims?

If they could post that again you could be my best friend.

Because Boring page sniped me.

[Doctor Drew]

Post Edit: Oh don't I look the fool......my apologies.

[TemporalLich]

hellbooks is being replaced for inactivity as she has accumulated three prods.

[hellbooks]

oops. Too late to come back? sorry.

[TemporalLich]

hellbooks replaces hellbooks.

oops. Too late to come back? sorry.

-You may replace back in if you are being replaced due to inactivity if no one else takes the slot.

[boring]

Revision:

Battle Mage - No claim, but writing French love poems to Annie that end in "gottago fast! ROGNTUDJUUU[...]"
Bingle/saladman - No claim

boring - "Coconut Townie"

Chateau Lobby - No claim

Chemist1422 - "Town 1-shotizer"
Doctor Drew - "Town Anti-Recruiter"
farside22 - "Town Effort Saver"

hellbooks - "Anti-Weak Rolecop"

Hoctac - "Town Guesser"

Iconeum - No claim... yet
Ircher - No *real* claim
ManateeDude - No claim
Pigman - No claim

Starbucks/Quick/dsjster - "VT".

Hellbooks claims she investigated this slot as "3p bomber"

Titus - Cupid? (loverizes folks)
TrueSoulEnergy - "Knowledgeable Townie"
Two Girls One Vote - "Town Utterly Pointless Investigative Role"

[boring]

Ignore the above. I made revisions, and forgot to take off the quote tags.

Revision, revision:

Battle Mage - No claim, but writing French love poems to Annie that end in "gottago fast! ROGNTUDJUUU[...]"
Bingle/saladman - No claim

boring - "Coconut Townie"

Chateau Lobby - No claim

Chemist1422 - "Town 1-shotizer"
Doctor Drew - "Town Anti-Recruiter"
farside22 - "Town Effort Saver"

hellbooks - "Anti-Weak Rolecop"

Hoctac - "Town Guesser"

Iconeum - No claim... yet
Ircher - No *real* claim
ManateeDude - No claim
Pigman - No claim

Starbucks/Quick/dsjster - "VT".

Hellbooks claims she investigated this slot as "3p bomber"

Titus - Cupid? (loverizes folks)
TrueSoulEnergy - "Knowledgeable Townie"
Two Girls One Vote - "Town Utterly Pointless Investigative Role"

[boring]

I want to express my appreciation for the fact that Quick was replaced in such a way that I didn't need to change the playerlist order to keep things alphabetical.

[hellbooks]

Hi everyone. happy to be here. but man did the last person in this slot stink!

[boring]

Hi everyone. happy to be here. but man did the last person in this slot stink!

Okay, that was cute.

[Doctor Drew]

Hmm, I am trying to figure out if there is anyway I can use my power in a pro-town way.

Is there any role that fucks scum if they have it?

Pre Edit: Ugh, thank God Hellbooks is gone.......Welcome Hellbooks!

[hellbooks]

Okay. I think I'm grasping your train of thought. How is this very different from your D1 claim that we should share our page numbers?
And what exactly does "abusable by town" mean?

seems like a good point here. btw, i got a blue card. yeah, I don't know if I can think of any real reason to not claim the card.

Pigman's reads are so off the wall I don't think they can come from scum.

don't see someone who seems to be Obvious Newbie as faking a townslip re: hoctac either.

[hellbooks]

also,
UNVOTE:

about ircher's reads: I was on board with all three being scummy to a pretty strong degree. But bingle and boring seem to be hard defending Titus, boring's got Bingle as like a top townread.... I really just don't see scum weaving themselves this house of cards of interactions here. Probably thinking there's one scum at most in those three, two seems almost implausible I think with all of them townreading each other, idk.

Aside from that, boring's got some serious bluff moves if she's scum and trying to hold me to investigating her + Bingle has been making good points. If I had to point to one and say scum, I still think Titus is most likely here but I understand the value of Bingle's plan to take care of Starbuck / Ircher. I don't really know where I stand on the loverizer targets for Titus. Here were the main points that I don't know ever got addressed.

- Why did boring lie about her card? I'm not hallucinating that that happened, right? (Again, i know -- why would scum lie about it? But even more than that, WHY would town lie about it?)
- Why did Titus refuse to claim earlier by saying that she's conftown when her role is just a loverizer? Her role is outed now, right? And she's not conftown? When someone says their role conftowns them, I'm assuming an activated IC / stump, something like that ballpark.

I think if I had to place myself here, I'd say. Boring town (or maybe like a 3P that doesn't super mind having a role outed, like a 3P that has the capacity to side with town?, Bingle town, Titus scum. But I'm unvoting anyway here just to get myself reevaluating

[hellbooks]

or maybe like a 3P that doesn't super mind having a role outed, like a 3P that has the capacity to side with town

this seems like it could actually be quite likely and I'm sure there's more justification to lie about a card result as 3P than town

[boring]

- Why did Titus refuse to claim earlier by saying that she's conftown when her role is just a loverizer? Her role is outed now, right? And she's not conftown? When someone says their role conftowns them, I'm assuming an activated IC / stump, something like that ballpark.

I think you missed some context. She was saying she didn't want to be confirmed by Hoctac. But then you're right, she had no problem verifying role function. Her power doesn't really vouch for whether she's town or scum. If it weren't for the way she's used and justified her loverizer choices, I'd be much more open to scum!Titus. As it stands, I think I'd need evidence.

[boring]

Hmm, I am trying to figure out if there is anyway I can use my power in a pro-town way.

Is there any role that fucks scum if they have it?

I've actually thought about this a lot (sorry, I'm creepy that way).
I thought we could just have you target anti-town players, and then we could lynch them with the full knowledge that they're scum. But that's a slow, possibly wasteful vig.
Now, if your ability turns everyone into a member of the mafia team (say serial killers, cult, etc.), that could eliminate other possible winning factions, but then it could tip the scales in mafia's favor and suddenly lose the game for us too.

So tl;dr: I have no clue.

[Doctor Drew]

Unfortunately, I can't turn 3p into scum.

[Bingle]

I claimed to be a self targeting role in the watcher family, but not necessarily a watcher, fwiw.

[Titus]

Townie

(role up to mod discretion)

The moderator chooses your role but not your alignment.

Alien Pheromone Seeder

Loverizes two people for the night and following day, giving them Day- and Night Talk.

Since this is still a thing, my literal role is Townie. I literally would have been conftown if Hotac guessed my role. I picked page 314 because it's my birthday.

The mod then assigned me Phermone Seeder.

[Titus]

Since this is still up for discussion and all the negative side effects are out, I figured it best to just outright claim

[Bingle]

Is there any role that fucks scum if they have it?

I mean... Judas, kind of?

But no, the role you claimed can never actually be useful for town. I will refrain from speculation on how it can become useful for theoretical antitown you.

[Doctor Drew]

Oh jeez, if I were an anti-town role I would have a field day with this.

This role is such a tease.

[Doctor Drew]

Oh hey....and happy scum day to me!

[TemporalLich]

TrueSoulEnergy has been prodded.