Redneck Mafia GAME OVER PARTNER!

[username]

I was scum in that game...

It was a weird game

Legit one of the most fun games I ever played


Even when I got locked in a PT with maria for like a month or whatever it was

[username]

No need for condescension, bud.

I'm sorry I just don't like answering questions that I had assumed were self evident

[chkflip]

Doubling down. Spicy.

FATE did that a lot better than you do.

[username]

I blazed the path that Fate walked, not the other way round dude


He was better at mafia than me though, and I've never said otherwise

[Almost50]

100% of my experience leaving 3ps alive was being screwed sideways. I have never seen it work.

They are not scum hunting and they vote. grrrrrr

One word: Gistou

[chkflip]

Better to be a humble wasp's nest then a spicy curmudgeon.

Good on you.

[username]

Better to be a humble wasp's nest then a spicy curmudgeon.

Good on you.

The wasps slumber in the old entity.

This entity does not allow fury within this vessel.

This entity exudes peace, love, empathy.

This vessel remains Tranquilo.

[Almost50]

What if he's a vanillaizer? What if any ability that targets him fails and makes the person vanilla?

Are mwe going to repeat ourselves for the resat of the day?? ELSA CLAIMS a ONE-SHOT VIG. Whether or not he targets Alch he IS effectively "vanillaized" after using his shot. If you think I was saying I would rather mistermoinate.. etc then I can say I think you're saying you'd rather EJ misvigs a townie than try it on the claimed 3P.

[username]

What if he's a vanillaizer? What if any ability that targets him fails and makes the person vanilla?

Are mwe going to repeat ourselves for the resat of the day?? ELSA CLAIMS a ONE-SHOT VIG. Whether or not he targets Alch he IS effectively "vanillaized" after using his shot. If you think I was saying I would rather mistermoinate.. etc then I can say I think you're saying you'd rather EJ misvigs a townie than try it on the claimed 3P.

Or what if, and hear me out, the vig doesn't out themselves and didn't hip fire and thus avoids misvigging a townie

[DrippingGoofball]

That's an awful roundabout way of saying "I'd rather Mislynch town than lynch someone who doesn't have a town wincon and might be completely lying about their mechanics and actual wincon."

This bears repeating.

[username]

What if he's a vanillaizer? What if any ability that targets him fails and makes the person vanilla?

Are mwe going to repeat ourselves for the resat of the day?? ELSA CLAIMS a ONE-SHOT VIG. Whether or not he targets Alch he IS effectively "vanillaized" after using his shot. If you think I was saying I would rather mistermoinate.. etc then I can say I think you're saying you'd rather EJ misvigs a townie than try it on the claimed 3P.

Or what if, and hear me out, the vig doesn't out themselves and didn't hip fire and thus avoids misvigging a townie

And yes before anyone bothers, I understand that we are well past this point

[DrippingGoofball]

What if he's a vanillaizer? What if any ability that targets him fails and makes the person vanilla?

What if he's something else that hasn't been thought of? A reflexive ability thief, ie the Vig shoots him and he absorbs it and gains a big shot without dying?

What if targeting him makes you join his cult? Do you not remember that this game may have bastard elements?

Whether you're town or scum, he does NOT SHARE your wincon and cannot he trusted to be telling the truth about his role.

This bears repeating too, and it's a crying shame he's not

guillotined

yet.

Stop pussy footing around and let the blade fall.

I want to see more votes.

[DrippingGoofball]

MOAR ALCHEMIST VOATS

[username]

DGB while I've got you here


Let's get together and plan Uncouth Mafia 3

[username]

Or uncouth 2 which I guess would make it Polite Mafia 3

[Almost50]

Well, I dunno what more to say. Those who want Alcj terminated can vote him. I just won't. Not even if it leads to the day ending in a No Termination. As the game had started in Even numbers I believe getting it to Odds (assuming Scum have 1 NK, no killing 3P roles, and Alch telling the truth) would be nice for town.

[TemporalLich]

Convince me Alchemist is scum fakeclaiming 3p, this is D1 and wasting the elim will deny us valuable info

[Elsa Jay]

Killing a 3p doesn't give associations at all. It just waste town's time and let's scum get away with a free day.

[username]

I feel like y'all are misunderstanding here

My vote is on alchemist already, and I do believe it's the best place for an execution

If you guys don't wanna agree with me, fine, it's whatever, and it's an issue for mafia discussion

However, you're not going to convince me right here and right now that it isn't the best course of action. I'm willing to allow Elsa to take a shot tonight at Alchemist, but I don't feel that is ideal.

We can keep arguing for page after page over some shit that should be in MD, but I'm only one vote out of whatever is the majority.

By all means feel free to case someone else as scum for me to look at.

[pisskop]

How is that shade? Just pointing it out.

bros getting defensive

[pisskop]

Convince me Alchemist is scum fakeclaiming 3p, this is D1 and wasting the elim will deny us valuable info

the more we talk about alch the more it becomes a useful flip from an information perspective, js.

[username]

Nah, Elsa's right about one thing, 3Ps by definition have no allies and so have less associative tells. You can judge based on how others respond to them, but tbh a claimed 3p knows they don't have to help the town

[Logicalicaltist]

Killing a 3p doesn't give associations at all. It just waste town's time and let's scum get away with a free day.

This is also a good point!

[DrippingGoofball]

DGB while I've got you here

Let's get together and plan Uncouth Mafia 3

QAnon mafia LOL

[DrippingGoofball]

Killing a 3p doesn't give associations at all. It just waste town's time and let's scum get away with a free day.

It's going to happen anyway.

Let's get rid of the lying liar that lies.

100% success rate.