Silent Star 1: Lunacy

[Raven Branwen]

it said no midgame alignment changes but there may be other bastard elements.

/in to mod

Is it possible your game has any of the following bastard roles or mechanics?

No cults or mid-game alignment changes. There may be other bastard elements.

I guess we’ll find out then, I don’t think anything bastard has happened so far. Does anyone here believe town is superstacked? I know MT thinks scum is informed but it’s just really weird to me.

[Morning Tweet]

UNVOTE:

Well it's not me + beeboy

like, if we're dealing with a 2 man non-mafia team, that's probably what it'd have to be. Right? So i can't really accept that there isnt more mafia cause i dont think beeboy/Dunn is the case

Why can't they be in other pts like the mafia were

And if that's the case people who were in pts with power roles aren't necessarily clear

ughhhhhhhhhhh. Lemme call them vampires

Well Raven and skitts vouch for each other, so i dont think they're disaligned. You and beeboy vouch for each other i assume.

My reads on Clover/midway mostly have them as werewolf. I suppose it's possible that midway is a vampire who is bullshitting the lone wolf thing.

I could be a vampire maybe since Kanna wasn't threatening to me, she was threatening to mafia.

So that's like me, Clover, and midway in that case. Do Clover and midway seem aligned? Idrk cause i've been tunneled on thinking both are wolf

[Morning Tweet]

it said no midgame alignment changes but there may be other bastard elements.

/in to mod

Is it possible your game has any of the following bastard roles or mechanics?

No cults or mid-game alignment changes. There may be other bastard elements.

I guess we’ll find out then, I don’t think anything bastard has happened so far. Does anyone here believe town is superstacked? I know MT thinks scum is informed but it’s just really weird to me.

If Nahdia was in a werewolf PT with one of the dead and they have the same flavour/role PMs i have, this is absolutely bastard. It heavily implies that Kanna is a werewolf

How else would Nahdia have known about us forgetting how to kill?

[Raven Branwen]

One of the theories I had with the night flavor is that people who were previously werewolves days 1/2 would start turning into mafia, until there was a team of 4 mafia

So the game would have started with 2 mafia, and then 2 more people would be 'infected', or by the flavor 'have their amnesia removed'

That would explain the missing kill last night, I don't know if the game wouldn't just end if all the mafia died though

This game wasn’t advertised as bastard though.

We're all werewolves and there was mafia in werewolf pts

We’re logically assuming Tux/Nahdia probably didn’t actually share one.

Oh right, that could be the bastard part. Yeah, that makes sense.

[beeboy]

Why is their a second faction that just can't kill?
That feels so disadvantagous and unfair for that faction idk.

[drusilla]

Dru making me feel so bad trying to lynch her wtf.
Can you just roll over and flip scum >:(

i won't though. if you're willing to look at them i'll link you all of my completed games as mafia. like i am clearly not here.

Idk who I should be voting then.
And I don't understand this setup.

I just feel like you make the most sense here

all of my games as mafia:

gacha mafia (shiki): viewtopic.php?f=23&t=83059
micro 940 (shiki): viewtopic.php?f=84&t=83045
micro 935 (shiki half of euphony hydra): viewtopic.php?f=84&t=82859
mini normal 2122 (team rocket queen): viewtopic.php?f=53&t=82337

could try voting the mayor again.

[Raven Branwen]

it said no midgame alignment changes but there may be other bastard elements.

/in to mod

Is it possible your game has any of the following bastard roles or mechanics?

No cults or mid-game alignment changes. There may be other bastard elements.

I guess we’ll find out then, I don’t think anything bastard has happened so far. Does anyone here believe town is superstacked? I know MT thinks scum is informed but it’s just really weird to me.

If Nahdia was in a werewolf PT with one of the dead and they have the same flavour/role PMs i have, this is absolutely bastard. It heavily implies that Kanna is a werewolf

How else would Nahdia have known about us forgetting how to kill?

No, I meant the town being superstacked part. I absolutely agree with you on this.

[Dunnstral]

That's what we thought we were at the start

[beeboy]

Not to mention we still don't know why solo scum Tux just shot into a watcher?
Or how uninformed Chara would somehow know to kill the cop claim without reading the game?
They would either know about 0 or both the claims I feel.

[beeboy]

VOTE: Hectic

die mayor

[Raven Branwen]

Why is their a second faction that just can't kill?
That feels so disadvantagous and unfair for that faction idk.

Yeah and Dru was the one who claimed that Nahdia was communicating a 3P scumteam, that’s another thing that pinged me. Why give credence to flipped scum wifom?

[drusilla]

Not to mention we still don't know why solo scum Tux just shot into a watcher?
Or how uninformed Chara would somehow know to kill the cop claim without reading the game?
They would either know about 0 or both the claims I feel.

it seems possible to me that the pt said specifically that kanna was a cop due to her having outed nahdia without it saying my role.

[beeboy]

And not the other where Chara spoke about self hammering?
It makes no sense to also be selective about it idk.

That's why I am still just voting Dru, I feel bad if I am wrong, but I am pretty sure I am right.

[drusilla]

Yeah and Dru was the one who claimed that Nahdia was communicating a 3P scumteam, that’s another thing that pinged me. Why give credence to flipped scum wifom?

because it was made more likely by other factors, and that third faction would not be aligned with nahdia.

[beeboy]

Not to mention we still don't know why solo scum Tux just shot into a watcher?
Or how uninformed Chara would somehow know to kill the cop claim without reading the game?
They would either know about 0 or both the claims I feel.

it seems possible to me that the pt said specifically that kanna was a cop due to her having outed nahdia without it saying my role.

kill: Dru

I want to get the watcher out of the way first

Why question a potential original kill?
Why does the scum PT only have 1 claim listed?
Idk I just don't think the scum team has 2 people or Chara just threw.

[Raven Branwen]

Not to mention we still don't know why solo scum Tux just shot into a watcher?
Or how uninformed Chara would somehow know to kill the cop claim without reading the game?
They would either know about 0 or both the claims I feel.

We don’t know which scum killed Lillith, because Kanna was AC not watcher but I think it extremely likely that Chara did kill Kanna because that slot was a gonner so it would make the most sense.

[drusilla]

Why question a potential original kill?
Why does the scum PT only have 1 claim listed?
Idk I just don't think the scum team has 2 people or Chara just threw.

i obviously can't answer these questions but it seems possible to me that chara didn't know. i'm not saying whether or not it did even, it might have and went through with the kill anyway as it was likely caught regardless.

[Raven Branwen]

Not to mention we still don't know why solo scum Tux just shot into a watcher?
Or how uninformed Chara would somehow know to kill the cop claim without reading the game?
They would either know about 0 or both the claims I feel.

it seems possible to me that the pt said specifically that kanna was a cop due to her having outed nahdia without it saying my role.

Well thankfully, we have MT to confirm or deny that.

[drusilla]

Well thankfully, we have MT to confirm or deny that.

to confirm or deny what the mafia pt said?

[Dunnstral]

I'm confused, what are we talking about?

[Raven Branwen]

Yeah and Dru was the one who claimed that Nahdia was communicating a 3P scumteam, that’s another thing that pinged me. Why give credence to flipped scum wifom?

because it was made more likely by other factors, and that third faction would not be aligned with nahdia.

The fact that scum was pushing that should have made it less not more credible, because it’s scum’s job to mislead town.

[drusilla]

I'm confused, what are we talking about?

why chara might have made the nightkill that it made.

[beeboy]

I'm confused, what are we talking about?

why chara might have made the nightkill that it made.

In regards to a 9/2/2 game.

[beeboy]

Game being 9/2/2 with a kill-less faction over 10/3

I think the former is just a stall strat to keep dru alive tbh.

[Dunnstral]

If mafia knew Kanna was a cop night 1, they'd have just killed Kanna

I don't buy that lilith as bodyguard on night 1 would target someone randomly when she thinks she is scum