I caught up, thoughts, not really a readlist in order but it is what it is. My med wore off so my thoughts are a bit foggy;
Not an easy game, normally by the end of d1 I have half the town locked. I am not very experienced in reading for mefias in a multilball setup, especially considering there's 4/9 scum left with up to 4 diff prs and I tend to scumread prs so meh. I think consistency is a trait not affected by multiball so
a50/dave have been consistently making content and been good-okay tone wise.
a50
historically, I have been scumreading/null reading them until they townclaim via one liners or t tells, never met his s game. It started out like that, his pacing is different than what I am used to but by page 12 he was pretty blatant town and never went down. Many of his takes are just too town poving hard and would not see scum faking them in quantity nor quality
dave
i remembered him as a stronger t player, never met his s game. Some of his early posting screamed town, some of his later cases were extremely weak and I expected better. He's been the most consistent throughout the game, he should be town. a50's listed dave's games, meh. I think he sounds much more confident in some of those games, idk tho, tone is consistent. I also respect my pred's read on them who implied hard town. Early interactions with Haya spewed town imo or diff alignement/team. His stuff about IRL issues was genuine as hell imo
Element
, oh well. Taking only this game into consideration, I would call him lynchbait town. There's a lack of agenda, he votes everywhere. I had mirror reads with some of his rxns, namely when he reacted to NS's unvote I quoted earlier or has just str8 up t posts, hard to fake as mefia. He showed town pov in numerous occasions when he wasn't prompted and in creative ways; like when he claims he should actually be left alive in this game in 5way just scum can kill each other off. It's not a strong read or anything but it doesn't make any sens as a thought process (even tho it's survivalistic), I just hardly see scum thinking about shit like this at all yet posting it.
Taking the listed game; from activity and tone, element is extremely different in this game. Id still call him town, would flip elsewhere and need to dive more his other games.
aGar
Early content sucked ass, started having better/great posts later on. I dislike his tone overall, might not be AI. Content wise, I am mixed. I think his wagon stuff was genuine thought process but it has less value in a multiball. Would probably townread them in singleball
SirCakez/Bulge
; Similar vibes on them, both has a few great posts but not very consistently so, never played with either
SC was great tonewise early one, his content never matched his confidence tho. He looks worse in 2nd half of the game
Bulge; Seems okay, some great one-liners, would need to reread iso
malakittens
Distinct lack of actual genuine content or unique thought process, barely anything but reaction posts. Has mentioned numerous times she was busy IRL about paramedic stuff, implying it was the reason for her lack of investment. The thing is, once it was finished, there was no difference in behavior. Notscience pointed out many times how she wasn't reacting in her expected town way, how she let her away with scum-reading her (and IV agreed, both died). IIRC, mala hasn't really engaged that fos from NS too much, not in a confrontantional way anyways (I might be wrong)
IMO, when I am town and someone is trying to use my own behaviour as an argument in a case, It annoys me and I feel like I had to prove them wrong, regardless of their alignement because It's my duty to not be scumread on objective grounds. Idk, feels like the kitten is coasting her scumread status and trying to milk the most out of this game. That being said, some of her one liners are great af lole, idk. Prob a mefia
Dramonic
Extremely hostile early game with great tone to booth and was very consistent. Has been coasting the game pretty hard for the 2nd half of the game iirc which is unlike what I would expect from someone that is hostile/agressive and opinionated. Never played with them. Prob a mefia
Dunstrall
Played a few times with them, they were always town and an open book pre page 5 read for me. I even saw his interactions as town with mariar within numerous game (at least 5+) when here was always town but Mariar wasn't always. IMO this is not town D'un so far, hes absolutely extremely underwhelming and that is considering that I know what his meta of non-engagement is. He just hasn't posted a single piece of content that makes me believes hes town past my page 5 read or so. Even his interaction with my slot (Mariar) is atypical at best and dodgy at worse. I think hes a mefia
