Musician Mafia: Guitarists GAME OVER

[Almost50]

Lol, I feel like I am the only person here who knows what djent is.

That's the "djent-tell, man"

[Almost50]

I think if A50 does flip scum this game, we found a buddy of his.

Flip him and see

Am I reading this wrong or did Looker just admit she knows I', Town already??

[I Keep Siteflaking]

TOWN

Iecerint
TiphaineDeath
A50
Titus
Doctor Drew
Pooky
a2rudeboy aka Hypnotoad
Galron
Pisskop
Gamma
BrightEyed
Starbuck
Princess Leia/REPLACEMENT

Lavender
Nono

Looker
DGB
IKS
Walter
Bambi
NPOM

SCUM

uhhhh

REASONS?

I'm happy to answer specific questions you have. You can see my thoughts from the posts I made as I caught up with the game.

You have less than 20 posts before that read list. There is zero possibility you sorted as many slots as did and covered them all in that limited span. YOU ARE A LIAR!
VOTE: Iecerint

I think, that there is a better approach for this than to claim that there is 0 possibility that he sorted that many slots.
@they may have thrown
why are following players in your list on positions they are in?
Galron, Pisskop, Walter, DGB, NPOM, iecerint, starbucks.

[Starbuck]

You have less than 20 posts before that read list. There is zero possibility you sorted as many slots as did and covered them all in that limited span. YOU ARE A LIAR!
VOTE: Iecerint

I feel like you missed his posts where he explained how he did it. If he has less than 20 posts, look up his ISO and then come back.


Also, answer Pooky's questions.

[Galron]

Pisskop, I have a personal question. Why are you pushing me for joking about modkill, but this was OK: viewtopic.php?p=11344630#p11344630

Eww... Why even go there?

[I Keep Siteflaking]

Pisskop, I have a personal question. Why are you pushing me for joking about modkill, but this was OK: viewtopic.php?p=11344630#p11344630

Eww... Why even go there?

Why not?
Took me like 5 mins to find that game, check who from this game pushed me for joking about modkill and was in the other game and didn't react on BS asking for modkill and was town.
And I have a neat FOS on piss now. I am happy.

[Iecerint]

@they may have thrown
why are following players in your list on positions they are in?
Galron, Pisskop, Walter, DGB, NPOM, iecerint, starbucks.

Galron: I townread him for his 339. This was his "people are attacking Leia and TD for NAI" post. He was the only one saying that kind of thing at the time.

Pisskop: I actually scumread him on his initial replace-in, but I didn't trust my scumread because I townread him (when he was scum) in our last game we played together (Baker's last game, now completed). His play in this game IS different from that game, so I wondered if I needed to turn my readhead upside-down. Then, I realized that the difference was mostly caused by his having replaced in, and I wondered if I needed to have my readhead put back. When I read his replace-in posts a couple more times (during my initial readthrough I paused and read his catch-up a couple of times), I eventually decided he was town. IIRC at first I was puzzled by a dissonant read he listed, which led to a scumread, but I was able to figure it out when I read it a second or third time. So, this one had a lot of back-and-forth mostly based on his replace-in posts. Overall, he has seemed like he wants to solve the game.

Walter: Went into my NULL pile originally and then re-sorted to scum when I read his iso and realized that (at that time) he had posted no content whatsoever while also having a fair number of posts. This differentiated him from someone like Lavender. He went lower on the list than Looker because Looker had a handful of townie-seeming posts in his iso.

DGB: I usually have a really strong townread on DGB when she is town. I don't have a really strong townread on DGB. I put her directly into scum without having to sort her from NULL. Also, I am surprised that she has totally ignored NPOM, because I would expect her to really focus on the whole "set-up outguessing" premise that Rudeboy mentioned, since she usually crusades against this kind of thing (e.g., the same Baker game that was just completed -- in that game, it was about "oh maybe this 3p will be townie" that she crusaded against, but it's a similar overprivileging of /outguess over scumhunting). But, it's more the former than the latter, because I think that associative tells are usually not helpful D1.

NPOM: This should be obvious; most of my iso is about NPOM. He made multiple early scumtells and his posts since then have been either brazenly without scumhunting, or fake scumhunting (e.g., posting a readslist that lists Leia when at that point Dave had replaced in and been active for awhile). [INB4 He posts pointing out that I did the same thing in my reads post but.] The main case for not shredding him is that Rudeboy says he's *possibly* a phantom jester (or some other shred-shenanigans role).

Iecerint: I embody the Iecerint.

Starbuck: I just think she's town. Prolly because she saw the thread the same way as me for a lot of the game I think. Townread has gotten stronger from content since I posted my readslist.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I can hold my own. I just have a hard time making up content when there's not much to go on.

lol making up content

bro only mafia make shit up - townies just type what they're thinking

[Starbuck]

I can hold my own. I just have a hard time making up content when there's not much to go on.

lol making up content

bro only mafia make shit up - townies just type what they're thinking

Can we kill that with fire yet?

[Galron]

Pisskop, I have a personal question. Why are you pushing me for joking about modkill, but this was OK: viewtopic.php?p=11344630#p11344630

Eww... Why even go there?

Why not?
Took me like 5 mins to find that game, check who from this game pushed me for joking about modkill and was in the other game and didn't react on BS asking for modkill and was town.
And I have a neat FOS on piss now. I am happy.

Alright I'll file it ffr. Everyone's grasping at straws anyway.

[I Keep Siteflaking]

townies just type what they're thinking

i am hungry

[Titus]

Starbuck, are you scum? You feel funny. You're sheeping a patently bad argument by Pookie. You should know this.

[Galron]

I can hold my own. I just have a hard time making up content when there's not much to go on.

lol making up content

bro only mafia make shit up - townies just type what they're thinking

Can we kill that with fire yet?

How far a leash do we extend rudeboy?

[Bambi Jay]

I want lecerint to psycho analysis me too.

[pisskop]

You're learning

quote of the game Right here

[Galron]

I think, that there is a better approach for this than to claim that there is 0 possibility that he sorted that many slots.
@they may have thrown
why are following players in your list on positions they are in?
Galron, Pisskop, Walter, DGB, NPOM, iecerint, starbucks.

1) I think his answer in 931 was odd in that he had extended commentary for each one of your selected players. What are your thoughts on that?

2) How did you choose the players to ask him about?

[pisskop]

i like 931 enough to not want it dead.

that's some decent efforting right there

[The Baker]

chkflip repacks in for Nono
Day One resumes, ending on Monday, September 28th 2020 at 10:00 am EST in (expired on 2020-09-28 10:00:00)
(This is a little later than the originally paused time, but I'm not getting up at 5:00 am)

[Starbuck]

Starbuck, are you scum? You feel funny. You're sheeping a patently bad argument by Pookie. You should know this.

I'm not sheeping his argument. I'm interested in the answer to his question.

[I Keep Siteflaking]

I think, that there is a better approach for this than to claim that there is 0 possibility that he sorted that many slots.
@they may have thrown
why are following players in your list on positions they are in?
Galron, Pisskop, Walter, DGB, NPOM, iecerint, starbucks.

1) I think his answer in 931 was odd in that he had extended commentary for each one of your selected players. What are your thoughts on that?

2) How did you choose the players to ask him about?

1) He claimed that he has reasons why he put players where he put them. Nothing surprising.
2)
galron - wagon
pisskiop - my scumread
Walter/ DGB - not general scumreads
NPOM - I don't find him that scummy as people do
iecerint - joke
starbucks - hasn't pinged me in any way and I wanted to hear opinions of others.

[Starbuck]

Also, not scum. I had 2 back to back scum games. It's a breather to get a town role PM.

[Starbuck]

I think the question should be posed to you, though. Are you scum, Titus?

[Iecerint]

I want lecerint to psycho analysis me too.

I kinda had a weak town gutread on you while reading the thread, but nothing worth commenting on. Then people started calling you scum around the time of the end of my readthrough. So I put you in NULL because I wanted to read your iso before I made a decision. When I read your iso, it did seem like you were active but not scumhunting (similar to what some people were alluding to). I think I had been weakly townreading you because your style is pretty light/breezy. So then I put you in scum. Your noise/signal ratio was unusually high, so I put you lower on the list. I've never played with you haven't meta'd you yet.

[Iecerint]

I think [Iecerint's] answer in 931 was odd in that [Iecerint] had extended commentary for each one of [IKS's] selected players.

What do you mean by "odd"? How is "extended commentary," either in general or as reflected in my post, related to "oddness"?

[a2rudeboy]

I'm just gonna sit here and wait for chkflip to catch up through 38pgs of nonsense