Mini Theme 2172: Great Idea Mafia - Game Over

[Iconeum]

Titus and EV are town upon a Ranny scumflip as well

[Iconeum]

Someone asked for my reads list. Here goes

Rannygazoo - Weak lean town. I can see both sides getting frustrated by the smartass comments I did but my gut says town.
Herta - Easily picked on town.
redcardinal - At least scumhunting. No interest in executing here today.
shellyc - Scummy. Her explanation for voting Herta while pushing Rangy seems scummy and an attempt to dodge VCA or take responsibility for her push later. She wants town to mislynch for her. VOTE: shellyc
iamausername - Same as redcardinal.
Titus - A perfect angel
Primate - I like what he's posted but I'd like to see him more.
Wiyvern* arachnidsGrip - Lurking. Would compromise hrre.
Iconeum* - Same as Wiyvern.
Assemblerotws* - Same as Wivern.
NoPowerOverMe - Same as Primate.
EchoVision - Same as redcardinal.
Noraa - Pretty obvtown.

i've got shelly v randy in reverse here
what makes you townlean there after the 'reaction to your move'?

[Iconeum]

now talk to me please :p

[MURDERCAT]

Ico can you give a read list?

That's a pretty weak catch-up after a week of nothing

[Iconeum]

Ico can you give a read list?

That's a pretty weak catch-up after a week of nothing

i'm not sure why you'd expect something stronger of me in the first place

i'm very much a real-time player and catch ups are really not my thing

the amount of times i've been quick-executed after such a catchup (as town) is way too damn high

[Iconeum]

i've only just started playing *this* game, due to bad timing irl and that's partly my fault

but on day 1 i've got a pretty decent scumread and a couple townreads after reading so it's actually pretty good imo

[MURDERCAT]

What are they?

[EchoVision]

I ran some back of the envelope numbers to see what we are dealing with. They aren't perfect because of stuff like alien sympathizer but I did take into account that there must be town majority.

Num of scum factions: % likelihood

1: 4%
2: 26%
3: 44%
4: 22%
5: 3%
6: <1% (though amazingly possible with town majority)

Dear scum, please cross kill thanks

huh so it's

veryyyy

likely multiball

[EchoVision]

Someone asked for my reads list. Here goes

Rannygazoo - Weak lean town. I can see both sides getting frustrated by the smartass comments I did but my gut says town.
Herta - Easily picked on town.
redcardinal - At least scumhunting. No interest in executing here today.
shellyc - Scummy. Her explanation for voting Herta while pushing Rangy seems scummy and an attempt to dodge VCA or take responsibility for her push later. She wants town to mislynch for her. VOTE: shellyc
iamausername - Same as redcardinal.
Titus - A perfect angel
Primate - I like what he's posted but I'd like to see him more.
Wiyvern* arachnidsGrip - Lurking. Would compromise hrre.
Iconeum* - Same as Wiyvern.
Assemblerotws* - Same as Wivern.
NoPowerOverMe - Same as Primate.
EchoVision - Same as redcardinal.
Noraa - Pretty obvtown.

meh these seem lazy
just to double check your lynchpool is {shelly, ico, wiyvern}?
meh

[shellyc]

lastly i have no idea what all these people are doing giving me an SR for apparently pursuing my top SR while acknowledging the secondary wagon??

[EchoVision]

There's a reason for that. Is it better to focus on setup WIFOM or actual scumhunting?

This is why I don't like your posts. What scum hunting are you doing? You saw the misconceptions that Noraa had that

I

had to clear up even though the claim happened page 1. Honestly it makes me concerns that Titus is scum because I know she is a strong player and I feel like she should be leading more

Titus is a strong player? O_o

yeah titus is jacked
benches 330

[SirCakez]

As Wiyvern did not post yesterday they will be replaced.
shellyc has requested replacement.

[SirCakez]

Prodding Primate

[MURDERCAT]

This is kind of sad, I'd hopped I'd be able to breathe some life into the game but I guess we are waiting on replacements now

[NoPowerOverMe]

Read lists on day one are dumb anyway. There's no way to have strong reads this early.

[MURDERCAT]

This is a very frustrating pov to try to play with. Would you rather just elim randomly until we lose?

[NoPowerOverMe]

No. You can still have opinions.

[Herta]

He already said it was rvs, and it was his first post of the game so that makes sense. AFAIC he was already pushed by username and the issue's moot.

Why are you against pressuring someone for something? This has nothing to do with ranny, I'm commenting on how easily username let up the push.

No problem pushing username but I don't see that happening there.

[Herta]

I'm not linking you to that post, just making an observation. But what is it about Titus that is missing?

Well I'm not all the way caught up, but there seems to be a general air of titus = town and I haven't seen that much to justify it in her posts

It's subtle. She seems to have a process that I find townie.

[Herta]

shelly thinks the solve is ranny/herta/noraa lmaoooooooooooo

Yeah, since you commented earlier, where I was going with that is how can she have us as partners when this has got to be multi-ball? I wanted to get her to explain that, but can't now ofc.

[MURDERCAT]

It's subtle. She seems to have a process that I find townie.

I don't think this is good enough, Titus is good enough to seem towny as scum

[Herta]

I want someone to explain how fakeclaiming gravedigger is even remotely probable. If I am scum it is because I am a scum gravedigger(I haven't checked to make sure there is a scum gravedigger role but someone said there is, I think somewhere.) But other than that I am nearly locktown.

#57 on the great idea role list.

You didn't check to see if there's a scum gravedigger, but you knew that gravedigger was #57 on the wiki list. Why wouldn't you read the rest of roles to get an idea of the possible roles in the game while you were already there?

[NoPowerOverMe]

Never played great idea before nor have I been a gravedigger.

[Herta]

I'm LHF, of course.

Stop with that. You're not LHF. Your claim is protecting you right now. Your posting isn't doing you any favors.

[Herta]

HOLY FUCK I LOVE MY AVI BEING BACK

I was digging the new one, but this one is good too.