Mini Theme 2172: Great Idea Mafia - Game Over

[Iconeum]

ungated = you have no restriction on using your power

a restriction could be 'even night only' or 'not allowed to doc someone twice in a row'

[EchoVision]

im strictly a town doctor
no ifs ands or buts about it
i am allowed to target one person every night
that person will be protected if a kill were to be aimed at them

pedit yeah that's not me

[EchoVision]

anyway, i have PMd the mod to ask if a hypothetical doctor would be able to self-protect, and since this is an open setup, i see no reason why this wouldn't be answered.

i expect that if Echo was scum he would have done the same before claiming to be a doc that could self protect, but i guess maybe he thought that was standard until people started questioning it

i expect that a doc that can self-heal would be informed in their role pm (because it not being normal), and apparently they had to check with the mod to know this so??

when did i say i had to check with the mod?
i said "i have confirmation of this"

[Iconeum]

EV i've got a terrible gut feeling about your role and claim and how ur going about it but i'm not gonna press you on stuff like this

especially when it comes to mod confirmations or not, content of role pm's, wordings etc

as bad as my feeling is that it just sounds like not something that would be in *any* game

i have no legit reasons to push you over it...

[SirCakez]

In this setup, a Doctor could self-protect, in response to a question.

[iamausername]

ok, now that that's established

The problem echo is that if you are scum and I die you get to say whoops sorry doc'd myself. So commit to docing me so that you die and we win the game tomorrow. Because if I die you aren't conf town tomorrow

i agree with this

[MURDERCAT]

This isn't a normal game clearly

[MURDERCAT]

Echo I think you should choose whoever you want to protect then, me or you. If we are lucky it might keep us both safe.

[MURDERCAT]

Herta's reaction is basically "you got me for the wrong reasons" which isn't a town mindset, it's a survivalist one. Instead of providing content when the spotlight was on them they flailed. And that is why we should all get herta NOW.

You're essentially co-opting username's reasoning as your own after admitting that you overreacted in the first place. That's not a villagery mindset. That's a wolf who got caught without cover.

VOTE: Shelly

I mean, how do you get scumclaim out of that, Shelly? Seriously. Because that's what people do is scumclaim.

because I called you newbscum
you said you were newbscum

VOTE: Herta

When on this site, on any site, have you seen a literal scum claim at the beginning of a game?

This is daft. You didn't like how I answered your question, so you called me newbscum or an alt. I said yeah must be newbscum. Boom you jump right into dancing the dance of joy. This is so surface level it's painful.

We've got enough scum factions probably that the whole game is going to be like this, people jumping on everything they see.

Does anyone have a case other than Primate? At least that one has some oomph behind it.

Damn I missed a lot. Noraa, your vote is still on shelly slot as is mine. You think that slot is still scum?

person changed. alignment still the same.

Yeah, I was hoping you'd be able to sum up Italiano before I got home tonight so I knew what to look for.

Ok I think Shelly replaced out due to Herta being upset about a bus.

I feel good about voting Herta now

[MURDERCAT]

VOTE: Herta

Not hammer because Primate unvoted

[Primate]

I think I get the vibe that vague is good here so I'm going to end it while things still are.

VOTE: Herta

[iamausername]

Echo I think you should choose whoever you want to protect then, me or you. If we are lucky it might keep us both safe.

really what he should have done was committed to protecting you in thread and then protected himself anyway

but i guess the wifom strategy is fine too

[Primate]

Echo I think you should choose whoever you want to protect then, me or you. If we are lucky it might keep us both safe.

really what he should have done was committed to protecting you in thread and then protected himself anyway

but i guess the wifom strategy is fine too

Eh, maybe. I'm not wild about that kind of play tbh. I'm a mafia prude though.

[SirCakez]

Votecount 3.2

Herta (4) - NoPowerOverMe, iamausername, MURDERCAT, Primate

Not voting (3) - EchoVision, Iconeum, Herta

(expired on 2020-11-17 17:00:00) remain until day end

With 7 players alive, it takes 4 to reach a majority.

[SirCakez]

Herta,

Werewolf One-shot Bulletproof,

was eliminated day 3!

Night 3 begins! It will end in (expired on 2020-11-11 19:47:00).

[SirCakez]

Iconeum,

Town Retired Marine,

was killed night 3!

Day 4 begins! It will end in (expired on 2020-11-25 20:12:00).

[SirCakez]

Votecount 4.0

Not voting (5) - EchoVision, MURDERCAT, Primate, iamausername, NoPowerOverMe

(expired on 2020-11-25 20:12:00) remain until day end

With 5 players alive, it takes 3 to reach a majority.

[MURDERCAT]

Great news, good work echo

[MURDERCAT]

No votes

[MURDERCAT]

I think we are 2:1:1:1 right now??

[MURDERCAT]

I was on ico last night, made the most sense. We need to think carefully about both the possible setups and all the claims and associations. Let's not rush this, town can win here

[NoPowerOverMe]

That would mean one of me echo and murder cat is not town.

[NoPowerOverMe]

I would say username or primate is the best elimination here.

[NoPowerOverMe]

Probably username since he most likely has a gun.

[iamausername]

I think we are 2:1:1:1 right now??

extremely doubtful.

either one of the scumteams only had one member, or Primate isn't actually a survivor. possibly both.