Guns & Roses V [Game Over]

[DrippingGoofball]

Reading Tanner's iso, Titusandman looks like a potential partner.

[Dunnstral]

so Akarin and Gamma are town. Which means there's no point for roses to keep their night hidden anymore - I'm a night 1 rose. Did anybody shoot at me?

[Titus]

Eyeballing this, I still want to execute Dunn, provided my understanding of D1 is correct. The choice was Anakin v Mom. Dunn bragging about changing over to a N1 gun isn't a point in his favor given the accuracy of the guns. It logically makes sense on 1.6 that Anakin actually isn't likely scum. 2 scum bussing D1 is a little much.

So if A is town, then objectively scum would be ok with either elim. That means likely scum in Dunn Hiraki.

[Dunnstral]

Titus - Rose
DrippingGoofball - Rose
Gamma Emerald - Gun
Dunnstral - Night 1 Rose
Bell - Rose
Hiraki - Night 2 Rose
Akarin - Gun

[Titus]

so Akarin and Gamma are town. Which means there's no point for roses to keep their night hidden anymore - I'm a night 1 rose. Did anybody shoot at me?

You and Hiraki both claimed nights. That's bad for obvious reasons.

It looks like you’re trying to bait out who is a safe kill.

[Dunnstral]

Right, I was definitely going to be the night kill.

[Gamma Emerald]

Eyeballing this, I still want to execute Dunn, provided my understanding of D1 is correct. The choice was Anakin v Mom. Dunn bragging about changing over to a N1 gun isn't a point in his favor given the accuracy of the guns. It logically makes sense on 1.6 that Anakin actually isn't likely scum. 2 scum bussing D1 is a little much.

So if A is town, then objectively scum would be ok with either elim. That means likely scum in Dunn Hiraki.

This is goodposting
While Akarin is conftown the assertion I made while pushing her that scum would want mom dead over no lim still holds imo. We also have the fact that the last 2 votes on mom were scum contributing to that sense.

[Dunnstral]

I think guns should claim who they shot

[Dunnstral]

did anybody shoot one of uncrowned/abr?

[DrippingGoofball]

Maxwell's reads:

Town reads: Mr Sandman, Hiraki,

Tanner

, DrippingGoofball

Null: Gamma Emerald, Iconeum, JohnnyFarrar

Scum reads: Bell, Akarin, Dunnstral

Strange that maxwell read Sandman, but not Titus.

Other than that I doubt maxwell put two buddies in the town reads, but you never know.

[Bell]

No, Maxwell had me as a hard town read.

[Titus]

I think guns should claim who they shot

did anybody shoot one of uncrowned/abr?

More scumposting.

By revealing who town shot, we reveal if either still has a live gun thus showing who scum need to play towards.

[DrippingGoofball]

JV's iso is nothing, don't waste your time.

[DrippingGoofball]

No, Maxwell had me as a hard town read.

I copied and pasted!

[Titus]

Maxwell's reads:

Town reads: Mr Sandman, Hiraki,

Tanner

, DrippingGoofball

Null: Gamma Emerald, Iconeum, JohnnyFarrar

Scum reads: Bell, Akarin, Dunnstral

Strange that maxwell read Sandman, but not Titus.

Other than that I doubt maxwell put two buddies in the town reads, but you never know.

Post 1106 dgb

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: dunnstral
I think it’s swell that the game where I catch umlaut for pulling the same garbage he did in Surrealism, Dunn also winds up scum with that slot
Iirc they were scum in that game together as well

[Dunnstral]

Who did you shoot?

[Titus]

Who did you shoot?

Do not answer this.

[Dunnstral]

Kill Hiraki and Titus after me. In the opposite order, and we win the game

[DrippingGoofball]

@umlaut, have you read *any* of the game? got any takes for us so far?

Haven't done any reading to speak of, no. I did take a quick look at your own ISO when I was sheeping your vote to make sure nothing screamed scummy to me, and saw a few posts I found towny in tone (67, 149, 232) and nothing that really pinged me, so I'm leaning town on you. My plan is to just read from the point where I subbed in and only go back if something catches my eye and I want to get more info about that. I've found that trying to just "read everything" really just doesn't work, I end up skimming and realizing at the end that I haven't really formed any impressions at all; whereas if I'm looking into something specific I end up reading more intently and actually getting something out of it.

Akarin's Gamma vote makes sense to me, I don't like how Gamma's explanation for voting him is basically "well _someone_ gave a reason for that wagon, as I recall" and it feels more like he's looking for a reason to be on not-the-leading-wagon.

In fact, it makes enough sense for me to
VOTE: Gamma Emerald

I can't even think of a game where I was scum and you were town.

Also, Umlaut’s questions here remind me of a VERY common scum tactic where they try to fish out reasons to figure out the move to make. It’s not just a mafia tell, it also works well in Among Us. If someone acts “who are we voting” close to the end of a meeting, it’s likely they’re an impostor trying to figure out the best vote that they can push.

This analogy is pretty forced. Asking you to justify voting Akarin is completely different in both content and purpose from asking something like "so who are we voting" in general.

Briefly looking in to respond to one thing

@Hiraki what does town!Umlaut look like to you? I personally have a sorta-high bar for him based on recent experience, and his play so far isn’t hitting it.

This actually kind of makes sense given I had some pretty strong moments in our recent games, but lately I seem to habitually find it hard to effort as town when I'm just getting into a game and can take a game-day or more to really start playing actively. Did you not notice this in our games too?

This show Player Slot A chatting with scumpal Tanner.

There is a change GE is bus'ing.

[Dunnstral]

I'm going to assume Gamma shot maxwell. Now we wait for Akarin.

[Gamma Emerald]

I think I’m comfortable keeping my shot a secret.

[Dunnstral]

There is a change GE is bus'ing.

It's not possible for GE to be scum. Take another look at the claims.

There's 4 town roses alive, there's 5 people claiming roses

That means Gamma and Akarin, who haven't claimed, must be guns (scum is lying about being a rose, or is a scum rose, which isn't counted)

[DrippingGoofball]

Nothing noteworthy in Gún's iso.

[Titus]

DGB, there's not a chance GE is bussing or being bussed? GE is conftown?