In post 1939, Andresvmb wrote:I can be both apologetic for being wrong, and continue to push for what I think is the correct solve. I’m not “changing my tune”, I’m playing the game.
And I think it’s mighty interesting that you don’t even consider the possibility that the Scum were bussing. Particularly since (i) Dunn, the claimed Cop, and Fuzzy, Confirmed Town, were not voting, and (ii) the only players voting outside of nopoint were geraintm, me, and nopoint. Is your theory that the entire Scum Team was voting outside of nopoint? Well if either geraintm or I are flipped and we flip Town, your theory immediately goes out the window. Are you ready for that?
In post 1940, Andresvmb wrote:I would also point out that no second wagon gained any traction. That is bizarre for a game with a Scum determined on saving a member of their own Team. We did such a poor job of organizing against a nopoint execution that we couldn’t even agree on the Town that should be executed? Does that make sense?
I just feel like your tenor toward me between last night and now changed really dramatically. I'm not inclined to totally rule out the possibility that scum bussed, but my FIRST INSTINCT on any scum flip is not to look for bussers, and interaction-wise, that seemed less likely. The idea that no other wagon could gain traction is a weird one to me, given you can see we had 3-vote wagons on me, nora, and johnny at one point (and that's 2 wagons on town fmpov, minimum). The wagon on nopoint also happened relatively fast, and it's entirely possible you just weren't prepared for it. Yes, if one of you or gera flips town I obviously have to re-evaluate and I plan to look at everyone again today to cover my bases but I'm just saying where my preliminary suspicions lie.
...I GUESS I could see a world where mafia don't want to vote johnny because they know he's in a hood and think they can pocket him, but eh. Still hard to see nopoint and the shelly slot as scum together. I have no idea what her meta was as scum, though.
In post 2008, PlusJOYED wrote: In post 1754, Insanoflex wrote:For what it's worth, I should disclose that Johnny neighborized me before he died, their hood was basically inactive, they greeted each other but didn't say much otherwise, nopoint didn't put any reads there so there isn't anything to learn from it.
Do think the unwnd/nopoint interactions day 1 are less likely to be s/s.
actually, can you quote what was said? Is that allowed?
I already think you're town but that would help others sort you.
I can't direct quote, per the rules. I can paraphrase but I've told you pretty much all there was to it anyway, they had less than a full page of posts in the thing.
(me being in the hood shouldn't really clear me, anyway, as people have said)
