TM 2021 - Black Flag Nightless

[Firebringer]

i don't wish to bring dishonor upon my team koba.

[Auro]

VOTE: Autumn, Leave

[Firebringer]

VOTE: Autumn, Leave

not a bad vote.

[DkKoba]

VOTE: Autumn, Leave

is this distancing?

[DkKoba]

ill read auros games tomorrow after work and get drunk

gonna be fun.

yall aint ready.

[Auro]

It sure as hell ain't buddying!

You should probably get drunk and then read my games

[Super]

super whats ur read on auro.

I will properly answer this tomorrow, I don't really know what to think of them atm but I'll probably ISO everyone tomorrow and post a mini reads list cos right now I'm heading out and can't be here

[Super]

I know I'm an easy townread

I'm curious - do you really believe this? You did say in your first post that you made 3200 posts in a single scum game and tryharded like a mofo to win.

I do believe this, the game I was scum in was a multi-ball so I had to genuinely look for scum in that game to win; so I was playing very much the same as I would be playing as town in that game

I think I'm an incredibly easy townread as town and I do actually think mafia should be scared of me but this could also all be wifom and I am scum tricking you MUWHAHAHA (but I'm town dw(OR AM I??))

[DkKoba]

super whats ur read on auro.

I will properly answer this tomorrow, I don't really know what to think of them atm but I'll probably ISO everyone tomorrow and post a mini reads list cos right now I'm heading out and can't be here

give me what u think rn like flash read without reading

[Super]

super whats ur read on auro.

I will properly answer this tomorrow, I don't really know what to think of them atm but I'll probably ISO everyone tomorrow and post a mini reads list cos right now I'm heading out and can't be here

give me what u think rn like flash read without reading

town was my first initial feeling

but I'm biased cos they immediately townread me and I'm a sucker for people townreading me

[DkKoba]

i meant reads on everyone

[Super]

i meant reads on everyone

ok from towniest to least i'd go

lilith
koba (this read makes me nervous though)
firebringer (breather? idr)
auro
autumn
chennis


idr who else is in the game cos i have a memory of a goldfish

oh there is amy (amph?) who I played a MU game with so that's exciting but I don't think she has posted yet

[Super]

actually auro over firebringer

[lilith2013]

lol auro I just reread your initial reply to me and you did actually answer. then I got all up in arms about you not answering. sorry

[lilith2013]

can we revisit why you think super's opening post would be an unusual strategy for scum?

[Ampharos]

Hi my name is Amy and I apparently can't do math, because I was 100% convinced the game started tomorrow.

AMA while I gather my thoughts.

[Ampharos]

...and as I say that I realize that my timestamps on this site are an hour ahead of my actual timezone and that nobody's posted for over an hour. Whoops.

guess it's a "rambling into the void" kinda night

[Ampharos]

mmmmmmmmokay, we got enough of a game on our hands that I'm comfortable doing a quick sort

==lean v==

lilith

- Simply put, I think she's been asking the right sorts of questions, and showing the proper amount of care and followup towards said questions. It's easy for scum to just fire off some nonsense questions to try to blend in... but the fact that she's hounding people for answers and seems to be legitimately considering them and following up pretty strongly indicates town to me.

dkkoba

- honestly mostly vibes. I tried to find a concrete thing I could point to but I honestly just think the way they're navigating the thread rn is town-indicative. This is the type of read that always seems to wind up biting me in the ass somewhere down the line but that's future Amy's problem, heh

Super

- This one's cheating because I'm extremely susceptible to people who know how to write more than two sentences in a post, but I think I agree with her assessment that she should be a fairly easily townread (off my whopping sample size of one game lmao) and I'm feelin' it here.

==also kinda lean v but weaker i guess? tiers are fake anyways==

chennisden

- I noted #156 as being a read I thought was towny - I don't think it's necessarily a GOOD read here, but I think it's the type that comes from town more often than not.

Auro

- seems comfortable in-thread, in a villagery sort of way.

==danger zone!==

Firebringer

- Seems to be the sort of poster I always have trouble drawing a bead on, but I feel like the schtick felt a little forced early on, and I feel like his game-relevant contributions have been... easy, I guess? The most against-the-grain thing he's done, as far as I can tell, is locking Auro town, and if he's scum that seems like an easy TMI to make? Just based on the sort of poster Auro seems to be.

Autumn Leaves

(or Infinity, or whoever) - Approach feels somewhat cagey, and if Firebringer is town then I like this slot's posting about koba's "slip" a hell of a lot less - I think there's a tendency for scum to legitimately want to call things townslips if the person doing them is town, and I think that sharing such a thought is an easy way to contribute to the thread without much effort (obviously koba would ALSO have to be town here, but that's not something I'm super concerned about rn). I specify Firebringer being town in this scenario primarily due to the way Firebringer talks about this slot later on - namely, throwing a lot of shade and supporting votes in a way that I don't think is w/w.

===========

that's probably everyone who's posted, I think

I do seem to be on the outside looking in wrt meta stuff - I've got one game with Super, but it was a hydra game, and I've got one game with Auro (and maybe lilith? or maybe I made that up) as part of a THREE-headed hydra and I honestly couldn't tell you whose posts were whose for that one, so I'm not counting it. Kinda refreshing tbh - means I have to rely a lot more on actual analysis than I usually do, especially d1.

VOTE: Autumn Leaves

[Ampharos]

i meant reads on everyone

ok from towniest to least i'd go

lilith
koba (this read makes me nervous though)
firebringer (breather? idr)
auro
autumn
chennis


idr who else is in the game cos i have a memory of a goldfish

oh there is amy (amph?) who I played a MU game with so that's exciting but I don't think she has posted yet

What's your reasoning on chennis?

[Ampharos]

also this is unrelated to anything but koba's avatar is S tier

[JohnnyFarrar]

Heyyyyy didn't realize the game started. Reading momentarily

[Flopz]

What??! No nightkills this game???????????

This post is honestly disgusting and I'm not being facetious here. Next time you want to make a joke please don't make it feel like you scrounged around the place, in the dead of night, hoping to find any lost dregs of humour, brute forcing the pieces together like some bastardised patchwork quilt which you then attempt to bring to life through the couple of torn pages of a really sketchy necronomicon you found shredded by a gutter in the really

bad

part of Town.

This is not a warning, it's a

threat

.

[Flopz]

Btw, I don't like either Johnny or Amp's entrances (hop agrees). Will probably mess about and come up with a readlist.

[Flopz]

Flopz - lower than average poster(as scum at least)

Nah, that's an all alignment thing. In all my games I've been trying to increase my post count but it's hard. Maybe this game'll mark a change, who knows.

[Flopz]

Gonna go through the list I guess.

Chen - Chen's vote on super at the start was a bit weird as I quite liked Super's intro.

On the AL+DK part, 129 and 145 seem to directly contradict one another, unless I'm missing something can you explain what you meant in 129 as Koba didn't give a reason so what explanation of the reason did you not like (or was that about Koba's Super point in the vote post, but not sure why you'd tie those points together)?

Auro v Chen feels eh, tho now looking through Auro's posts, he's really chummy with fire, tho fire also made a comment on Auro's general play-style so this could just be players with history memeing together. Tho I agree with Chen's assessment that Auro feels a bit forced.