Sunny 2: Rules of Im-peachment - Over!

[staypositivefriend]

A lot of Zaidens posts feel like they're trying to project their town game and talk about things they do as town to try and replicate that same energy than just being town. Look at 225 for a good example.

There. 1 flaw. Happy?

zaiden's reasoning for townreading me felt very flimsy. the rest of 225 looks fine to me

[Untrod Tripod]

Votecount 1.2

Cheetory6 - 1 (Spring Breeze)
clidd
Gamma Emerald - 1 (staypositivefriend)
Gypyx - 1 (Jingle)
Jake The Wolfie - 1 (Gamma Emerald)
Jingle
MURDERSUNNY
MariaR
midwaybear - 2 (noraa, Gypyx)
noraa - 1 (PrivateI)
Pink Ball
PookyTheMagicalBear
PrivateI - 1 (MURDERSUNNY)
SirCakez
Something_Smart
Spring Breeze - 4 (SirCakez, midwaybear, Zaiden, Cheetory6)
staypositivefriend - 2 (Pooky, Jake)
Zaiden - 1 (MariaR)

Not Voting - 3 (clidd, Pink Ball, Something_Smart)

Day 1 ends on January 29th at 8PM EST. With 18 alive, it takes 10 to ask someone politely to leave.

If I make a mistake in the Votecount, please PM me or message me on Discord to let me know. Do not clutter the thread with posts about it.

[staypositivefriend]

VOTE: cheetory6

what's pinging you?

this particular string. posts read like they were trying to overplay their transparency

Spoiler:

I think the nice big preprepped post is a common one for scum to ease their way into the game.
Or at least I've done it more than once as mafia and assume others have had the inclination as well.

the point. a-ok!

I think if gamma was dropping that and content then it would be less pingy, idk.
It makes sense in my head!!!!!

Like I'm being imprecise but the meaning should be clear and I think you're being pedantic!
God!

pedantic is like
"oh man technically you're wrong because of this small thing that doesn't matter"

but yeah I'm a little scrazzled right now.
mafia does my brain weird.
I need to go to bed and I'm scared I'm going to total my weekend on this game by overthinking it.
):

okay like the details of
"did they prep it before the game started" or "did they do it as an attempt to NAI crutch into the game" don't matter if the point is that the post is a crutch regardless of the circumstances that led to it and I feel like you should know that and are trying to make something out of nothing. >:c

rest is scumpings

was trying to see if anyone would feel that way, but no one did!

i got the opposite impression from this exchange - it stood out to me that above all else, cheetory's primary concern was making sure that his reasoning was properly understood. i feel like people playing from a scum mindset are more likely to capitulate to people criticizing their reasoning, but cheetory's main reaction was just to get genuinely

frustrated

that their reasoning was being misinterperted and misframed.

this type of emotional concern over the particulars of their reasoning is town!indicative, imo. gth i don't think that scum has that level of emotional investment into having their specific reasoning validated

[staypositivefriend]

VOTE: PrivateI

[MURDERSUNNY]

murder, murder! infinity is pouting at you

Infinity knows me well enough to know I'll obv town when I'm good and ready and not a minute earlier

[Noraa]

I still don't see anything crazy wrong with Private's post. Is it because generally a list mod won't post something flimsy like that? Do I actually have to go meta them?

[Noraa]

The post is flimsy, I agree. I've definitely seen worse posts from town before tho.....

[staypositivefriend]

noraa has come off as really cagey about people fos'ing her/throwing shade on her in this game, and i think that meshes well with the fact that she's still giving genuine consideration to whether or not private's vote on her is scum motivated

i think noraa!scum would be more likely to let people throw shade on private and discredit the person that's actively scumreading her, instead of expressing doubt about whether or not private is scummy. it feels slightly town indicative

[staypositivefriend]

noraa and midway are probably the two names that i townread the most strongly right now. i'm gonna sort out the rest of my thoughts into a reads list of sorts this evening. let me know if there's anything specific that y'all want my opinion on - i work best when i'm communicating and sorting out my thoughts in real time with other people

[Pink Ball]

What's bad about the jake vote?

Timing

[Noraa]

noraa and midway are probably the two names that i townread the most strongly right now. i'm gonna sort out the rest of my thoughts into a reads list of sorts this evening. let me know if there's anything specific that y'all want my opinion on - i work best when i'm communicating and sorting out my thoughts in real time with other people

O_o
I don't like being on the same tier as midway >:(

also I keep thinking ur Saudade!!!!!!!! AHHHHH

[Cheetory6]

also I keep thinking ur Saudade!!!!!!!! AHHHHH

lmfao

[Jingle]

I assume you're referring to the fact it came right after Jake's "I'm a votemagnet" selfmeta. Why is that scum indicative?

[Jingle]

also I keep thinking ur Saudade!!!!!!!! AHHHHH

She is. If you look deep inside, you'll find we're all Saudade.

[Cheetory6]

@spring

can I get a read on PrivateI from you?

[Noraa]

also I keep thinking ur Saudade!!!!!!!! AHHHHH

She is. If you look deep inside, you'll find we're all Saudade.

Woah I didn't know that. Am I secretly Saudade to?

[Jingle]

also I keep thinking ur Saudade!!!!!!!! AHHHHH

She is. If you look deep inside, you'll find we're all Saudade.

Woah I didn't know that. Am I secretly Saudade to?

You can be whoever you want to be.

[Gypyx]

hey, just got my brain fried from watching one of the most boring movies i recall seeing, i'll try to post but prob won't be very productive

[Gypyx]

i don't get what's your point

I think your claim that Jake wanted the wagon redirected anywhere but at Jake doesn't make much sense. I think Jake hopped onto an existing CW with the intent of diverting pressure. Or at least I think it's a possibility.

uhh... no that's litterally the opposite of what i'm claiming


like idk, there's a fine line between scum redirecting the votes one someone else who's scummy, and town who's pushed but also finds someone scummy

[clidd]

Ok, I finished my catch up.

I need some time to work with my impressions.

[SirCakez]

Spring breeze's posting is still pretty scummy

[staypositivefriend]

Spring breeze's posting is still pretty scummy

in what way?

[Noraa]

T^T how come im the only one that does see these scummy posts

[midwaybear]

Also not overly liking Spring Breeze, but that's fine.

What do you mean by this? You don't like someone's posts, but that's just fine because ...

Thought process and the way you get to point A to B seems very...meh

I'm going to assume that you are talking about Zaiden's thought process here, and I'm going to say that I noticed that as well. I've been a bit more unsuspicious because he is relatively new.

what's pinging you about me and why is that fine?

Darn.

So I don't quite understand why there's a push against them. I've looked through their posts and haven't seen anything off.

Yeah, I don't really think my wagon will go anywhere. The longer Gypyx/Noraa votepark me, the worse it looks.

Does no one else seriously think this could be scum attempting to buddy all the girls in the lobby through the power of simping?

Err as scum yeah he tends to buddy and charm his way through games. To be honest, I am a little scared to scumread him I don't think I'm the best at reading him, but he was gut town early on for me.

I think Jake hopped onto an existing CW with the intent of diverting pressure. Or at least I think it's a possibility.

It seems like Jake hopped on spf because he found her vote the scummiest, and I think I townread the process behind that.

Heh, it seems like a lot of people have picked up on that line from PrivateI.

midway are probably the two names that i townread the most strongly right now.

Just curious, how much of this townread on me was influenced by petapan?

let me know if there's anything specific that y'all want my opinion on

What's your read on Jake now?

@spring
can I get a read on PrivateI from you?

I like this.

T^T how come im the only one that does see these scummy posts

lol are you talking about me here?

[Gypyx]

wait wtf where does that spring wagon comes from