This post pinged horribly for me. It seems like a very good way to agree with a consensus TR but then also shade me and all of my reads. And all this rand town stuff is annoying. Feels like you don't wanna commit to a single read.In post 512, staypositivefriend wrote:rand town, iIn post 498, midwaybear wrote:What's your read on Jake now?In post 483, staypositivefriend wrote:let me know if there's anything specific that y'all want my opinion onguess. his reasoning is extremely hard for me to understand but i don't sense any scum intention from his posts. there is a level of internal consistency to their progression from the way they go from questioning gamma on #137 to scumreading them on #168. i also think that they'd be less likely to tell noraa to stop posting so much on #383 if they were playing from a scum mindset - i imagine that scum would be happy to have a player like noraa to distract from the gamesolving
Wow im concerned now. I've never heard Dannflour's name in terms of playing mafia but ik they modded a lot. I expect better reads than this from them and you tbh.In post 518, Jingle wrote:Dann is already proving that he was a valuable pick for our team:
@PB can you elaborate on your early townreads, particularly the Maria one?
We seem to be on the same page that midway is town and Cheet/Murder are lesser-but-still-probably town. Dann likes Noraa and Monty for wagons, and of the two I vibe with monty a little harder.
VOTE: PI
This could easily come from scum but im not sure. Throw it into the SR pile for now.In post 537, SirCakez wrote:I think Midway and I saw the same thing in your opening three posts
Hey Wanna and Pooky .... is this public flirt fest necessary?In post 538, Spring Breeze wrote:well, my heart was always his...In post 457, Zaiden wrote:Does no one else seriously think this could be scum attempting to buddy all the girls in the lobby through the power of simping?
/swoon
hm. I need to think on this. The SR on Cake stays tho.In post 550, midwaybear wrote:I like the way Pink Ball is making his reads, but I also share a bit of Cakez's concern cuz it looks too easy lol.
Pink Ball, were you serious when you said that you were expecting Jingle to scumread you in 447?
*throws murder into town bin*In post 555, MURDERSUNNY wrote:That wasn't really my point, my point was that I thought Jake's vote was opportunistic while under pressure and that the justification given could easily be fake. So now why do you TR there?In post 552, midwaybear wrote:Yeah, you just said you thought he was lying(correct me if I'm wrong). I don't know if there's any argument to be had over that.
This comes from scum more often than not imo. Ik that if my buddy was town and I saw someone steal a beautiful emoji, I'd tell my buddy to kick them. But if I was scum, I'd use it as a slight pocket attempt the way this^ feels.In post 561, Something_Smart wrote:Pooky, lilith would like you to know that she knows you copied the flower girl emoji thing from her.
This is town and im certain of it. TSTBS. This isn't scum.In post 568, PrivateI wrote:I'm hoping to not be phone-posting by the end of the long weekend, sorry.
Spring just has weird vibes for me, specifically the seeming overjustification of their Cheeto vote earlier.
I'm still scum reading Noraa more though, but that could just be because she's saying a lot while saying little? I'll revisit later.
Pink Ball, multiple pages later, how are ya feeling about Gamma?
Sheas on ur team? Oh goodness gracious. I'm gonna get absolutely tunneled aren't I?In post 575, Cheetory6 wrote:@privateI, shea would like to know what your team's experience is with noraa.
Oh this can be town nvm. I like this. Feels simple.In post 581, staypositivefriend wrote:shady & i traded reads with each other from our respective games. i gave him a list of players to ISO (private1, cheetory6, punkball) and i'm gonna paraphrase his thoughts while adding some of my own:
private1:shady got the impression that private is genuinely trying to share the perspectives they have while theyre here and following along on mobile, even if their posts lack substance. he's suspicious of people who are pushing on private too hard and thinks that a push on private will not yield much valuable information right now. i'm inclined to agree - i do take issue with some of private's posts, but they are absolutely a LHF target at the moment, and it's hard to get anything valuable out of pressuring them when they are so disengaged from the broader context of the game. i could see this slot being scum but shady's analysis makes me want to pressure outside
cheetory6:shady thought that cheeto's slot warranted more pressure and suspicion, and there were several moments in cheeto's ISO that he felt iffy about. shady especially zero'd in on cheeto's progression on zaiden - he thought that cheeto treated zaiden's slot in a weird way, and that his vote on zaiden a little while ago meshed awkwardly with the stances about zaiden that he had taken earlier in the thread
i looked into this myself and i agree that the progression is a little weird - the soft defense of zaiden on #425 is uncomfortable given that cheeto did not engage with the cases against zaiden and moreso broadly declared that he will "probably" be easier to read later in the game. in spite of this, they say on #434 that they're willing to pressure zaiden if other scummy slots get townier, and then they end up voting for zaiden on #574. this progression bothers me in the sense that i don't feel like cheeto gave genuine consideration to zaiden's alignment in his build-up to his vote - he felt overly concerned with playing into the dynamic of the thread instead of carving out his own stance
pink ball:shady seemed kind of torn about this slot, and was confused about pink saying on #564 that cakez's read on me was the "best" analysis posted so far in the game. he seemed receptive to the idea that pink was town, in that he thought pink's opening was too scummy to be scum, and he noted that #501 presented a higher level/depth of thought in pink's analysis than had been implied by his earlier posts
I probs skimmed 482. I shall read that laters.In post 597, staypositivefriend wrote:yup. i explained it a little bit on #482In post 596, Pink Ball wrote:Noraa?In post 593, staypositivefriend wrote:i started writing out a big list of reads and then realized that making analysis of 17 different players barely over 24 hours into the game is a wildly unnecessary waste of my time and energy in a game with a 2 week deadline
so instead, i'm just gonna focus on finding solid townreads that i can trust and use as a foundation for the rest of my solving in this game. the two names i have right now are noraa and midway. i would like to expand that another couple of names by the time today ends
This is town and im pretty sure of it too. Again, feels simple.In post 612, Gypyx wrote:mostly thinking about Post 581 from SPF when saying that
i know that's an answer, but idk, it just sounds really focused on not getting heat?
idk if my 7 in the morning brain makes sense tbh
I think this is town too. Straightforward and simple.In post 619, Spring Breeze wrote:VOTE: zaiden i guess i dislike your vote on me the most.
reconsidering cheetory. i like his good faith to me and his haphazard randomness is quite townie. uncrowned also started reading the game and said he felt the same pings on midway early on and that hard push would probably be what he did if he was here.
speaking of midway, i agree with the townreads. i have little meta, but he's a strong PURE read for me. even his latest posts where he says his hot take of gamma town and then voting him 2 posts later. scum... probably don't do that
NANCY ILYSM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!In post 629, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:nancy says noraa is 100% obvtown and there is no way noraa is scum here.
koba says spf is meta-scummy for being agenda-y and trying to maintain herself above a POE.
oka poka didn't say anything.
he's actually been pretty in your corner this game.In post 657, Noraa wrote:Sheas on ur team? Oh goodness gracious. I'm gonna get absolutely tunneled aren't I?
Very surprising. I can throw you in the town bin then. This felt genuine.In post 660, Cheetory6 wrote:he's actually been pretty in your corner this game.In post 657, Noraa wrote:Sheas on ur team? Oh goodness gracious. I'm gonna get absolutely tunneled aren't I?
Changed my mind. I have a lot of threads I gotta do today. Gonna finish this one up rn.In post 635, Zaiden wrote:I've played with some strange people. But some of you take the cake for strangest people I've ever played with.
*snip*
I do love throwing a dash of AtE into posts just as a little treat though.In post 662, Noraa wrote:The reason it felt genuine is cuz you probs could've thrown a pinch of AtE in there if u wanted to but you didn't.
mmk. I can trust in this judgement. I suck at reading MariaR. I 10/10 would've thought she was scum in Xeno if not for the fact that I was scum and knew she wasn't.In post 642, Cheetory6 wrote:old bones.
I guess you could say this makes Noraa solid townIn post 646, Pink Ball wrote:I'm townrleaning you and I trust Nancy's read on noraa, that's the kind of 'obtown!Nancy correctly identifying town' moveIn post 629, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:nancy says noraa is 100% obvtown and there is no way noraa is scum here.
koba says spf is meta-scummy for being agenda-y and trying to maintain herself above a POE.
oka poka didn't say anything.
, but I don't really think this means anything for Pooky's alignment. 
yesIn post 618, Spring Breeze wrote:was this to me? i can't engage with you if you're gonna be like that and i'd like to cause i feel like there's no substantial reason to scumread me right nowIn post 537, SirCakez wrote:I think Midway and I saw the same thing in your opening three posts
why do you feel the need to vote someone on your wagonIn post 619, Spring Breeze wrote:VOTE: zaiden i guess i dislike your vote on me the most.
reconsidering cheetory. i like his good faith to me and his haphazard randomness is quite townie. uncrowned also started reading the game and said he felt the same pings on midway early on and that hard push would probably be what he did if he was here.
speaking of midway, i agree with the townreads. i have little meta, but he's a strong PURE read for me. even his latest posts where he says his hot take of gamma town and then voting him 2 posts later. scum... probably don't do that
scummy
what does this mean?In post 657, Noraa wrote:TSTBS.
uh no?In post 666, midwaybear wrote:I guess you could say this makes Noraa solid townIn post 646, Pink Ball wrote:I'm townrleaning you and I trust Nancy's read on noraa, that's the kind of 'obtown!Nancy correctly identifying town' moveIn post 629, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:nancy says noraa is 100% obvtown and there is no way noraa is scum here.
koba says spf is meta-scummy for being agenda-y and trying to maintain herself above a POE.
oka poka didn't say anything.
Disagree that Zaiden reads genuine literally anywhere.In post 668, SirCakez wrote:what does this mean?
Zaiden 635 reads super genuine
@Cheet why did you suddenly start efforting on page 26
Hi Morning Tweet
I woke up, had a nice bit of coffee and decided I felt like reading the game like a good boy instead of just reacting to things.In post 668, SirCakez wrote:@Cheet why did you suddenly start efforting on page 26
Hm? What do you mean? You think Pooky is town?In post 669, Noraa wrote:uh no?