i think this works better if you dont warn scum in advanceIn post 3052, Noraa wrote:I didn't give any reasons for anyone to TR me. I'm literally looking specifically for SRs on me.In post 3051, Gypyx wrote:you're more likely town, but not for what you advancedIn post 3048, Noraa wrote:wow that was helpful you just told me that I could be town or scum.
I am coming at it from a different perspective.In post 3073, Morning Tweet wrote:I touched on this but i think roughly around the middle of the wagon the elimination was quite likely to happen and if it didnt then it was certainly a forever thing that several players would push i think. i dont see the incentive for scum to bus more than rand% of them already being on the wagon
but again nobody ever agrees with me on this so maybe i just undervalue the importance of votes. What makes scum more likely to essentially join a wagon that is going thru than not? It would do nothing for their looks and in my opinion it doesnt really mean anything at all, it's like executing an order
The fact that PI did not actually join the wagon here is not a good lookIn post 3071, Morning Tweet wrote:>PrivateI thought there was scum in PB/SB, with the recent case he is inclined to swap to SB probably, mentions he would likely generally buy his case. Eh eh eh
Also not greatIn post 2009, midwaybear wrote:UNVOTE: lol
Talked with team about this a bit. Given my other reads, I wouldn’t be too opposed to voting Spring Breeze. I’m not going to yet.
Oh I totally missed this.In post 2068, PrivateI wrote:I think it's just that--I don't think PB AND SB are scum, and I was more inclined to think PB is scum at that time. I could probably be persuaded on this, especially after the events of the last day, where I've liked a lot more of what PB has to say, and I think their case was something I'd generally buy.
i agree that PB pulling SB into the spotlight is particularly unlikely as a distance move, not only is that a waste given the other wagons, but now PB is going to be watched for the rest of the game, and if he's scum, it will be odd after a while when he stops catching scum and never gets NKed. generally when someone plays confident like they've got to solve before dying on the first day, its been from townZaiden wrote:Actually something struck me as really strange. If scum wanted to bus, why bus their strongman? Surely it would make more sense to bus a goon or something?
That's what makes me think it probably isn't Pink Ball. And that scum only followed onto the bus once Pink Ball's case made Spring Breeze's elimination seem inevitable.
WHAT AM I WRITINGIn post 3084, Morning Tweet wrote:of course, if that isnt the impression you guys had im willing to accept im wrong, maybe there was more uncertainty regarding the elim than i got from it. I'm not contesting that there is scum in the wagon cause out of 10 players with me Murder and Noraa not on, then for sure yes
It does seem like Private thought that PB/SB was some kind of scum/town interaction, so I think it makes sense?In post 3082, Cheetory6 wrote:I personally can't imagine being like "oh wow this person made some scummy posts but this person is MUCH scummier so that means that the former is probably more likely town". You don't have the flip of the second person in your hand so I would think it's more likely that you just scumread both.
It's also the kind of post I would make as town.In post 3081, SirCakez wrote:Like that's the kind of post scum makes to start distancing while holding off in case the wagon/case goes away
Yeah although i suppose the question is why is there an arbitrary "1 scum in PB/SB" line being made, that which i would like to pose as a question to Private probably if he remembersIn post 3086, midwaybear wrote:It does seem like Private thought that PB/SB was some kind of scum/town interaction, so I think it makes sense?In post 3082, Cheetory6 wrote:I personally can't imagine being like "oh wow this person made some scummy posts but this person is MUCH scummier so that means that the former is probably more likely town". You don't have the flip of the second person in your hand so I would think it's more likely that you just scumread both.
he apparently never faced scum!kanna so that's a reasonable explaination whyIn post 3088, Morning Tweet wrote:Yeah although i suppose the question is why is there an arbitrary "1 scum in PB/SB" line being made, that which i would like to pose as a question to Private probably if he remembersIn post 3086, midwaybear wrote:It does seem like Private thought that PB/SB was some kind of scum/town interaction, so I think it makes sense?In post 3082, Cheetory6 wrote:I personally can't imagine being like "oh wow this person made some scummy posts but this person is MUCH scummier so that means that the former is probably more likely town". You don't have the flip of the second person in your hand so I would think it's more likely that you just scumread both.
The other thing I want to hear about is why Pooky's soulread failed. how. how could it !?!? I dont really know if that makes sense as question but its on my mind
Okay but like when you have that kind of assessment you usually say "I think there is one scum in this grouping and I scumread both". Monty's outward facing reasoning on Spring suggests that she should be a scumread, and the implication is that because Pink Ball is a stronger scumread that makes Spring a townlean but I don't think anyone actually reads the game like that as town.In post 3086, midwaybear wrote:It does seem like Private thought that PB/SB was some kind of scum/town interaction, so I think it makes sense?
well, if you got a S/T read that seems reasonable to me yes?In post 3090, Cheetory6 wrote:Okay but like when you have that kind of assessment you usually say "I think there is one scum in this grouping and I scumread both". Monty's outward facing reasoning on Spring suggests that she should be a scumread, and the implication is that because Pink Ball is a stronger scumread that makes Spring a townlean but I don't think anyone actually reads the game like that as town.In post 3086, midwaybear wrote:It does seem like Private thought that PB/SB was some kind of scum/town interaction, so I think it makes sense?
I do follow you and I agree that outside of you there's no real coherently townie read progression from anyone else that followed because they all followed on from you, SPF and myself included. But I think some votes particularly stand out from the 10 players. Are you seriously going to tell me and others that our vote is equally as shady as MariaR's vote? Because from my perspective, no fucking way.In post 3093, Pink Ball wrote:If you guys don't start treating me like the IC I am right now I don't even know what's up with you. The level of paranoia you guys are having is not townie, is not "hey I have to consider ALL alternatives because I don't have all the information!", it's plain stupidity. My case is not scum bussing other scum; I DESTROYED SB. Absolutely demolished her. And I gave her enough space to feel comfortable and give us hints on who her teammates are.
Murdersunny, step up dude. Yes, scum probably voted SB. Do you think the best approach to this day is to look at 10 players? From my perspective, all votes after mine are absolutely NAI because SB would never come back from the case I made; as I already said, I destroyed SB. Read SB's ISO again and you'll get a far better and narrowed down playerlist to focus on.
That is all. Stop fucking around.
No that wasn't the main reason. The main reason was that kanna reminded me of myself in Mini 2 something.In post 3074, Morning Tweet wrote:i think that noraa's defense of SB due to the particular reasons she had that made her feel very sure was very towny. something that she thought was exclusive to town gave her great confidence in the read, aka the fruits. I dont think she would think to fake that