Sunny 2: Rules of Im-peachment - Over!

[PrivateI]

I'm up to 121 and also my Internet is out today but I will keep reading as I can in between contacting Cox.

Y'all. I hate phones.

I got one peach last night.

[PrivateI]

Update: it may not have been a peach? It doesn't specify. It just says a particular variety. Do the rest of y'all's specifically say "peach"?

[Cheetory6]

+1 peach for gyp should be added so that's 13-15.

I think that fakeclaiming a fruit-target could end pretty badly, especially since mafia would be able to narrow who could be lying about targets via number of received fruit.

[Morning Tweet]

i didnt get any peaches if that was missed

murder's case is pretty towny for murder, and my dear teammate infinity says he sees his soul with his cake questioning. i can't comment about cakez though because i don't know him well. based on this game alone, i'd still say he was towny.

i think pooky is town again due to soulmeld but no good reason

i decently liked s_s when he got involved earlier

for pink ball, i do think i was biased with yesterday. i felt like he was really selective with my posting to put me in the worst possible light. gut says it feels unfair, but brain thinks it could be genuine if i think about it from his shoes. i don't know what else to say here, i am biased

i skimmed the rest of the thread and i'm generally, i'm feeling this

{murder, noraa}
{pooky, cheetory}
{gypyx, zaiden, s_s, sircakez, morning}
{pink ball, mariar, midway, spf} --- null
{jingle, private, jake,

gamma

}

feel free to ask me to elaborate on any of these

wow look at SB's iso and CTRL-F Gamma, there is 0 reasoning for this lol

i think that looks better for S_S, probably worse for gamma if she never mentions him

[Pink Ball]

Zero reasoning for PI too. Exactly the same

[Morning Tweet]

SPF's reads are basically consensus, I dont think analyzing her reads will be extra helpful beyond mayyybe if she had 1 or 2 players in the bottom half slightly lower than other people did? So something you could kill and get away with not being noticed - that i think is a stretch though

oh Shirou read thru my game the other night ! He is pretty happy with my townreads, Pink/Noraa/Cheet/Zaiden were his strongest. He liked most of Jingle's posts and midway's early posting. Murder/Pooky are above random town for him from behaviour towards SB wagon

his PoE is MariaR/Private/Gamma and maybe one of SS/Jake but not the both of them

He notes that he was excited with Cakes on scum!SS but the way ss acted around SB made him less interested there, and Cakes he had as a townlean but ended up less sure i think

also an extra thing for Noraa: Shirou says every game he's played with town!PB he suspected or caught a scum on the first day or two so this sequence of events doesnt surprise him, and he says you should definitely give him space

[midwaybear]

Update: it may not have been a peach? It doesn't specify. It just says a particular variety. Do the rest of y'all's specifically say "peach"?

You might want to ask the mod about that.

[Pink Ball]

Shirou is a sweetheart as always

[Noraa]

both of my peaches were specifically labelled as peaches.

[Gamma Emerald]

PB, you're acting very weird. Can you cut to the chase, please?

[Gamma Emerald]

eh, could we get more content in before we APtL red peoples?

if you think private is scum, why would you say this?
We get scum day 1 and 2 ... doesn't really matter if we don't get much info - we literally will have like tons and tons of lims to waste.

I have seen towns waste such a lead in the past

[Gamma Emerald]

her scumrange is p much infinite
any time she says she's "outside of her scumrange" it's bs

but that doesn't mean she's scum yet

I think Gamma is scum for this post

why

I'm really just ripping into mariar for the halibut (plus it's fun to get her goat)

[Untrod Tripod]

Votecount 2.2

Cheetory6
Gamma Emerald - 1 (MURDERSUNNY)
Gypyx - 2 (Noraa, Gamma)
Jake The Wolfie - 1 (Jingle)
Jingle
MURDERSUNNY
MariaR - 2 (midwaybear, Zaiden)
midwaybear
Morning Tweet
noraa
Pink Ball
PookyTheMagicalBear
PrivateI - 4 (Cheetory6, Pink Ball, SirCakez, Gypyx)
SirCakez
Something_Smart - 1 (MariaR)
Zaiden

Not Voting - 5 (Jake, Morning Tweet, Pooky, PrivateI, Something_Smart)

With 16 alive, it takes 9 to ask someone politely to leave. Deadline is February 11th at 10PM EST.

[Jake The Wolfie]

Praise the sun, the VC is back!


\o/

[SirCakez]

I like Cheet telling Jake to stop shitposting and play the game

Why?

Because Jake's playstyle right now is blatantly pro scum regardless of alignment

p-edit: ya I think you may be on to something with the pink ball townread idk just call it a hunch.

lol this is exactly what I noticed too, I think Gamma could be scum here

Oh do you?

[SirCakez]

pink ball
noraa
cheetory
zaiden
midwaybear
pooky
murdersunny
morning tweet
gypyx
jingle
something_smart
mariaR
sircakez
private1
gamma emerald
jake

roughly where i've landed. i'm sure i'm misreading a couple of people here, but that's standard for d1

killed for reads?

Nice catch
The bottom five (aside from me obv) are all in my pool today so this makes me feel good

[SirCakez]

Gamma went mostly ignored day 1

[Something_Smart]

I continue to not think that spf was killed for reads given how similar they are to everyone else's.

Maaaaaaybe the Gamma read, but that still feels like a stretch.

[SirCakez]

Creature thinks Cheet, Murder and Gamma are town

[Noraa]

If you're a PR just lie about sending a fruit to someone you trust or something idk

that won't work cuz numbers don't work like that.

[Noraa]

Pink ball hurry say you received 6 peaches

[Gypyx]

and what about the elements i pointed out?

your PR's activated by fruit alignement is also wrong as we already claimed fruit anyways, and i don't see a world where some town roles are activated by specific flavor

FV knowing they were RB'd isn't particularly useful for town, given they wouldn't know who rb'd them or why. It is potentially useful for scum deciding who needs to make the NK if there's a town RB.

If the number of fruit received is roughly the same as the number of players (one or two less at least), claiming the sending of fruit probably doesn't out any PRs. This is corroborated by the SB flip being a multitasking PR and FV, as PB mentioned. Unless it turns out that 14 or so peaches were received what we've already claimed is more than ample for D2.

I have seen no indication that scum would have multiple kills in this game so far, and until there is such an indication I don't think it's wise to try to play around it.

As far as specific fruit being PRs, there is a chance that say, golden delicious apples (obviously not a type of peach) are actually doc shots that show up as fruit. Or some other form of invention. I don't know that scum doesn't have a method of trying to narrow down PRs based on peach flavoring, and I don't see a reason not to play around that.

alright that's fair

[MariaR]

From Mena: @S_S Why was PB holding the game hostage a bad thing?
@Gamma This is not how I played in Ruby, besides that game is ages ago and has very little resemblance of my wolf game now anyways. It's funny that you think Maria would just do whatever I want as a wolf here, rather than her setting the entire pace. If she was a wolf she would just wouldn't pass along my msgs if she didn't want to or at least modify them to her liking.
Finally duh I wasn't in Xeno but there's this thing called 'gamings existing after they end' and 'isos are a thing'. Maria and I disagreed about Norra's play so she linked me to Norra's scum game in Xeno and I started to notice her doing things where she calls the wagon on her buddy on D1 trash and goes “omg how could you vote cakez, he’s so obvtown!?!!” (You remember this don't you Cakez? ^^) Hey guys, what is Norra doing this game? Exactly that.

[MariaR]

As for me I'll post more myself tomorrow. Long work day

[Something_Smart]

@S_S Why was PB holding the game hostage a bad thing?

Because it wastes everyone's time. I thought that he was preparing for some big thing, which would naturally make me not want to really get engaged with the day before seeing what it is (because obviously it would matter a lot for the course of the game). Seems like I was mistaken there, though.