Titus v Nancy Drew (Game Over)

[clidd]

By the way, I'm playing drastically different here, Nora.

[Batsunami]

I'm pretty burnt out atm. That was a pretty crappy wagon sorry guys. Morning will be steering the wheel for a couple days while I recover. Anyways I probably won't be posting but I'll be reading.

I'm tired.

[Red Eye Knights]

Kinda tired out, I'll be back later maybe.

Except later won't be tn.

- Darth Roast

[Nancy Drew 39]

I don’t know how night skip helps scum because nightkills are usually bad for town. Probably to annoy people - more likely.

Power roles sorting things out at night. Day 1 is when town has the least info

That's not to say I necessarily think it was a scum role that caused this

When people count miselims, they usually take into account the nights.

[Batsunami]

I'm pretty burnt out atm. That was a pretty crappy wagon sorry guys. Morning will be steering the wheel for a couple days while I recover. Anyways I probably won't be posting but I'll be reading.

I'm tired.

[Morty and Rick]

BATTLE MAGE I SWEAR TO FUCKING GOD IT WASN'T MY FAULT THIS TIME.
This is literally my first post on the account this game and I've got 86 pages to read soonish.

(I am quite aware of the irony of my slot being one of the first votes on a D1 BM mislynch but I PROMISE you, it wasn't me THIS time...)

[Red Eye Knights]

I'm pretty burnt out atm. That was a pretty crappy wagon sorry guys. Morning will be steering the wheel for a couple days while I recover. Anyways I probably won't be posting but I'll be reading.

I'm tired.

It's okay Noraabear!

A wrong wagon on D1 was very likely.
Sorry your tell got disproven (or simply mal-applied?).

Go relax tho, reset yourself, and return fresh and ready to conquer the evils which plague this thread!

- Darth Roast

[Morty and Rick]

(Auro and I haven't talked because I was without internet from Friday to Monday and I've been busy and we didn't get a PT until Tuesday and I've not gotten into this game yet but soonTM it'll happen.)

[Gamma Emerald]

BM, Nora, Italiano and W/P are likely town.

pedit: @Dun No, I mean that he's not saying what he truly thinks/knows. The point of view he is trying to show is posed.

what drove this townpool?

Initial impressions.

That seems extraordinarily weak given the focus on those slots

[Nancy Drew 39]

BATTLE MAGE I SWEAR TO FUCKING GOD IT WASN'T MY FAULT THIS TIME.
This is literally my first post on the account this game and I've got 86 pages to read soonish.

(I am quite aware of the irony of my slot being one of the first votes on a D1 BM mislynch but I PROMISE you, it wasn't me THIS time...)

Let’s hope that you are steering this hydra then. I <3 Auro but not sure I trust his reads.

[clidd]

Ok and what do you make of it, Gamma?

[Red Eye Knights]

mastina's here! =D =D

[Morty and Rick]

BATTLE MAGE I SWEAR TO FUCKING GOD IT WASN'T MY FAULT THIS TIME.
This is literally my first post on the account this game and I've got 86 pages to read soonish.

(I am quite aware of the irony of my slot being one of the first votes on a D1 BM mislynch but I PROMISE you, it wasn't me THIS time...)

Yay, Mastina is here!

My vote on BM was because I felt he was being very political, at first. Sorry about that >.> Please steer for us lol!

-Morty

[Nancy Drew 39]

Sorry everyone, I don’t mean to be so salty. I know you did your best, I just really hate miselims. :/

[War and Peace]

Would anyone else like to chime in on the points that I'm making right now?

I think I commented on this partially in my last post, but my impression is that Batsunami (more specifically Noraa) is sometimes more emotionally driven. Simply repeating the same question again and again doesn't help anyone; it just clutters the thread and makes people annoyed. You assert that this is potentially a scum tactic, but what does she gain here with this tactic? Do you think it's worth it for scum to make an enemy this early on?

It is easier to shut me off than it is to engage, and easy to drown out with other interactions if I am unwilling to keep calling her out on it.

On the contrary, you are drowning the thread by continuing to espouse this rather than letting it go.

Ircher feels very tonally different from his townmeta. No crank, no snark, all politics.

No quote walls...

At the time I was posting, there was less than 7 pages, and I was actually around at the beginning of the game. The quote walls serve as a mechanical tool to not spam the thread while giving people my thoughts on past stuff.

Also, please actually scumhunt and not make surface level observations like this one.

Also the title for this one is kinda out of order compared to other Versus games and it throws me for a loop somewhat

Yeah, I noticed that too. It took me a while (during signups) to realize the proper stump roles.

May I suggest ItalianoVD?

Awful suggestion. Their posting was purposefully flashy and showy. I'm not saying it couldn't come from scum, but that alone is hardly a good basis for a scum read.

Fey and Batsunami are both town probably. Batsunami for 275 particularly.

Why 275 specifically? I've seen Noraa invoke AtE as scum, so I don't think that 275 is particularly town indicative for them. (Other posts, sure, but not that one.)

No. I am not going to do that. I would rather you post while annoyed as that will give us a better grasp on how you're really feeling, as things such as that are harder for scum to fake, right?

This is really flawed logic. I've seen countless scum fake emotion and anger, especially recently. Some are admittedly better than others, but it's far from being harder to fake. (I should clarify though that I don't think she's faking it here. That still wouldn't, by itself, clear her, but it also doesn't necessarily mean she is scum.)

As much as I currently SR ircher, I agree with this.

This seems a bit contradictory; do you care to elaborate some?

And then sherlock is pushing him hard for some reason

This by the way is a good point; I find Sherlock's attention on Italiano very questionable.

Although that was almost 3 years ago, I remember he hates playing scum.

I still don't particularly like playing scum, but I would advise players to not use 3-year old meta... because it's 3-years old. I have more recent scum games as thoroughly documented on my wiki page.

nora, sam, pooky, auro, pooky, akarin, clidd, and dunn

You listed Pooky twice. Why?

To bottom of page 15. I realize I'm still very far behind. That's probably not changing until the weekend (Saturday specifically), so it would be great if we don't add 40 pages a day.
~War

[Gamma Emerald]

Hey now there Akarin

I was never masons with you lmao

And I've never been hydras with Fey

Huh, didn’t expect to get a clue on Fey like this

[5uffering]

I think what I'm most disturbed by is the skip. I like to use the night to rethink a few things, but now I just want to resolve another D1 thought I had. This D2 doesn't feel like it actually happened yet and it's throwing me into a loop.

[5uffering]

UNVOTE:

For now.

[Gamma Emerald]

Ok and what do you make of it, Gamma?

Kinda think you might be scum who tried to score points off townblocking those slots
I’m definitely not acting on that yet, mostly because I wanna see how the votes worked across D1

[Morty and Rick]

Mastina, I don't really put a lot of stock into my reads but I have {5uffering, Gamma} as my top two scumreads at the moment.

I have an idea about who 5uffering is, and the way in which he's playing here doesn't square with how I've experienced town!him playing. His stances just feel weak, and look like a mimic of how he plays as town.

Gamma's pop-in at the BM wagon (something along the lines of "why were people saying he was hammered") without posting anything else feels very scummy. As I recall, he has a slight tendency to address posts in catchup walls as opposed to direct engagement. Please do have a look at these two ISOs.

Pyro is near townlock

for the way he's playing [given he is who I think he is].

Batsunami is townlock

simply for Noraa's extreme conviction - and the additional factor that as scum knowing BM was town, I doubt she would've stuck to the whole "BM is being good and towny and therefore is scum" argument through the day.

Pyro/5uffering: do you mind if I tell Mastina in our PT who I think you are?

-Morty

[Morty and Rick]

Let’s hope that you are steering this hydra then. I <3 Auro but not sure I trust his reads.

Izzok once Mastina begins posting I'm gonna slip away to my hydra PT :3

-Morty

[Gamma Emerald]

Hmm I guess I could add Pyro to that but that would probably out his main

Hm
This makes me less sure about Pyro’s ID
but I might have a good idea about Fey’s

[Red Eye Knights]

ftr I don't like Alt Hunting but have at it I guess.

I won't take part in those proceedings.

[5uffering]

This game is forever sworn to secrecy. I'm playing a bit more experimental, and want to keep it that way forever. I trust the two stumps do not reveal me post-game either.

If you think I'm someone, I'm probably not. If you think I'm not someone, I probably am.

[Gamma Emerald]

he has a slight tendency to address posts in catchup walls

This is kinda bullshit
The most I’ll wall when catching up most times is by doing one or more pages at a time with a few quotes at once
And it generally takes me time to start posting anything more than a single response at once