My ISO/our opinions might look confusing because we haven't made some things clear
So let's make it clear:
First of all, shirou was the one mostly helping me in my game and he thought from D1 that it was Pine/FL, with the caveat that there could be from 1 to 2 scum in [DEB, Akarin, Ramcius] depending on Pine/FL flips.
That's why in D1 / D2 / D3 start i was focusing on Pine/FL, because it was Shirou that was mostly helping in my game and i thought their solve seemed good.
Later, JJH did read the game around D2 EoD and started to help us out intensely in D3, while Shirou got bored from the lack of progress in eliminating from their solve and stopped checking.
JJH think it's likely Pine/Ramcius, but in reply to Shirou’s theory of Pine/FL, he says that it's not impossible. It is likely just Pine/Ram though.
At the time when Ram was pushing for the TSQ elim, it was the winning move for a Pine/Ram scumteam since FL was the likely final elim, FL has just not played in a way that resembles a winning scum strategy today at all, which indicates it's not scum FL.
Is Pine scum? Yes. Both Shirou, JJ and also me have always believed so.
Is Ramcius scum? Yes absolutely, it is the unique slot that makes the most sense as Pine’s scum teammate. And they are the one pushing For scum!Pine’s plan to endgame.
Is FL scum? No, he is howver. A huge detriment to town, as Pine has pocketed him and he is pushing scum’s agenda. Howver, he is making one crucial difference, he is pushing me today. Which is not the ideal elimination for scum!Pine. And also we have agreed that both Pine/FL being scum makes little sense mechanically. Which is very possible. In which case FL is the town stooge and scum team is exactly
Pine/Ramcius
.