Mini Theme 2210: The Deck of Astral Roles [Game Over]

[Guillotina]

The only brainshocker in astral deck is this

viewtopic.php?p=12723698#p12723698

[Dunnstral]

Town Brainshocker

(Town / Brainshocker)

Once per night, you may target another player and cause their action(s) (if they have used any) to be redirected onto themselves.

[Raya36]

Why did you target me N1?

[Dunnstral]

Why did you target me N1?

You had exactly 1 post and it felt scummy so I went for you. Not much else to go off of.

[Dunnstral]

The fact that ircher's kill didn't go off means that my role is proven

My alignment isn't, but I don't see the reason that everyone ran me up to e-1 anyways

[Titus]

The problem I have with that Dunn is there's only 2 KPN

So there's three possibilities

1) You're lying (the most likely)
2) Scum shot Ircher simultaneously.
3) A protective role saved a scum kill.

Occam's Razor says you're lying.

[Dunnstral]

I also asked a lot of questions about ircher but none of them were "why did his kill fail"

[Guillotina]

I'd be damn cause he caught both yeeted scum themselves in their lie.

[Dunnstral]

The problem I have with that Dunn is there's only 2 KPN

So there's three possibilities

1) You're lying (the most likely)
2) Scum shot Ircher simultaneously.
3) A protective role saved a scum kill.

Occam's Razor says you're lying.

If I had an extra kill, there would have been three people dead. I redirected Ircher's shot to himself.

[Titus]

The fact that ircher's kill didn't go off means that my role is proven

My alignment isn't, but I don't see the reason that everyone ran me up to e-1 anyways

This is false.

You could have targeted Ircher with a scum kill and Ircher's kill was somehow blocked, or on SirCakez

[Raya36]

Why did you target me N1?

You had exactly 1 post and it felt scummy so I went for you. Not much else to go off of.

What was scummy about my post? Also are you implying the fact that I only had 1 post is scummy?

[Guillotina]

My last post is not a defense but we cant lie thst he catching both scum in their lie looks good no?

[Dunnstral]

The fact that ircher's kill didn't go off means that my role is proven

My alignment isn't, but I don't see the reason that everyone ran me up to e-1 anyways

This is false.

You could have targeted Ircher with a scum kill and Ircher's kill was somehow blocked, or on SirCakez

What faction of scum?

Because I discarded werewolf, and the mafia probably performed the janitor kill

[Titus]

Given Ircher was town, I am actually rethinking massclaim now with 2 kpn. I think we still eliminate the guilty here but we need to force scum's hand.

[Dunnstral]

Why did you target me N1?

You had exactly 1 post and it felt scummy so I went for you. Not much else to go off of.

What was scummy about my post? Also are you implying the fact that I only had 1 post is scummy?

Considering the flipped player was 3rd party I wasn't giving you any points for sheeping onto that

[Dunnstral]

It's pretty obvious that ircher didn't shoot at sircakez

[Dunnstral]

Given Ircher was town, I am actually rethinking massclaim now with 2 kpn. I think we still eliminate the guilty here but we need to force scum's hand.

Yes we should massclaim, and also I shouldn't be at e-1 so we don't lose instantly

[Titus]

The fact that ircher's kill didn't go off means that my role is proven

My alignment isn't, but I don't see the reason that everyone ran me up to e-1 anyways

This is false.

You could have targeted Ircher with a scum kill and Ircher's kill was somehow blocked, or on SirCakez

What faction of scum?

Because I discarded werewolf, and the mafia probably performed the janitor kill

You could have rolled 2 wws, be an alien or you and the janitor had to act separately.

I know I got you visiting dead in multiball. I don't need much else.

[Raya36]

Why did you target me N1?

You had exactly 1 post and it felt scummy so I went for you. Not much else to go off of.

What was scummy about my post? Also are you implying the fact that I only had 1 post is scummy?

Considering the flipped player was 3rd party I wasn't giving you any points for sheeping onto that

Reasonable but that doesn't answer my question. What about my post was scummy? Why did you choose me of all people to presumably potentially kill?

[SirCakez]

Bah humbug love y'all good luck!

[Dunnstral]

I'm also unlikely to be an alien because I immediately pointed out what was wrong with cook's claim, which he likely would not have botched up if we were together

And bussing is a lot less likely in this setup

And is there a mafia role that lets them perform two kills? otherwise I can't be that

Me rolling werewolf twice is possible but for occam's razor, unlikely

[Titus]

Then who is scum Dunn?

[Dunnstral]

Why did you target me N1?

You had exactly 1 post and it felt scummy so I went for you. Not much else to go off of.

What was scummy about my post? Also are you implying the fact that I only had 1 post is scummy?

Considering the flipped player was 3rd party I wasn't giving you any points for sheeping onto that

Reasonable but that doesn't answer my question. What about my post was scummy? Why did you choose me of all people to presumably potentially kill?

The fact that you had one post and it was you joining the wagon, and it wasn't main faction scum, looked bad for you. I'd only kill you if you performed a kill yourself.

[samantha97]

VOTE: dunnstral

[samantha97]

it's too convenient to target the dead guy with brainshocker

I think you picked it to appeal to me because I posted it