3d20 – The Great Board Game War [GAME OVER]

[Dwlee99]

What did you think was scummy about mega?

[Dwlee99]

Also totally onboard with policying Thor because I'm kind of annoyed with the "I'm going to play anti-town as town cause I can get recruited." He did it as town before so he could be town here but I don't really want to play with that schtick again.

[SirCakez]

I'd be down with voting Thor, James, or Cyrus if any of those end up being the only viable lims; I'm assuming I'm off about the no lim thing but I'm interested to hear what people think about it.

Cyrus claiming VT makes that a fine alternate to the no lim because he's either lying or we don't have to worry about limming a PR

Oh on ISO I realized MegA basically didn't post anything I think I confused their posts for someone else. Basically null then.
But Gamma is scummy anyways.

[Gamma Emerald]

It's cause I always roll town.

bruh my last game together u were scum lol
btw i'm not going to be using meta here because its been a lil while and I don't remember it that well after such a busy summer

If this was Titus I would be locktowning her for this

why?

It's taking an obvious joke and shading someone for it.

didn't read like a joke to me at all

V/LA until Sunday

I'll try to do a catch up tomorrow though. Realize I'm several pages behind

How long does it take to read 9 pages?

if you're not skimming, it can take 15-20 mins. at least for me.

@sircakez

talk about your kyouko read a little more?

their posting feels really manufactured and LAMIST-y
like it's not genuine, just going through the motions

jamesthenames: probably scum, but could be improved town
cyrus: scum

how are you reconciling this considering James is tunneling cyrus?

I lied about not using meta. I do remember that Hunter played a really...interesting game as town in a game I modded he is definitely limbait. not really eager to go there rn.
I don't think Cyrus is scum. at least definitely not cult and I want to get the cult today. so not interested in a vote there either.
tbh still think ssbm is the scummiest person and could definitely be cult.
either them or someone who isn't posting a lot.
dwlee is being kinda useless it could be them tbh
we could also just PL Thor for 290 lol

Can someone ELI5 why Roberts roll claim makes him scum

Can someone ELI5 why Roberts roll claim makes him scum

It's a low chance that he rolls the same role that Thor did. Far more likely he lied about what he rolled and to avoid getting caught outright later on, he stole someone else's roll (Thor's) so it would be a 1v1 at worst. If RMH had claimed before Thor I'd be saying the same thing about Thor rn, in reverse.

Odds of rolling the exact same role seem lower than the odds of him being scum trying to hide what he really rolled (possibly a decent scum PR that one of his buddies or he ended up with)

ok I can see this argument

VOTE: RMH

ngl this progression on robert feels pretty bad as well
I'll admit my read rate of cakez hasn't been the greatest but I feel like I'm tuning into the right signal by choosing to follow my scum feelings on him

[Gamma Emerald]

I'd be down with voting Thor, James, or Cyrus if any of those end up being the only viable lims; I'm assuming I'm off about the no lim thing but I'm interested to hear what people think about it.

Cyrus claiming VT makes that a fine alternate to the no lim because he's either lying or we don't have to worry about limming a PR

Oh on ISO I realized MegA basically didn't post anything I think I confused their posts for someone else. Basically null then.
But Gamma is scummy anyways.

-_-

[cyrus62]

VOTE: cakes your omging needs work. @ dragon of the west. i stated no one should claim anything and that i recommend every one claim vt also i have shown countless of times why vt can exists so calling me a flat out lire here is kinda of offensive.

[cyrus62]

and fyi i get very angry very fast for being accused of lying. i mean very fast.

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: cakez

[Thor Ragnarok]

Also totally onboard with policying Thor because I'm kind of annoyed with the "I'm going to play anti-town as town cause I can get recruited." He did it as town before so he could be town here but I don't really want to play with that schtick again.

I am not doing that and I never stated I was going to do that. The fact this narrative has been spun somehow truly baffles me. I will once again reiterate:

While town, I will be playing for the TOWN. I will be voting who I think is scum, and not playing anti-town.
If I get recruited, I will start playing for whatever faction I am recruited for.

Who came up with this narrative in the first place? Because whoever did is very likely scum.

[Thor Ragnarok]

Nero and Robert are both scum

[cyrus62]

only 8 of the 13 roles are reliable so nic picking is kinda low. you remove the cult the scum rolls that leaves 5 town roles we can count on.

[Thor Ragnarok]

Once again: I am not deliberately playing anti-town or playing worse on purpose

[SirCakez]

How is this omgus? I was calling Gamma slot scum before they even started pushing me.

[SirCakez]

What's wrong with my Robert progression?

[Gamma Emerald]

What's wrong with my Robert progression?

feels like your initial townfeels on him or whatever caused you to resist were just for show

[Thor Ragnarok]

redtea posts a lot of nonsense and asks questions without follow ups, especially recent posting but his earlier posting is solid and legit, he's probably pushed by scum. Thor is the worst and some of his posts have a cult feel. His role is interesting, he doesn't know how to use it, we probably should eliminate him today for that etc. The wording here "If you want to vote me out because you think scum will recruit me" really pings me because he says scum instead of cult. It's a sign of deception.

VOTE: Thor

This is such a bad post. Let's repeat Robert's reasons:

-Thor is the worst and some of his posts have a cult feel
-His role is interesting, he doesn't know how to use it, we probably should eliminate him today for that etc
-The wording here "If you want to vote me out because you think scum will recruit me" really pings me because he says scum instead of cult. It's a sign of deception.

1) Some of my posts have a cult feel because I've spent a lot of the game talking about cults? Well done for noticing that, Robert. Bravo.

2) My role is interesting and I don't know how to use it, so I should be killed for that? How is this a town thought?

3) We don't know if there's a mafia or werewolf recruiter as well as a cult one, what is he talking about?

VOTE: Robert

[Thor Ragnarok]

And let's be real, he's only voting me because the only scumread I expressed before was him.

[Dragon of the West]

VOTE: cakes your omging needs work. @ dragon of the west. i stated no one should claim anything and that i recommend every one claim vt also i have shown countless of times why vt can exists so calling me a flat out lire here is kinda of offensive.

Cyrus, this whole game is based around people lying. I don't really know what to say if you're so fragile being scum that you have to lash out. But my point wasn't that you were definitely lying; it's that if you're lying about being VT then I'm fine limming a liar and if you aren't lying then limming an unhelpful, anti-town VT is probably the best mislim we could have

[SirCakez]

What's wrong with my Robert progression?

feels like your initial townfeels on him or whatever caused you to resist were just for show

Somebody explained why he was scum for mechanical reasons, my tow read was based on other things. How does that not make sense?

[Gamma Emerald]

still doesn't feel right
I'm trying to listen to my gut more and my gut is telling me you're scum

[cyrus62]

VOTE: cakes your omging needs work. @ dragon of the west. i stated no one should claim anything and that i recommend every one claim vt also i have shown countless of times why vt can exists so calling me a flat out lire here is kinda of offensive.

Cyrus, this whole game is based around people lying. I don't really know what to say if you're so fragile being scum that you have to lash out. But my point wasn't that you were definitely lying; it's that if you're lying about being VT then I'm fine limming a liar and if you aren't lying then limming an unhelpful, anti-town VT is probably the best mislim we could have

tell me what is smarter play here stating you have a role on the list so cult or scum know where to aim or saying you anit on the list so scum doesn't aim at you. anti town? this whole game i been trying to help town by showing why the mech talk wasn't helpful. all it did was waste are time and leave us wondering what 5 roles can trust with out even knowing what or who we can trust.

[cyrus62]

then you have Thor how has he helped oh he claimed his role was on the list? a weak role something scum will pass over in hope of hitting a pr that does help town. if anything james , redtea cakes or thor are best eliminations.

[Marashu]

3) We don't know if there's a mafia or werewolf recruiter as well as a cult one, what is he talking about?

What makes you think there is?

[Gamma Emerald]

hold on

what

[Gamma Emerald]

3) We don't know if there's a mafia or werewolf recruiter as well as a cult one, what is he talking about?

I may be missing something but I think there's no chance of a mafia recruiter by the setup?