Not Quite Normal Multiball II (Game Over)

[MonkeyMan576]

I could see Klick as the fourth werewolf.

[Nero Cain]

remind me who you think the other 2 are?

[MonkeyMan576]

Dunnstral and Menalque

[Nero Cain]

I mean, that's like not outside the realm of possibility tbf, but the progression was confusing - 1705

I mean yeah. It still feels like he's mad @ Nashville for floating the idea of a catboi elimination after town reading him and just throwing shade.

Scumreading butterchurn is unironically the towniest thing mastina has posted

would love to ask Catboi why its townie of Mastina to scumread Butter

[butterchurn]

Well, I asked for you. See post 2197.

[butterchurn]

Also, Nashville's switch from believing the wagons were counterwagons to MonkeyMan to saying they were counterwagons to catboi was absolutely an unsupported and scummy progression. She failed to explain it until several days later and the explanation wasn't even that good. Saying that Well Done was criticizing the progression because they were upset with the switch to catboi is absurd and a false narrative.

I still believe we had 2 scum wagons Day 1 on catboi and Nashville, and that's why the game stalled out for so long. I think the Nashville wagon would have gone through if that slot was town. Instead it met significant resistance, which wasn't seen with the wagons on people like bnuuy, tictac, and Toogeloo. This, to me, is evidence that Nashville is scum and those three are more likely to be town.

[Nero Cain]

If Nashville was scum she only has 3 buddies. Are you telling me that 3 scum are in control of the game?

What about the other not Nashville wagons, did they all fail b/c they are scum?

[butterchurn]

Enough to affect whether a wagon goes through, same as with catboi. Which wagons, specifically? I brought up the 3 that I remembered being most prominent, and they happened quickly.

[butterchurn]

Looking back, the only other prominent wagon I see was on MonkeyMan, and that could be on scum, yes. It gained a certain amount of traction but never close to enough, and it never felt like there was a lot of scum piling on the wagon to push it forward.

[Nero Cain]

Are you tr'ing cass?

eh....

Didn't really like the blank vote in 5229. In hindsight maybe it wasn't that bad b/c she just wanted the day over.

Although I feel like she kinda contradicts her reasoning

Agree w/ butterchurn that toogeloo is the scummiest lurker, if we want to do a lurker push that one i could maybe get behind.

this is unequivocally a stupid compromise wagon, but i need the day to be over and for us to get some actual mod confirmed info or i think my head is going to explode

5044 is what made me think she's a possible catboi buddy and why I had her as a wolf in a reads list or 2.

I do like her first point on bnunny in 6147 but I still massively disagree that we are unable to scumread Meg just b/c "it's her policy". Coming in @ 195 pages and going "hey, lets spend more time!" It looked like an attempt to cause even more apathy. It wasn't pro-town in the least to just ignore what was happening and I legit felt like her just sticking to a script. Maybe you could argue that she's just not very good @ reading the room but it wasn't a pro-town play in the slightest.

She seemingly had her in her lean scum pile which is ???

I sorta like her sheeping me on Dunn though you could argue that scum are theoretically sheeping me.

[Menalque]

So there are two people voting me now who absolutely refuse to explain why they think I am scum

it’s almost as if there are 8 players here who didn’t get a town role PM

[Menalque]

Man I’m so disappointed I didn’t get to roll wolf this game

[Nashville Dreams]

Butterchurn engaging in revisionist history is cute and a flagrant attempt to discredit anyone who can't be a wolf.

Without even cite checking, there's bullshit that a) the only other major wagon besides myself and catboi was MM, b) the wagon on us immediately dissipated when Ydrasse entered/Norway exited which meant scum could no longer hide on that wagon, c) butter is objecting to me using wagon momentum and claiming lack of progression. His original vote was because he didn't like the catboi vote.

My bet, without proof, is that the wolves jumped upon me when they saw an opportunity due to my prior RL and EE pushing heavily. They did not expect EE to leave and thus make their parking obvious.

[Nashville Dreams]

Actually, I did check the receipts on the disintegration of my wagon and there's an alternative. Maybe people unified behind EE because they were obviously town and wanted to progress things. With EE leaving, there was no reason to stay there leaving the scum out in the cold rather than the scum immediately bailing. That makes more sense with my reads but could be me forcing things onto my reads.

[Nashville Dreams]

Nashville Dreams (4) | butterchurn, Well Done, catboi, Cat Scratch Fever

This is the last few people hanging on from yesterday. We know catboi was scum. We know butterchurn was on almost every counterwagon to catboi there was, if not every wagon, we've been over Dunn's problems and that leaves CSF. While CSF doesn't have the same gaping holes, CSF hasn't been a beacon of towniness either.

[Nashville Dreams]

I gave butterchurn chances to defend catboi because their vote position was crap and I got semantic deflections instead

[Dunnstral]

we've been over Dunn's problems

I don't think we have

You quoted two wagons, neither of which I was a part of, and then voted me

[Dunnstral]

Oh and I'm maliciously asking the same question twice while pretending I didn't see the answer the first time in this 265 page game

Have you ever seen scum do that ever? Why is that scummy?

[Klick]

So there are two people voting me now who absolutely refuse to explain why they think I am scum

it’s almost as if there are 8 players here who didn’t get a town role PM

Klick liked this post

[Nero Cain]

meh it was an ok post.

Also Klick, you are scum reading CSF right?

Why did you vote FL at the end of d1 instead of Toog?

[Menalque]

Klick do you wanna start a new faction with me where we win if we manage to make the game fun again?

[The Keeper]

$20 says he is "roleblocked" tomorrow.

If he is I will trade my red health for all black.
But what do I get from you?

[SCP 682]

Man I’m so disappointed I didn’t get to roll wolf this game

woofy post

[SCP 682]

snip

This post really just made me want to vote Klick tbh

yeah the "you only talked about Klick" thing was kind of just... not true, but tbf, you said that Mena was lurksack, which is also not true given he has hundreds of posts

Well Done was really town day 1, and while the slot has fallen off, I think that could also be a function of it just being one head now instead of a hydra

name a significant take that menalque has expressed

catboi town LOL

my point exactly

[Enchant]

I think game stagnating.