HMS Mutiny [Game Over]

[Gimli]

I am Miller.

That is all good night.

100% believe you

[Gimli]

early townread on HPE, it's feeling good and swaggy

VOTE: radical rat

Is commenting on the picture in our role pm allowed??

angleshooting already like a true pirate

Let us trust in the heart of the cards

Town locked

I feel it

the pirate roleplay is making my eyes bleed.

so that's page 2

[Gimli]

Scummy+low poster lim > scummy+high poster lim > anyone else

omg imagine this idea of playing mafia well! frogster, this isn't the place for that.

early townread on wayward for their opening and their townread on HPE

I don't like passenger's vote on HPE cause HPE gave me the opposite impression - of vibing as town - and, IDK. I like that wayward is throwing suspicion at passenger in #91 and feel stronger that wayward's play is coming from a townie.

#94 by frogster is a glorious post, I like that he stopped scumreading wayward in it and I like the points of view on both flea and elements. I'll go back to that post later on.

further pushing elements in #99 is also very good.

[Gimli]

VOTE: elements

either started incredibly slow or is mafia.

pending a read on the rest of the game but I can't do that now.

frog/nancy, wayward, HPE are townreads

[Enchant]

You can't use swear words in pirate themed game

That's... F... Friking... Sad

lockscum

[Malakittens]

Might just vote std just to move this game on.

This is legit just focusing all time and energy

Like come on

It’s getting in the way of hunting imo

Also my cat just bit me while I was sleeping so here I am awake when I need to be up in 4 hours

I think I'm right about Dragons because I remember Dragons feeling like they were more helpful than this as Town. I kind of read them like Gamma where if they feel helpful then I think they're Town and if they feel disruptive then I think they're scum. How strong would you say you Town Dragons right now? I'm not inflexible.

Here's the thing:

You/Flea/STD has taken up a bunch of the thread. The thread won't decompress unless something is done. As much as I hate it eventually this is going to happen. You are the towniest of everyone. I don't really have much experience with flea so i'm not really sure to gather to fae's alignment. As for std is my weakest of all the reads.

Replacing Andresvmb. He may no longer post in the thread.

CAN WE JUST ELIMINATE THIS PLEASE.
IT'S GOING TO FLIP SCUM.

"THE SHARKS, THEY ARE NOW CIRCLING,
THEY ARE WAITING TO BE FED,
THEY WANT TO SEE THE SEA ITSELF
TURN TO A BLOOD RED"

[Gimli]

CAN WE JUST ELIMINATE THIS PLEASE.
IT'S GOING TO FLIP SCUM.

I'm here and I'm town, so you're wrong and you're not only wrong but you're loud about it. now be a nice miller and let me play the game without shouting in my general direction.

[ActionDan]

I have been abandoned cries

Mala is right though this is Andres scum meta. I do happen to like gimli's content posts since it's almost about where I was page 4. We'll see if that holds when he gets to page 20

[Malakittens]

CAN WE JUST ELIMINATE THIS PLEASE.
IT'S GOING TO FLIP SCUM.

I'm here and I'm town, so you're wrong and you're not only wrong but you're loud about it. now be a nice miller and let me play the game without shouting in my general direction.

I'll do whatever I feel like.

[Gimli]

Because I was asked to explain my vote and I don't want to for reasons provided in the post you quoted?

And now nobody will talk about your vote anymore but about your secret reasons. I dislike STD's p5-6 stuff, it seems out of character but let's see where this goes.

[Gimli]

I’m like the killing joker posts for town. Mainly because I know frogs meta and this is definitely the town game.

As for STD I was back and forth tryingest to figure out his alignment in my brain. His early game felt more scummy, but as this day is progressing I’m going back to a soft town read. I don’t std scum would make a vote like this right now.

@STD, you’re claiming a reaction test on our slot? Yes? In what universe did you not think, that I would not find that suspicious? Now that that game has ended, town!STD did exactly the same thing in the Temple game, so because he had never actually done it before - despite it being beyond silly and lame - still bought it as authentic but there’s pretty much no way in hell, STD expects me to seriously fall for it two games, back to back.

VOTE: STD

oh my.

another thing that brought my attention to STD's early behaviour - hiding thoughts and whatnot - is that it feels like he is trying to keep interactions to a minimum, and that while doing things that are supposed to get him townread. it feels like he is trying to enter the game by looking town rather than doing solvy things like he's supposed. his reaction to elements finding his behaviour strange feels a little out of place as well, like he is already feeling pressure. it doesn't vibrate like carefree town would, and I think STD is a pretty carefree player in general.

[Gimli]

1) Why did Dragons vote our slot seemingly out of nowhere for absolutely no reason?
2) Why is Elements suddenly going out of their way to push Dragons and white knight our slot?
3) Why is Dragons pretending to be agitated for absolutely no reason or provocation? (137)
4) Why does Dragons play make no sense internally based on what he claims to be doing? (133)

I dislike your conclusion, Mala, because it completely overlooks the only logical conclusion about Dragon's play: it's an obviously scummy move which gives Elements an excuse to push Dragons and set her own slot up for endgame. There is literally no other reason, Town or scum, for Dragons to play the way they have over the last couple of pages.

also feel like elements/STD interaction has a high SvS equity.

do we keep playing d1 or just sheep killing joke hydra?

[Gimli]

137 is the hint

VOTE: STD

[Gimli]

hydra too strong

[Gimli]

also think I'm clearing wayward regardless of elements/std's alignments

[Gimli]

Read up.

VOTE: StD

First, this isn't a reaction test if he's willing to use associatives to divine a read on Elements 137. So let's make this simple: It's a bad vote against someone likely town. If there was "something to see" show us.

Town reads on RR who has essentially spent his time chastising someone in role play mode for voting a no Elim do not make sense to me.

Bella, what makes RR's posting a different caliber to eria's?

Flea's 111 sucked.

I think wayward has done alright extricating himself. I'll choose to believe his posts at face value.

Elements' posting leaves a lot to be desired but I'm not getting particularly strong scum feelings from them either.

this guy is also town

so mala/killing/Action/wayward all town

[Gimli]

Also I think HPE could be scum but I forgot to mention that earlier and that above post doesn't help

why is that?

[Gimli]

If posting Harley gifs is really keeping you from reading me than I can stop but after I saw Joker doing it, I thought it looked kinda fun. \_0_/

I mean we're here to play a game and have fun, the Harley thing you have going on is more than the gifs.

I'll work it out either way, we're still early D1, there's time yet.

What is it yer seein' here Flea? I've tried movin' me patch to each o' me eyes but can't see anythin' out o' the ordinary with Harley

We talk regular out of game and have played enough games together that of all people - Nancy is the person I'm most confident I can read quickly and accurately.

You start RP'ing and that's a barrier between the players and you - I should know, I do it on alt accounts for giggles sometimes. There's nothing off about Nancy here, and I'm wanting to try and lock a read on her ASAP - meaning the hydra is my current objective and sole focus where I'm going to put my energy.

If she's red, the RP can potentially stop me getting that red read on her, muddy the waters a bit and leave me still questioning.

If she's green and I get to a point where I can lock that in, her knowledge can help cover my blind spots (such as Mala and probably others) as I know I can then trust her reads.

I think that makes sense but the problem with what you're saying is that harley isn't hiding behind a cover, her posts have 0 roleplay (as opposed to all the pirates posting for instance) and so I don't feel too good about you talking about the images they're posting like it's hindering your ability to read harley.

[Gimli]

This is just typical scum assigning busy work to Town while contributing nothing. I'm not doing chores for a slot who actively refuses to commit to a single read on any player in the game. Your ISO is atrocious. Harley said you would be AI over time and by God she was correct. Your next step as scum!Flea--since your faux pas attempt to pocket me in 191 has failed--is to chainsaw us for Dragons. You are fence sitting ALL OF YOUR READS while you wait to see how much you have to commit in order to save Dragons. How convenient your reads are ambiguous when wagons are taking shape and how quickly they will form soon once it's clear who you need to push in order to create a counter wagon for Dragons.

my god man stop solving

this game is stupid, I wanna be miselim'ed d1 like my slot was going to, to counter balance a hydra pair that is town and has precise meta reads on half the playerlist

[Gimli]

so ok there's three scum outing themselves to the hydra pair in many pages of this game. I'll skip the rest cause this will not be fun for many gamedays.

which one are we killing?

[Gimli]

HPE is town so mala/killing/Action/wayward/HPE all town

[Gimli]

eiralox town

[Gimli]

STD's vote on HPE = lockscum status and who we should eliminate today

[Gimli]

hydra dissonance in page 15: I think harley is letting caught scum talk themselves out of earlier more organic posting that denounced their affiliation. talking it out is easy and you're inviting that by bringing up past games and other things that are unrelated to this game. the fact is, std/elements/flea all joined in against your hydra like an actual pack of wolves. they made no attempt at solving each other and voted you out of spite. Maybe being inside an hydra head it's harder to feel confident about it, but as someone kind of reading on the sidelines it looks very clear to me how it happened and the rest of this game will be all about getting you n1ed and making sure nobody will understand early game enough to vote them out.

[Gimli]

it's page 16 and flea doesn't realise STD is scum yet. I don't buy it.