HMS Mutiny [Game Over]

[Gimli]

Hi.

I was drunk yesterday and didn't read anything when I dropped a Titus vote.

I do not have any grudge against std, I really like playing with him and just thought he was scum in this game. Saying I have a grudge and playing spiteful would mean I'm not playing to win as well, and that's not something I will ever do. But even if I was it wouldn't be to STD cause I have absolutely nothing against him.

Will try to read the gameday now.

[Gimli]

Eh, more interested in action Dan/flea rn? Eira seemed more buddy as scum but this is only on one games meta.

Do you think Eira ruffled feathers on D1? That's not the impression I got.

Amusing, your blind eye on Elements and Titus.

Curious even.

Killing Joke, Eira, Gimli and Erynis is such an easy thing to say at this point that, if you're a mutineer, you're not even trying.

You haven't factored in the passenger death here. As a mutineer..... meaning most of your friends were on passenger.

But as crew it might mean you still hold to your old emotional ways. Might mean you concluded that those four the dirtiest and just haven't factored in Passenger's death yet.

Yet you were hidden yesterday, and not to be trusted yet, in my estimation.


We'll see.

You're still my top townread, eira

[Gimli]

Thread too cluttered to read in one go, actually. I'm back later.

[Gimli]

This one is going to be busy for a bit so it will place it's vote now so as not to be wholly useless until its back.
VOTE: Killing Joke

Ok I lied and am reading through. This feels opportunistic.

[Gimli]

So continuing with the trend from day 1

Still heavily scumreading you Elly

Can I call you Elly?

Either way your tone in posts like these is one of a wolf and I see you were all snarky on D1 cause you knew we'd all look like imbeciles regardless of the flip.

[Gimli]

Damn.

KJ look real bad and Eira still won't vote them.

Elements, talk about that visit.

My read is that BBT is still town and will have a hard time leaving the KJ tunnel

I hope I'm right on KJ. It felt like town the entire D1, and I swear I'm strong townreading everything Nancy posts in D2 even if it's a little unfair to gamma who just replaced in

Also: hi gamma! Good to see you here

[Gimli]

Passenger was a vig shot.
UNVOTE:
While Nancy isn’t strong with mech I also think she’d be stronger with it as scum between the Xenoblade 2 fiasco as well as seeing her in FFXIV

Whatever gets you to a KJ townread, but I wonder if actually thinking scum would kill passenger isn't sort of faking cluelessness? It doesn't take much mafia experience to understand mafia isn't killing limbait counterwagon like this

[Gimli]

Also someone please tell me who claimed to vig Passenger?

Nobody needs or should claim the passenger shot

It came from town and it's outing a power role

[Gimli]

I want HighPrincessErinys and BBT. I can't see any reason I'm killed if they aren't scum. Enchant and Elements are ok compromises but I'd hope to see something in my reads on my last day.

VOTE: HighPrincessErinys

You're the captain titus

[Gimli]

MY BAD

You dumbass

Jk

We still got this

[Killing Joke]

Gimli what do you think of Rats push on you?

Passenger was a vig shot.
UNVOTE:
While Nancy isn’t strong with mech I also think she’d be stronger with it as scum between the Xenoblade 2 fiasco as well as seeing her in FFXIV

Whatever gets you to a KJ townread, but I wonder if actually thinking scum would kill passenger isn't sort of faking cluelessness? It doesn't take much mafia experience to understand mafia isn't killing limbait counterwagon like this

I think Gamma looks fake yeah

even if it's a little unfair to gamma who just replaced in

Objection! I think town!Gamma is eager to get reads and share their opinion. Gamma had the better part of a night phase to read the game.

[Gimli]

@Rats, @Gimli, @BBT

Can you Town case yourselves?

I don't do the towncasing myself, and I prefer being suspected and eventually wagoned cause it helps solving the game

Pedit: idk, could be scum. I hate the D2 posturing of HPE, RR, BBT, elements, but don't think they're all scum for it. BBT at least reads like town.

Lots of limbait on D2 if passenger wasn't flipped already, so it makes sense that scum would come to the thread wanting to frame me, you and eira especially

[Killing Joke]

Okay so do you have any reason to suspect Gimli did that on purpose rather than being wrong town?

That opening post. It was flagrantly manipulative, not inquisitive, or really even accusatory. There's been basically no effort at sorting or any kind of actual traceable thoughts. Just joined the game, started pushing Townies in the worst way possible, and then rode out the day.

What about the general sense from Gimli's posts that they believe in what they're saying?

[Gimli]

hello friends who's mafia

Is this 'that opening post'? @RR

[Gimli]

They poisoned titus cause all the loud townplayers were voting STD and having a crappy day. The poison went for titus to antispew.

[Eiralox]

I misunderstood the setup. I obviously don’t want to know anymore, duh.

~H

I need to know how you don't seem to know about the black spot if Joker acted like something they weren't?

The entire pivot of Joker's plan, from a crew perspective, is to be cursed by the blaggards' dark magic? To let the muteys waste their efforts on lesser crew? Confirming yourself as crew, making hunting muteys easier.

Like it's possible but honestly strange.

Another factor: Joker saying there are five mutineers. I had my own reasons to suspect this, but now with ya'll claiming yer a Loyal Sailor, the 'there's five mutineers' needs to be explained.

[Eiralox]

got quotes wrong quoting Killing Joke

[Eiralox]

that's kind of obvious? yeah.

[Gimli]

One question I have to Harley to the post eiralox quoted is how did you understand the setup earlier, that you thought outing the vig was somehow a good idea?

[Gamma Emerald]

That’s specifically because I’m not gonna put much effort into this game rn and that surpasses my current effort allotment by a long shot
You may get it eventually, but I’m not gonna try to accelerate it at all.

Okay, why not? How do I know you aren't just scum copping out by saying "I don't want to put a lot of effort into this game"? How am I supposed to tell the difference between your play right now and scum?

idk, meta?

Not happening anytime soon, pal.

Why not?

Because I don’t want to.

Okay, aren't you a player who presumably takes pride in their Town game and had the better part of a night phase to read the game?

Maybe I used to but putting my ego into games seem like a fast track to getting toxic. So I’m trying to avoid it.

[Killing Joke]

I want HighPrincessErinys and BBT. I can't see any reason I'm killed if they aren't scum. Enchant and Elements are ok compromises but I'd hope to see something in my reads on my last day.

VOTE: HighPrincessErinys

How does that make sense exactly? What exactly makes you think that this one or BBT would absolutely have to be scum for you to be the nightkill, especially when this one hasn't really interacted with you to begin with?

How do you account for all of these posts after Titus soft inno’d us, yet you don’t unvote us and say absolute nothing about that?

Because this one doesn't innately believe you not having visited anyone makes you innocent, at least from the impression it gets of how Tracker and factional kills work. Claiming some nebulous PR that somehow magically had insight into Fenrir's role on D1 so you could try and get him elimmed is also just a bluff that is making it extremely wary of you, town or not.

Oh cool I was actually doubting my vote earlier thinking that maybe HPE missed Titus’ soft inno claim. HPE can die now. lol

~H

[Killing Joke]

Frog coming in with all of these questions instead of answering the things that have been levelled at him is not a good look.

Why is it a bad look? That’s pretty much town!Joker in every single game.

[Killing Joke]

On a broader scale, Gimli is my most confident scumread and I am trying to get him eliminated. On a right now right now scale though, I'm mostly waiting on Elements.

Long-term focus is probably just going to be normal scumhunting. If we're lucky, Titus isn't the only investigative. If we're not, we're on our own from here on out, and it'll come down to the usual stuff. Dissonance between words and actions, associative tells, consistent bad faith pushes, etc. In particular your slot is very high priority for sorting, and we do seem on the cusp of figuring that out.

His vote on bleeding obvtown!Titus was through the roof whack but it’s just such a godawful vote, it reads tstbs to me because it’s that terrible. But meh?

But it’s probably objectively the worst vote in the entire game thus far.

[Killing Joke]

This one is going to be busy for a bit so it will place it's vote now so as not to be wholly useless until its back.
VOTE: Killing Joke

Ok I lied and am reading through. This feels opportunistic.

So continuing with the trend from day 1

Still heavily scumreading you Elly

Can I call you Elly?

Either way your tone in posts like these is one of a wolf and I see you were all snarky on D1 cause you knew we'd all look like imbeciles regardless of the flip.

Well obviously vibing with both of these but happy with my vote since HPE outright scumclaimed.

[ActionDan]

Will post tonight after work. Titus being the kill makes 0 sense to me I guess good job getting a pr.

I have a lot of this game as town, I'm going to soft reset