Mini Normal 2289 - Postgame

[Cephrir]

VOTE: enchant

[T3]

Reads changing from one post to the next is fine, but there should be a consistent thread that you can follow to make sense of the person's thought process. T3's reads have been... well not that.

what do you think about my content today?
also, can you point to some specific examples. i know there's the alchemist one but i think i already explained that.

[furtiveglance]

[Cephrir, Not_Mafia, T3] = >1 Mafia

[Cephrir]

cool why tho

[furtiveglance]

Why not

[Cephrir]

I hate all of you

[PenguinPower]

[furtiveglance]

Penguin can you towncase Cephrir

[PenguinPower]

No.

[PenguinPower]

And I don’t mean that as in “No, I won’t” I mean it as “No I can’t and I’m not strongly townreading Ceph”

[furtiveglance]

You could be persuaded then

[PenguinPower]

It would be difficult to persuade me to join ceph’s wagon today.

[Cat Scratch Fever]

UNVOTE:

[Cat Scratch Fever]

[Cephrir, Not_Mafia, T3] = >1 Mafia

Who else is scum?

[furtiveglance]

[Cephrir, Not_Mafia, T3] = >1 Mafia

Who else is scum?

I think Eiralox, Penguin and Dionysus are town so everyone else. Maybe you

[Cat Scratch Fever]

Why is Dionysus town?

[Cat Scratch Fever]

How do we feel about Enchant? Alchemist died voting for them.

VOTE: Enchant

One dead town said Enchant was scum, and the other dead town said Enchant was town. Why are you sheeping Alchemist over Frogs?

[furtiveglance]

Why is Dionysus town?

For being a thoughtful young man, and for voting T3

[Cat Scratch Fever]

Can you quote some of these good thoughts?

[furtiveglance]

Ok so this game has barely moved since I last checked in despite the several new pages. Some high-level thoughts on the main wagons atm:

STD - I didn't like #15, its troll nature felt kind of insincere, but it was page 1 so whatever. But since he has sort of floated and not said anything useful which is +scum. I don't wanna join this wagon though as I want something more damning than a page 1 post lol.
Furtive - I don't understand these votes someone enlighten me please
Eiralox - honoured that half of their posts are about me? The obsession. The focus on my vote and why it is there is kinda weird ngl and maybe +scum. Although I literally just as I am typing this checked the vote count again and saw that the other vote is a self-vote so that explains it, they are just sensitive. Anyway I assume the obsession is to find out why my vote is on them. Well I thought it was obvious at the time but I didn't like how they sheeped my MT vote
T3 - Why do you think this post is scummy #45

VOTE: T3

Eiralox you can relax now

Way to walk into a beetlejuice at the exact moment I was becoming paranoid about you, Dionysus.

If you were suddenly put into a Final 3 between alchemist and NM, who would you hammer and why, Dionysus?

It's not a trick question, I am actually comparing between those two right now.

This is addressed to you, Dionysus.

why these two

Process of elimination! I'm wrapping up my team solve for tomorrow morning.

Nothing particularly pings me from alchemist apart from him saying fewer posts = better for him. Because it is true that more posts = more hunting. But I can also relate to this because coming back to 7 pages of shitposting made catching up a chore. But it's not optimal for town to have fewer posts, so I don't agree with him posting it and it is +scum. Hardly a smoking gun though.

NM has 3 posts or so and they're all spam. So I can't make a judgement call on them. On the basis of what I can see between them I would hammer alchemist but I think it would be 50/50 a mislim due to lack of content from NM.

So my main take away from the last few pages is:

1) frogster vs Cephrir is really fucking funny. Thank you so much for replacing in as it has made this day very entertaining
2) frogster is going to extreme lengths to dig up dirt on Cephrir which I think is very +++town. It means he legit believes in his read because if Cephrir flips town then this would look so bad.
3) I townread alchemist already but I definitely feel sure he is Town now. He has been engaged and scum hunting and I have liked his analysis. So not that the question is relevant anymore if I had to hammer either him or NM I'd go NM.
4) I still think Cephrir is scum
5) although I think Cephrir's enchant analysis is interesting
6) this could be svs but it was largely ignored or disagreed with so maybe they are wrong

[Cat Scratch Fever]

Dionysus is probably scum for pushing someone for being "inconsistent" instead of actual scummy behavior. Town is more likely to be inconsistent, since they're not overly concerned with image, and less likely to spend time making sure their own reads are consistent.

Spoiler:

This push on Enchant seems like Alchemist is caught scum trying to divert attention away by starting a 1v1? Maybe?

Was this post an actual scumread? Because if it is then this:

VOTE: Eiralox
I think I'm gonna put my vote here for now.

is weird.

~~~~~

I've read through alchemist ISO and it isn't as townie as I remembered. The humblebrag on the scummie nomination in #222 is something I've got in the back of my mind. I think there is a decent chance they're partners. T3's reads have been a bit all over the place. I get it, day 1 is hard, but he's not a noob. His progression on alchemist for example just doesn't make sense only for him to not vote him, unless they're scum together and T3 doesn't want to vote his partner. Alchemist also replied to eiralox's post of T3's messy reads and didn't actually acknowledge this inconsistency.

VOTE: Eiralox
I think I'm gonna put my vote here for now.

Ok I'll take the bait... Why

I think it would be best if votes are applied there.

VOTE: Enchant

...

VOTE: Dionysus

A dagger to my heart </3

But I get it. I've been kind of mia so far today. Truth be told I've been struggling to follow this game because it is pretty much almost entirely vibes and I'm better at hunting scum with logical deductions.

Having said that, I still think T3 is scum. Their contributions may be better than mine in terms of volume, but not in terms of content. Reads changing from one post to the next is fine, but there should be a consistent thread that you can follow to make sense of the person's thought process. T3's reads have been... well not that.

[furtiveglance]

Dionysus is probably scum for pushing someone for being "inconsistent" instead of actual scummy behavior. Town is more likely to be inconsistent, since they're not overly concerned with image, and less likely to spend time making sure their own reads are consistent.

Spoiler:

This push on Enchant seems like Alchemist is caught scum trying to divert attention away by starting a 1v1? Maybe?

Was this post an actual scumread? Because if it is then this:

VOTE: Eiralox
I think I'm gonna put my vote here for now.

is weird.

~~~~~

I've read through alchemist ISO and it isn't as townie as I remembered. The humblebrag on the scummie nomination in #222 is something I've got in the back of my mind. I think there is a decent chance they're partners. T3's reads have been a bit all over the place. I get it, day 1 is hard, but he's not a noob. His progression on alchemist for example just doesn't make sense only for him to not vote him, unless they're scum together and T3 doesn't want to vote his partner. Alchemist also replied to eiralox's post of T3's messy reads and didn't actually acknowledge this inconsistency.

VOTE: Eiralox
I think I'm gonna put my vote here for now.

Ok I'll take the bait... Why

I think it would be best if votes are applied there.

VOTE: Enchant

...

VOTE: Dionysus

A dagger to my heart </3

But I get it. I've been kind of mia so far today. Truth be told I've been struggling to follow this game because it is pretty much almost entirely vibes and I'm better at hunting scum with logical deductions.

Having said that, I still think T3 is scum. Their contributions may be better than mine in terms of volume, but not in terms of content. Reads changing from one post to the next is fine, but there should be a consistent thread that you can follow to make sense of the person's thought process. T3's reads have been... well not that.

Or town can push scum for being inconsistent - until T3 flips, who's to say

[Cat Scratch Fever]

234 is still a scummy post, I'm not going to rehash that >_>

So my main take away from the last few pages is:

1) frogster vs Cephrir is really fucking funny. Thank you so much for replacing in as it has made this day very entertaining
2) frogster is going to extreme lengths to dig up dirt on Cephrir which I think is very +++town. It means he legit believes in his read because if Cephrir flips town then this would look so bad.
3) I townread alchemist already but I definitely feel sure he is Town now. He has been engaged and scum hunting and I have liked his analysis. So not that the question is relevant anymore if I had to hammer either him or NM I'd go NM.

4) I still think Cephrir is scum
5) although I think Cephrir's enchant analysis is interesting

6) this could be svs but it was largely ignored or disagreed with so maybe they are wrong

Doesn't vote either. Is that an inconsistency?

[furtiveglance]

VOTE: T3

[Cat Scratch Fever]

Dionysus is probably scum for pushing someone for being "inconsistent" instead of actual scummy behavior. Town is more likely to be inconsistent, since they're not overly concerned with image, and less likely to spend time making sure their own reads are consistent.

Spoiler:

This push on Enchant seems like Alchemist is caught scum trying to divert attention away by starting a 1v1? Maybe?

Was this post an actual scumread? Because if it is then this:

VOTE: Eiralox
I think I'm gonna put my vote here for now.

is weird.

~~~~~

I've read through alchemist ISO and it isn't as townie as I remembered. The humblebrag on the scummie nomination in #222 is something I've got in the back of my mind. I think there is a decent chance they're partners. T3's reads have been a bit all over the place. I get it, day 1 is hard, but he's not a noob. His progression on alchemist for example just doesn't make sense only for him to not vote him, unless they're scum together and T3 doesn't want to vote his partner. Alchemist also replied to eiralox's post of T3's messy reads and didn't actually acknowledge this inconsistency.

VOTE: Eiralox
I think I'm gonna put my vote here for now.

Ok I'll take the bait... Why

I think it would be best if votes are applied there.

VOTE: Enchant

...

VOTE: Dionysus

A dagger to my heart </3

But I get it. I've been kind of mia so far today. Truth be told I've been struggling to follow this game because it is pretty much almost entirely vibes and I'm better at hunting scum with logical deductions.

Having said that, I still think T3 is scum. Their contributions may be better than mine in terms of volume, but not in terms of content. Reads changing from one post to the next is fine, but there should be a consistent thread that you can follow to make sense of the person's thought process. T3's reads have been... well not that.

Or town can push scum for being inconsistent - until T3 flips, who's to say

I don't think he's really trying to understand the mindset of T3, which is scummy. He's just pointing out something that T3 did. Do you disagree?