Mini Normal 2289 - Postgame

[T3]

The balance between ‘obscure’ roles and ‘not obscure’ roles has been very tilted towards the obscure side in recent times. Mods have tried pushing the boundaries of normality, so you almost never see a Cop or Doctor without significant modifications.

I prefer open setups personally. Normal games focus too much on setup spec and then postgame everyone yells at the mod about the setup.

Haha, yeah. My favorite part of mafia is fakeclaiming, whether town or scum, and you can’t really do that in open setups. I don’t think I’ve played an Open in a year or so.

[T3]

All the PR claims can’t be true. Otherwise the setup would have very likely been denied by the reviewers. This is unless scum have some insane powers.

Yeah. I think 4-5 are most likely. Is your reason for thinking 2 claims are fake purely mech-based or reads-based as well?

Mostly mech, but I find it hard to believe that NM and Enchant are both town.

[DragonEater70]

All the PR claims can’t be true. Otherwise the setup would have very likely been denied by the reviewers. This is unless scum have some insane powers.

Yeah I agree. Tbh the mason/bodyguard claims feel the scummiest on the surface but I should probably do a bit more reading before jumping to conclusions.

[furtiveglance]

All the PR claims can’t be true. Otherwise the setup would have very likely been denied by the reviewers. This is unless scum have some insane powers.

Yeah. I think 4-5 are most likely. Is your reason for thinking 2 claims are fake purely mech-based or reads-based as well?

Mostly mech, but I find it hard to believe that NM and Enchant are both town.

Ok. My POE almost necessitates the same thing, unless it's Brickwall/Cephrir/Firebringer which I don't think is likely because I think only 1 of the latter are Mafia.

[DragonEater70]

Oh wai trhe person I was replying to was claiming mason. Hmmmm.

Anyway let me go back to reading

[DragonEater70]

Wait, do we have any knowledge of how many scum are in the game? Is it possible we are at ELo or MElo or something?

This is like my first closed game ever.

[furtiveglance]

Wait, do we have any knowledge of how many scum are in the game? Is it possible we are at ELo or MElo or something?

This is like my first closed game ever.

The last Mini Normal I did was 10/3, so I'm assuming the same for this game, but we don't know for sure.

[Firebringer]

What is your experience in mafia

[furtiveglance]

What is your experience in mafia

cmon Fire you know me :3

[DragonEater70]

What is your experience in mafia

Played one game on this site so far, played a bunch of Epicmafia and Avalon in the past.

[DragonEater70]

1. Dionysus (Novice 1-Shot Vigilante)
2. T3 (Mason)

3. Not_Mafia (Simple Bodyguard)

4. Alchemist21 (VT)
5. Enchant (Neapolitan)
6. Frogsterking (VT)

7. Eiralox (...)

8. Save The Dragons (Mason)

9. Cephrir (VT)
10. Cat Scratch Fever (VT)
11. Firebringer (Jester)
12. Brickwalll (Even-Night Psychologist)
13. furtiveglance (...)


I presumed Masons to be town for now. While it can be fakeclaimed, it's high risk high-reward and will be selfresolved.


Furtive did you claim.
Also i would like real Firebringer role.
And wait when we have new Eiralox.

Hi I'm the new Eiralox. Why are we massclaiming?

[DragonEater70]

@brick why did you target CSF
@enchant why did you target brick and what is your modifier
@masons did you crumb and what does your pt look like

earth to enchant

come in, enchant

I excluded NM, Eira and then tossed dice.
I don't want to claim modifier.

Why the exclusion?

[DragonEater70]

So here's a tentative readlist from just reading sorta all over the place (pleaseee someone tell me the important pages/posts to read if there are any):

T3 - townlean
Save The Dragons - slight townlean (but obviously on the same team as T3)
Brickwalll - slight townlean
Not_Mafia - null
Enchant - null
Cephrir - null
PenguinPower - Scumlean
furtiveglance - Scumlean

Dies anyone agree or disagree with any point in particular?

[DragonEater70]

It kinda sucks that my four biggest townreads are either dead or my own slot.

[Cephrir]

All the PR claims can’t be true. Otherwise the setup would have very likely been denied by the reviewers. This is unless scum have some insane powers.

Yeah. I think 4-5 are most likely. Is your reason for thinking 2 claims are fake purely mech-based or reads-based as well?

Mostly mech, but I find it hard to believe that NM and Enchant are both town.

Ok. My POE almost necessitates the same thing, unless it's Brickwall/Cephrir/Firebringer which I don't think is likely because I think only 1 of the latter are Mafia.

I got a townread from furtiveglance I'm printing this out to frame on my wall unless he was just bad at counting

[Firebringer]

What is your experience in mafia

cmon Fire you know me :3

i can't give you any special treatment for this job interview

[Firebringer]

I got a townread from furtiveglance I'm printing this out to frame on my wall unless he was just bad at counting

Why not both

[Firebringer]

i feel like this is first game in a long ass time no one is hounding me to read the game from start till now.

Its both refreshing and speaks to how low effort everyone is feeling.

[Cephrir]

i mean selfishly i want you to go see my townie radiance and bask in it but i'm not much for hounding. more of a cat person

@dragoneater
-how will you deal with your inevitable war against save the dragons (i do not think he would be on board with eating them)
-though not guaranteed this game being 10v3 is very very likely. i feel comfy assuming it

[Firebringer]

i only want to read it to see ur funny posts and witty comments.
i doubt ur going to be glowing in town radiance!

[Cephrir]

and here i thought dogs were supposed to be faithful

[Firebringer]

im loyal not faithful. I cheat all the time, but im doing it loyally.

[DragonEater70]

@dragoneater
-how will you deal with your inevitable war against save the dragons (i do not think he would be on board with eating them)

I considered voting them, but RVS is kinda over so for now I feel I have better things to do with my vote.

Regarding your townie radiance, please direct me to a soecific post or posts.

[DragonEater70]

Do you think there's a cost to posting even though there's no post limit? Should we be trying to keep our post counts low?

It would be very helpful to me personally if the game's post count stayed low. I don't want to come home from work and have the game feel more like a chore than a game because there's a mountain of new pages.

I can do that tbh, especially since you posted this. I know the rate of my posting is intense and I can taper it down gradually from here. I think the beginning of these games have a lot of clues as to the scum team so I like to get a massive jump out of the gate.

Also fuck it, I think alchemist is town. If these are scum posts then this dude is as cool as a cucumber.

I really hate that the posting rate stayed high
Can't help but agree with Alchemist that it feels a bit like a chore reading through.

[Cephrir]

@dragoneater
-how will you deal with your inevitable war against save the dragons (i do not think he would be on board with eating them)

I considered voting them, but RVS is kinda over so for now I feel I have better things to do with my vote.

Regarding your townie radiance, please direct me to a soecific post or posts.

It's a vibe mang
Might as well ask me to explain the ocean with a glass of water