Going through Feysal ISO
In post 130, Feysal wrote:
In post 122, Black wrote:
I would argue Dragon didn't seem to care about RVS much either. I feel like both of their entrances could be considered "aggressive with a disregard for RVS" so I just wanted to see why Dunnstral got the pass.
It was a difference in tone. Dunnstral was asking questions, but Dragon seemed angry at Firebringer for the act and voted them for it.
What is the difference of tone? This seems like a buzz word to talk about nothing while sounding like you actually have reasoning.
Here is the posts Dragon made on the subject
In post 29, DragonEater70 wrote:
VOTE: Firebringer
I really don't enjoy their entrance and I dare say it's possibly scummy.
In post 40, DragonEater70 wrote:
Monocole man suddenly draws a gun, aiming it at the cowboy.
"Drop the act!" he calls out to him. "Or else, drop dead."
(Fire please take the hint and stop this madness)
What exactly this tonally angry about these posts? Maybe I could see you picking up on the language being a bit overwrought with "dare I say" and "stop this madness" but angry? Nah. This feels like you're trying to make an ex post facto distinction that isn't there to artificially explain why you didn't pick up on two things being similar.
To piggyback off of FBs post there's no sorting here either. I don't get the impression you're trying to read dragoneater at all here OR dunn for that matter, I get the impression you made a comment about someone being scummy because it looks like thread engagement and then had to try to justify later, but missing from all of your commentary on dragon and dunn is an actual thought process about motivation. Even if I buy your premise that dragon was angry (which I don't, I don't buy that the things are tonally different and if anything it goes in the opposite direction) why is this scum?
In post 368, Feysal wrote:
I've seen Dragon's town games, and got the impression that he was more relaxed in them. I would have expected him to join in on the joke for a laugh, not to tell Firebringer to knock it off. There is a sort of nervousness I get from his play, and I wonder why that is.
So now we get some sort of explanation for why this is scum dragon and not town dragon but we've changed how we're describing him. Now he's not angry, he's nervous. We would have expected him to join in on the joke. Never mind the goal post shifting but [citation needed].
Can you provide me with examples of dragon "joining in on the joke for a laugh" instead of finding it scummy?
More to the point this read is now extremely stale. A whole ton of stuff has happened since then and you're still on something dragoneater did on like the first post of the game. If you actually had a sincere scum read on him why have you not commented on the stuff hes posted and done since? Has it changed your read? Is it still tonally angry? Is it tonally nervous? You seem to have taken roughly 2 stances this game which you haven't updated since saturday despite like 20 pages. Everything else in this ISO is either noise or defending yourself. And I know you're catching up but I haven't seen any evidence of any sort of progression in any of the posts where you're doing so. You still seem caught up on things that happened 20 pages ago and are ignoring anything that has happened since except for discussion of those things.
