Pokemon Battles 2 - Attack on Giratina [GAME OVER]

[$elene]

Quick Links
Current Votecount
Opening Post
Rules
Game Mechanics
Battle Demonstration

V OTECOUNT 1.3
E LIMINATION V OTES
P LAYER N AME	C URRENT V OTES
Pink Ball (4)	Blue., SirCakez, Sheepsaysmeep, Klick
Sheepsaysmeep (1)	Pink Ball
Firebringer (1)	Doctor Drew
Not_Mafia (1)	Not_Mafia
Mittens (2)	Black
Patchwork (1)	Skygazer
Skygazer (1)	Titus
Black (1)	Mittens
SquirtleSquad (1)	Invisibility
WhemeStar (1)	Chandra Nalaar
Chandra Nalaar (1)	NorwegianboyEE
Doctor Drew (1)	SquirtleSquad
NOT VOTING: jjh927, Firebringer, Flavor Leaf, KittyTacky WhemeStar, Ranger, Patchwork, Magical Girl
With 23 alive, it takes 12 votes to flip! Deadline: (expired on 2023-06-12 10:16:25)
Notes: All alive players gain +1 DEF.

[NorwegianboyEE]

If Chandra imagined Wheme's inactivity to be scummy, why push it immediately at the start of the game instead of waiting a bit to see if their inactivity is going to be an recurring theme rather than an one-off thing.

[Firebringer]

If Chandra imagined Wheme's inactivity to be scummy, why push it immediately at the start of the game instead of waiting a bit to see if their inactivity is going to be an recurring theme rather than an one-off thing.

I don't think this is much alignment indicative as personality/playstyle pushing so.....not sure why u keep wanting to tread this water

[NorwegianboyEE]

It's the one lead i feel i have in this game RN, why wouldn't i wanna prod it.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Are you familiar with the player?

[Firebringer]

no idea who it is.
u keep prodding. I will cheer u on from the sidelines while i start planting evidence in pink balls house of his crimes

[Blue.]

If scum only ever did things they "have to" do, their win rate would be much lower.

What I meant is that scum!Squirtle is never getting town!sheep limmed with that half assed push, and they aren't looking townie while doing that either
And Klick is defending a player that I wouldn't take too much effort to defend in the first place (no offense sheep but this playerlist has a lot of other players that I would consider as a priority to get townread from)

When I say that they don't have to, is that it shouldn't be prioritized because they wouldn't get anything out of it as scum.
So the most logical conclusion is that town!Squirtle legitimately thought that sheep's entrance was scummy, and town!Klick couldn't hold the urge of get their nose in

Scum can very easily force posts early in the game to appear 'productive', because being serious early looks townie. Not saying that's what happened here, but you're taking a very surface level view of their posting.

[Blue.]

*throws a great ball at firebringer*

[NorwegianboyEE]

Maybe i should look at their previous games to get a feel of their playstyle.
But later, i'm going to sleep soon.

[Pink Ball]

Scum can very easily force posts early in the game to appear 'productive', because being serious early looks townie. Not saying that's what happened here, but you're taking a very surface level view of their posting.

What's your stance then?
Is Klick manufacturing their stance to look productive, or are they just posting a "well actually" kind of post that town!Klick usually posts?
Is Squirtle trying to look productive by pushing sheep, or is his scumread on sheep legit?

[Pink Ball]

Take a stance on players. You don't like that I'm taking hard stances this early? Do you think I'm scum trying to buddy some townies? So do you agree with me that they're town? Is one of them my partner? Or am I town and you think that I'm wrong?

At some point one of you will be annoyed with me because I'm right for the wrong reasons and you will show your true colors

[Blue.]

VOTE: patchwork

[sheepsaysmeep]

VOTE: patchwork

down

[Pink Ball]

That's a solid stance

[sheepsaysmeep]

(no offense sheep but this playerlist has a lot of other players that I would consider as a priority to get townread from)

I will be this town's leader

[Invisibility]

Mittens (2)
Invisibility,

I'm voting Squirtle!!!
UNVOTE: not anymore thbough lol

Fixed -Ali

[Invisibility]

recent posts are cool

[Invisibility]

VOTE: Patchwork
sure

[Blue.]

Scum can very easily force posts early in the game to appear 'productive', because being serious early looks townie. Not saying that's what happened here, but you're taking a very surface level view of their posting.

What's your stance then?
Is Klick manufacturing their stance to look productive, or are they just posting a "well actually" kind of post that town!Klick usually posts?
Is Squirtle trying to look productive by pushing sheep, or is his scumread on sheep legit?

Not particularly, no. I thought sheep's posts were about as null as you can get and so anyone seeing things there was imagining things that weren't there. Squirtle's push there was forced, which isn't necessarily scummy, although it can be. I don't think it was though, but that's based on other stuff he's posted. I'd be more concerned if he was still trying to push sheep.

I don't have issues with the conclusions you made, I just don't trust your reasoning.

[Magical Girl]

VOTE: patchwork

[SquirtleSquad]

much more interested in doctor drew.

seems just like normal patchwork to me. they're always like this.

[Pink Ball]

I just don't trust your reasoning

You don't trust it in what sense, that it's bad reasoning, or that you think I'm scum for the reasoning I'm giving?

[SquirtleSquad]

doesnt preclude them from being scum I suppose.

[Pink Ball]

VOTE: Dr. Drew

[Invisibility]

much more interested in doctor drew.

seems just like normal patchwork to me. they're always like this.

what do you find interesting?