Mini Normal 2305 | GAME OVER

[Elements]

Bloop

[humaneatingmonkey]

@hem answer my question first, then I’ll answer yours.

Greeting you already know why. I think your karmadog vote is bad faith. It felt like you made up a reason to establish your vote as stronger than it is -- than you really having a strong reason to scumread karmadog.

[geraintm]

@oopps

Yeah, I could sew a vote for Furtive.
There is an attempt at content and reads, but it doesn't look good, plucking names out of the air with zero to back it up.

[furtiveglance]

I also like this posting from clidd

Or it's an inexperience thing..

Im not buying it . forum games or not, theory is theory. you KNOW how mafia games work. I dont know you well, but you are logical and can think through motivation. I dont think TownOD seriously thought..

VOTE: Greeting I'm still interested in this slot.

What motivation exists in order for Greeting to kill Takutai?

I get it, you want to put out there that you thought Tak had greeting on a town lock. But at the end, he did not. So I feel like TownOD, would have looked over Tak a bit before putting this out there for people to consume.

platinum posting

um actually that's a karma post

Yeah is this why people aren't voting clidd?

[furtiveglance]

@oopps

Yeah, I could sew a vote for Furtive.
There is an attempt at content and reads, but it doesn't look good, plucking names out of the air with zero to back it up.

This is outrageously hypocritical.

[Elements]

I also like this posting from clidd

Or it's an inexperience thing..

Im not buying it . forum games or not, theory is theory. you KNOW how mafia games work. I dont know you well, but you are logical and can think through motivation. I dont think TownOD seriously thought..

VOTE: Greeting I'm still interested in this slot.

What motivation exists in order for Greeting to kill Takutai?

I get it, you want to put out there that you thought Tak had greeting on a town lock. But at the end, he did not. So I feel like TownOD, would have looked over Tak a bit before putting this out there for people to consume.

platinum posting

um actually that's a karma post

Yeah is this why people aren't voting clidd?

People aren't voting clidd because everyone other than you thinks Clidd is town

[Morning Tweet]

VOTE: Gera

[Morning Tweet]

Gera/Klick/IDK

[Morning Tweet]

HEM might be right Takutai's first post might've made them too tempting of a kill actually + fairly universal townread so it's plausible anyone would kill them tbh

i was going to theorize that Klick and Gera probably didnt request ot kill Takutai but they coudlve so whatevr

I'm suspiciouws of Klick's read on me and Roden, I'm suss

Gera having no opinion of anything happening in the game whatsoever is a little surprising to me.. i *think* furtive is town though and that one take Gera just had on furtive seems like overdoing it to me? Does Gera rlly think furtive is plucking stuff out of thin air to back things up ?? Where di dthat come from? That's kind of what I'm getting at

Isn't that like, something you should have been noticing o r mentioning back at 1462

It's a strong support for furtive suspicion out of nowhere

[humaneatingmonkey]

i like that take tweet

[OopsieDaisy]

HEM might be right Takutai's first post might've made them too tempting of a kill actually + fairly universal townread so it's plausible anyone would kill them tbh

Ohhhhh god I forgot his first post, my reads based on the Takutai kill mean a lot less now gdi

[Elements]

I can vote Gera

[OopsieDaisy]

Yea as much as my gut tells me Furtive is scum this game, I'm not seeing the justification for Gera's scumread there. It feels like he's parroting other people's points around the Furtive slot in his most recent post rather than coming up with an original reason to read there, and I'm a little worried that he's trying to buddy up to me/hide behind me by just sheeping my read onto Furtive.

@Gera, which reads from Furtive do you believe are unjustified and why?

[curiouskarmadog]

got busy with work, first time I have turned on my (personal) computer today. will catch tomorrow with one of my scummy walls of text catch up posts.

[curiouskarmadog]

LOL, disregard, this game as only moved one page....still have to wait till tomorrow, with a less scummy catch up post.

[Umlaut]

Klick and clidd were prodded.

[Umlaut]

Vote Count 2.2

furtiveglance (3):

Elements, clidd, OopsieDaisy

Greeting (2):

humaneatingmonkey, curiouskarmadog

curiouskarmadog (1):

Greeting

geraintm (1):

Morning Tweet

clidd (1):

furtiveglance

Not voting (3):

geraintm, Emperor flippyNips, Klick


With 11 alive, it takes 6 votes to drive someone out of town.

The sun will set in (expired on 2023-07-15 10:20:00).

[furtiveglance]

I voted Clidd btw.

Fixed

-Um

[geraintm]

@oopps

Yeah, I could sew a vote for Furtive.
There is an attempt at content and reads, but it doesn't look good, plucking names out of the air with zero to back it up.

This is outrageously hypocritical.

Sorta yes.
I hadn't been trying to make reads on people though , I was just being useless

[geraintm]

I can vote Gera

Oh, everyone can vote me. I know I am offering nothing to this game, but I cannot fake reads.

[geraintm]

So, im going to go through Furtive's posts now and show why i thought they were plucking reads from nothing

I don't like that votecount at all.

Clidd, Greeting or geraint wagons anyone?

vague post just wanting to push at 3 random people

I don't like that votecount at all.

Clidd, Greeting or geraint wagons anyone?

Clearly not
Join something that's actually going to happen

I'll vote CKD over Roden if I have to

now willing to vote Curious, but i don't know why. - they follow this with a vote for Curious

I genuinely think Roden's townier. I don't have to agree with the perceived consensus...

an opinion on Roden, but zero to explain why

Ok I think ckd's recent posting has been towny. Especially interactions with Greeting.

no explanation why Curious is townie now. Also doesnt unvote

Next Day

That said, the individual I'd like to talk to at this point is Furtive.

Other than the suspicion expressed about me, there haven't been any other *expressive* instances to check out his perspective on the game.

VOTE: furtiveglance

What are your current impressions? (apart from my slot, of course).

You and Greeting remain my biggest scumreads. I'll go back and look at what Takutai was saying, I feel like they weren't really a UTR so maybe killed for their reads.

Saying CLidd and Greeting remain top of their scum reads, they hadnt mentioned them for a long time. ive been dropped . still unsure why on Day 2 they are top of their list

1378 - actually gives a reason on why GReeting is Scum - stiff, lifeless and push on them is calculated.
then votes Greeting

It's interesting to see how fast that Greeting wagon took off compared to my push on clidd yesterday.

I'm gonna vote clidd and see what happens.

VOTE: Clidd

wait... they unvote because they dont like the wagon?

{side note, if Greeting comes back green i will immediately vote Furtive just for this}

@furtive if you're so set on clidd, who are the other scum?

Greeting, Geraint, maybe Emperor

I'm not sure

next post, just starts pushing more people, still with no reasoning.


So, that is why i said there is an attempt at content, but they have basically been plucking names from the air and have zero to back it up

people happier with why i didn't like Furtive now?

[OopsieDaisy]

people happier with why i didn't like Furtive now?

Yea I like this post, Gera showing us the method behind his thinking helps a lot with my worries about parroting points/hiding behind me. He has his own reasons for the push backed up by evidence across the thread.

[Umlaut]

Seeking replacements for Klick and Greeting.

[curiouskarmadog]

Seeking replacements for Klick and

Greeting

.

[curiouskarmadog]

Gera/Klick/IDK

you think that is the scum pairings? really?