mystery box of silver 15: i'm killing hostages (negotiated)

[schadd_]

[Dannflor]

comedy

[Dannflor]

uh I’d kinda prefer sheepsaysmeep next?

[Meuh]

I'd be cool with that

[sheepsaysmeep]

wait no I'll do things

[sheepsaysmeep]

a player from the mafia is eligible to be hostage killed during this day.

does this mean we should let this day go an insanely long time or do we just ignore it

[HighPrincessErinys]

blob d

not voting (2):

xyzzy, HighPrincessErinys

Hell yeah, blob.

Also, happy scumday MUSH! It appears to be on my birthday, funnily enough.

[HighPrincessErinys]

wait no I'll do things

VOTE: sheepsaysmeep do them faster

[sheepsaysmeep]

happy cake day

[MUSHSHAGANA]

blob d

not voting (2):

xyzzy, HighPrincessErinys

Hell yeah, blob.

Also, happy scumday MUSH! It appears to be on my birthday, funnily enough.

Don't worry about it. I'm a nexus of unnerving synchronicity. Also, reality breaks down in my presence. See: the water duplication glitch incident, the vanishing ATM, the extra door on the Heinz Building, the impossible alleyway... Also, the first two involved witnesses.

[schadd_]

blob d

not voting (2):

xyzzy, HighPrincessErinys

Hell yeah, blob.

woops i guess i'll leave it

[MUSHSHAGANA]

blob d

not voting (2):

xyzzy, HighPrincessErinys

Hell yeah, blob.

woops i guess i'll leave it

You could say that you blob'd them. Why would you, though?

[MUSHSHAGANA]

a player from the mafia is eligible to be hostage killed during this day.

does this mean we should let this day go an insanely long time or do we just ignore it

This actually DOES seem to be a good idea. It's a free scum kill if Edman homers AND there's no townie scummier-looking than scum. If we speed-lim here, I think we could lose out on useful information about what's scummy to schadd_ (since it's not alignment-bound for this phase).

If that's not important to people, then sheep's not a bad choice, but I think xyzzy is a better one: guaranteed red.

[Ranger]

3 red slots left, the group says xyzzy is one for sure. RCE, Ranger, Meuh, Sheep are candidates for the other.

Try checking how many of those I’m willing to eliminate.

VOTE: sheepsaysmeep

Would also vote RCEnigma or xyzzy, willing to continue the purge regardless on all three.

[HighPrincessErinys]

Okay that is true, waiting just gives us a free scum kill.
UNVOTE:

[Ranger]

My preference; xyzzy->RCEnigma->sheepsaysmeep; voting sheep because I honestly don’t care what the order is as long as all are purged pronto.

[HighPrincessErinys]

My preference; xyzzy->RCEnigma->sheepsaysmeep; voting sheep because I honestly don’t care what the order is as long as all are purged pronto.

Sorry Ranger but this one is probably waiting for a day until the Cardinals vs Athletics game tmrw concludes and we see if we nail scum.

[ofrhz]

VOTE: sheep

[Ranger]

I don’t trust schadd. He killed one of the towniest slots in the game, for...voting...scum???

Think about that. Bulge wasn’t remotely scum by play, nor was the BlueSnakelet vote bad as it was voting scum.

Do you

really

want to trust schadd's judgment on who's scummy, when there’s only a

chance

to hit scum?

What happens if he thinks a town player like me or MUSH is scummier than scum?

I much prefer we solve by play, rather than rely on a dice roll we've already got evidence is rigged.

[MUSHSHAGANA]

Deeper explanation of my thoughts on waiting:

The fun part about no deadline is that we don't really lose anything by waiting for a dinger. Day-phase mechanics are likely to be those that don't gain any value as a day goes on, and they seem to be triggered off of homers or lims, so we hould be good waiting for one homer.

Once we get a dinger, there's no value in waiting for a second one, though. We only gain from the first home run, anything subsequent is probably going to dig a hole (even if a shallow one).

[MUSHSHAGANA]

I don’t trust schadd. He killed one of the towniest slots in the game, for...voting...scum???

Think about that. Bulge wasn’t remotely scum by play, nor was the BlueSnakelet vote bad as it was voting scum.

Do you

really

want to trust schadd's judgment on who's scummy, when there’s only a

chance

to hit scum?

What happens if he thinks a town player like me or MUSH is scummier than scum?

I much prefer we solve by play, rather than rely on a dice roll we've already got evidence is rigged.

Bulge makes sense as a kill, genuinely.

You're panicked about this in a way I'd expect scum to be, funny enough. Why?

It's not because scum WILL die, or even that scum dying would matter. It's that it sheds light on WHY the prior dingers hit the people they did. Would schadd_ have preferred to hit much uglier scum slots, or are all the scum efforting, meaning limming in the lowposter pool is a bad idea? That unlocks the earlier dinger kills as something we can parse through meaningfully, instead of asking empty questions about. It helps us sort.

[HighPrincessErinys]

I don’t trust schadd. He killed one of the towniest slots in the game, for...voting...scum???

Think about that. Bulge wasn’t remotely scum by play, nor was the BlueSnakelet vote bad as it was voting scum.

Do you really want to trust schadd's judgment on who's scummy, when there’s only a chance to hit scum?

What happens if he thinks a town player like me or MUSH is scummier than scum?

I much prefer we solve by play, rather than rely on a dice roll we've already got evidence is rigged.

Bulge got doinked by being low-content and the vote likely was a non-factor. Like, this was a shitpost you know. This one is pretty confident that the victim of a homerun is gonna be one of xyzzy/sheep/RCE and they'll either flip scum or stop being deadweight town. Or it'll hit Skygazer. RIP.

[HighPrincessErinys]

Skygazer is deadweight town but they're FUN deadweight town so hopefully Tommy just murders a mafia instead.

[SirCakez]

Wow MTs scum meta is insanely predictable..

[SirCakez]

VOTE: sheep the train rolls on