[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/ext/alfredoramos/seometadata/event/listener.php on line 114: Undefined array key 13990267 [phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/ext/alfredoramos/seometadata/event/listener.php on line 114: Trying to access array offset on value of type null micro theme 1093: u-pic [game over] - Mafiascum.net
Post
Post #146 (isolation #1) » Wed Nov 22, 2023 2:54 am
Postby Meuh »
Considering I lost a 23p game on day 9 because I was too amenable to scum Wheme doing brash anti-town things, I can’t say I’m super eager to townread him for what he’s doing rn
Wheme can still be town (don’t have a strong feeling there), but I’m unwilling to let Wheme do anti-town things and get away with it because of good posting. That’s more my point
Post
Post #461 (isolation #14) » Sun Nov 26, 2023 11:16 am
Postby Meuh »
Accurate in terms of like, how he approaches the game and his meta, I don’t have a strong grasp on his actual gameplay in this game but Aureal’s counter seems vaguely accurate
Post
Post #465 (isolation #16) » Sun Nov 26, 2023 11:24 am
Postby Meuh »
Oh also imo Drew is still alive, there’s just shenanigans that made those votes not enough to kill
His death just being delayed is more perplexing and convoluted, something something Occam’s razor
Which is a good thing cause that speedlim sucked!!!!!
Post
Post #547 (isolation #19) » Mon Nov 27, 2023 4:43 pm
Postby Meuh »
In post 2, Skygazer wrote:
- this game will have seven apple-aligned players and two orange-aligned players.
Briefly considered whether this meant there HAD to be a third party but it's pretty vague and says nothing about what a 10th player would even be
Could see 3p, though I also wouldn't be surprised if kabouter was an alt controlled by one of the players here
Nothing really rules out just an extra town or mafia (though the latter sounds incredibly unlikely balance-wise)
Post
Post #724 (isolation #31) » Wed Nov 29, 2023 12:27 pm
Postby Meuh »
Your early posting just felt slightly stiff and tonally off iirc
I don't have a strict definition because it's not a clearly defined thing, just a general feeling
Post
Post #731 (isolation #33) » Wed Nov 29, 2023 12:41 pm
Postby Meuh »
Spoiler:
In post 3028, Meuh wrote:
Are there examples of you elaborating on those reads? Explaining them? Anyone can throw players into 5 categories if they want, I can do it right now if I want!
Here's players sorted by how much I associate them to celery vs tomatoes
In post 616, Taly wrote:
then vote me because why would i actively incriminate myself by hard-defending a partner i could just hammer and cash in towncred for it?
you have 0 depth to your thought
hmm... you're right. jjh is scum, you're not. i can agree to that assessment
Post
Post #767 (isolation #39) » Fri Dec 01, 2023 1:36 am
Postby Meuh »
Like I’ve heard jjh praised as a mighty town player who’s easy to find, and not to be rude but neither seem to be true here? They seem unenthused to solve, their posts that have been trying to solve are very meh and nothing they’ve done indicates town to me
So Drew, tell me more about why you thought Wheme was being coached to lurk and not fight his elimination?
Just seemed like he was too ok with his lim, like I could see a buddy in that situation telling him to just act like you have no idea what is going on and don't fight.
But honestly, started to feel like he was being coached as I questioned him a bit about not having any reads at all despite what has transpired.
I might have been projecting how I would have handled things though heh.
Pre Edit: Theta, do you think this is something we legit should pay attention to? I have been kinda ignoring it so far
this feels too specific a reason to come from scum at the velocity of the wagon
I think Drew
needs
to pull out 'specific reason' here to have any chance of not throwing giant red flags all over the place here. So no, I don't agree with you there. This very much reads like an excuse to me because Drew has good reason to think I'm going to suspect him for this. Drew and I have played with Wheme before, in Weird Dreams which I referenced earlier. Guess who got voted out day one after doing very little and even saying a lim on him wouldn't be bad? Guess who fought tooth and nail against the limbait-Wheme wagon? I'm finding it hard to reconcile Drew's readiness to yeet Wheme here with his contempt for such things elsewhere. What was so different about Wheme here, Drew?
I have played with Wheme more than just Weird Dreams, and I have seem him much more engaged as town then here(admittedly I don't remember much of Weird Dreams outside of me saving Python and killing scumTitus at the same time lol). It wasn't until this moment that I remember him as the D1 lim there until you brought it up.
If memory serves me correctly, I have seen Wheme be very blase as scum in Pokemon? I could be misremembering that, but the point being, Weird Dreams had no factor in my read of Wheme here.
I already explained in detail why I thought they were scum here, if you don't like the reasoning behind, so be it......you do you. It was few hours until deadline and someone I had already voiced concern with was the leading wagon(wheme) and I didn't want one of my top town reads(Bianco) limmed, and to a lesser extent jjh or Taly limmed(over wheme least). Maybe I talked myself into it a bit too much, if I am gonna be self critical......maybe I justified it in my head, but he seemed to fit the pieces of a good scum lim for D1.
Pokemon huh? OK taking a look...
Gosh, he was so much more engaged there. Just looking at the first 24 hours of his posting there, I feel he was doing way more in that time than he did all game here. Or maybe even here plus Weird Dreams, though he did start getting involved while being wagoned right at the end in that one.
I'm still not getting how this makes you come down on the side of voting a lurker day one when the other wagon was also someone you'd expressed suspicion towards.
Comparing engagement in Pokémon to this game seems… questionable?
The gamestate here for a large chunk of day 1 was pretty boring and not particularly inspiring for a lot of players, which many people (including Wheme) mentioned
In post 517, WhemeStar wrote:
You guys ever have a game wheee you have like 0 reads
This is tbat game for me
These sorts of posts about not having much to cling onto tend to be true regardless of alignment IMO and so in my eyes, it just makes sense for Wheme to be more engaged in a different game than this one with a rough gamestate, especially when the other game was a large with complex mechanics outed from the start: a whole lot more to talk about from the start.
Aside from engagement, there was tone (which I think Drew was more referring to here), which I found Wheme to be matching here
In post 767, Meuh wrote:
Like I’ve heard jjh praised as a mighty town player who’s easy to find, and not to be rude but neither seem to be true here? They seem unenthused to solve, their posts that have been trying to solve are very meh and nothing they’ve done indicates town to me
Look at some meta rather than going off reputation and then get back to me
What you've got there is kinda empty and I can't really argue back when I'll concede I'm not as motivated for this game as I was, say, the earlygame of my last game. But I am exactly as motivated for this game as the lategame of my last game
Tbh I’d like to see other people chime in with their own meta on you, forgot to ask for that specifically but I feel it’s pertinent, I’d rather explore meta that other players have than do it myself before that input
Post
Post #776 (isolation #46) » Fri Dec 01, 2023 6:42 am
Postby Meuh »
In post 775, Meuh wrote:
I will say that my read on you revolves around POE, but I also haven’t found a singular townie thing in your ISO so I feel good about said read
Post
Post #778 (isolation #47) » Fri Dec 01, 2023 6:59 am
Postby Meuh »
In post 777, jjh927 wrote:
How many people in this game do you think actually have any experience with me?
Why do you expect me to have a strong assessment of this when I’ve never played with you before?
This is such a pointless thing and it shows how little you care about solving this game
In post 135, jjh927 wrote:
Nah you just gotta understand how mr wheme park operates
He's probably more frustrating as scum if you ask me because he's more obstinate when he leans into wacky shit like this
In post 144, jjh927 wrote:
Wheme acted rashly but what I actually liked was when he slowed down and then stopped. Sure, he also stopped posting and probably went to go and do something else, but he was taking me seriously and I wasn't just an obstacle to the thing he wanted to do
In post 768, Meuh wrote:
Taly’s role just sounds like a 3p finder so not targeting Wesley with it is ??????
"Why bother, it's not going to work because it's obvious wesley isn't town or scum, and I won't even necessarily have a way to confirm that it didn't work other than trying to grill wesley into admitting it" is probably what my train of thought would be there, given that ability.
Why do you even care? Weird thing to kvetch about when Taly already flipped town.
Why is this your reaction here? Seems disproportionate to me just dropping a comment on Taly’s role
Also, it’s impossible to confirm someone is not in a hood… but:
1. Wesley wouldn’t know they were meant to be in a PT, right? So Taly could catch Wesley just based on that lack of knowledge
2. If Wesley is shown to be in a PT, then we know they’re much less likely to be 3p.
Incredible utility? No. More potential than any other option? Yes.
Though I guess arguing this at length is pointless cause as you said, Taly’s dead!
Post
Post #794 (isolation #54) » Fri Dec 01, 2023 9:23 am
Postby Meuh »
In post 726, Taly wrote:
methinks im damaging thread health which is unusual hmmmmmmmmmm
maybe i should meme more
my mental health has plummeted i can definitely meme
pedit
In post 724, Meuh wrote:
Your early posting just felt slightly stiff and tonally off iirc
I don't have a strict definition because it's not a clearly defined thing, just a general feeling
In post 722, Taly wrote:
so for this worldview to make sense, only 1 scum is on the wheme
wagon
Is this hard to believe?
nope, i think its entirely plausible
It’s little things like this with Taly: town is much more likely to have a thought like “my posting is damaging thread health” and care about it, it’s hard to fake
In post 768, Meuh wrote:
Taly’s role just sounds like a 3p finder so not targeting Wesley with it is ??????
"Why bother, it's not going to work because it's obvious wesley isn't town or scum, and I won't even necessarily have a way to confirm that it didn't work other than trying to grill wesley into admitting it" is probably what my train of thought would be there, given that ability.
Why do you even care? Weird thing to kvetch about when Taly already flipped town.
Hold on, you have been giving me the business about why I voted Wheme and not JJh, and here you are, Aureal, trying to make the person pushing JJH(Meuh) look bad.....just as the JJH wagon is gaining steam.
I even looked backed to when you switched from voting JJh to Wheme, literally was right before I voted Wheme......you gave me shit for not voting him and choosing to vote Wheme, when you LEFT the JJh wagon to vote Wheme!
I think you are trying to play both sides here, trying to push JJh while also keeping others in the conversation for a mislim. I was looking at you like 'of course Aureal is town' but taking a step back I see I was probably wrong. Ironically you pushing me on why I voted Wheme caused me to take this step back, so thank you for that lol.
VOTE: Aureal
Aureal suddenly giving a shit about me when I push jjh is scummy, but imo more likely to be partnered than scum stepping in to defend a townie? Aureal gets herself into shit by pushing back on me considering there’s momentum against jjh, I don’t think scum Aureal really benefits from taking this stance with a town jjh
Post
Post #796 (isolation #56) » Fri Dec 01, 2023 9:29 am
Postby Meuh »
imo this is either scum Aureal with scum jjh or town Aureal
Which makes me wanna vote jjh more lol
Don’t really see the world you’re positing though, Drew. Scum Aureal town jjh doesn’t click
In post 768, Meuh wrote:
Taly’s role just sounds like a 3p finder so not targeting Wesley with it is ??????
"Why bother, it's not going to work because it's obvious wesley isn't town or scum, and I won't even necessarily have a way to confirm that it didn't work other than trying to grill wesley into admitting it" is probably what my train of thought would be there, given that ability.
Why do you even care? Weird thing to kvetch about when Taly already flipped town.
Hold on, you have been giving me the business about why I voted Wheme and not JJh, and here you are, Aureal, trying to make the person pushing JJH(Meuh) look bad.....just as the JJH wagon is gaining steam.
I even looked backed to when you switched from voting JJh to Wheme, literally was right before I voted Wheme......you gave me shit for not voting him and choosing to vote Wheme, when you LEFT the JJh wagon to vote Wheme!
I think you are trying to play both sides here, trying to push JJh while also keeping others in the conversation for a mislim. I was looking at you like 'of course Aureal is town' but taking a step back I see I was probably wrong. Ironically you pushing me on why I voted Wheme caused me to take this step back, so thank you for that lol.
VOTE: Aureal
Aureal suddenly giving a shit about me when I push jjh is scummy, but imo more likely to be partnered than scum stepping in to defend a townie? Aureal gets herself into shit by pushing back on me considering there’s momentum against jjh, I don’t think scum Aureal really benefits from taking this stance with a town jjh
Well that's the thing, I don't think she is blatantly protecting JJh(and no I don't think.they are partnered since she has been
seemingly ready to vote him
, since I repped in at least).
But the timing of giving you a little bit questioning just as the JJh wagon is gaining steam, while also giving me shit for not voting JJh, just doesn't add up to me.
Especially since some of the same things she was pushing me on she was doing herself!
seemingly
That’s the important word here. Particularly since the thread is actively talking about a jjh wagon now and she completely avoids mentioning it.
The gap in logic you describe can come from a townie though, tbh. Townies (myself included) can be hypocritical pretty often. I’ve repeatedly scumread people for things I’ve also been doing.
Either Aureal is just being a townie doing contradictory things (which is common), or Aureal is scum taking advantage of a situation. In the latter, I don’t see why she’d position herself the way she just has if jjh is town.
Post
Post #799 (isolation #58) » Fri Dec 01, 2023 9:46 am
Postby Meuh »
Like the biggest momentum since daystart has been Bianco and I pushing for jjh, and then earlier, Aureal’s had some back and forths with you and Wesley’s been calling jjh scum. If she’s scum and jjh is town, I feel like she gets herself into trouble for no reason by posting like she is currently.