Eminence in Shadow: Season 1 [Game Over]

[Dunnstral]

Why do you think they can't make that post as mafia?

instantly talking about flavor as mafia is weird

You did not seem to react to page 1, where a few players indeed did instantly talk about flavor. There is no indication that this is a part of your reads, which means you're only using this as a reason to townread Whemestar here. Curious.

[Luka]

You did not seem to react to page 1, where a few players indeed did instantly talk about flavor. There is no indication that this is a part of your reads, which means you're only using this as a reason to townread Whemestar here. Curious.

I mean they didnt immediently open with my character is hot out of the blue

[T3]

Klick's entrance here feels different from when I modded a game when he replaced into a scum slot a while ago

i need more words this is vague as fuck

It means that I thought Klick might be town for how he behaved when he replaced in

Then I looked at 7 past Klick games in which he replaced in and realized it was NAI

Does Klick usually have a narrow focus when they replace in?

I didn't specifically pay attention to that, but I don't think he has a narrow focus as either alignment when replacing in

[Dunnstral]

You did not seem to react to page 1, where a few players indeed did instantly talk about flavor. There is no indication that this is a part of your reads, which means you're only using this as a reason to townread Whemestar here. Curious.

I mean they didnt immediently open with my character is hot out of the blue

But when questioned about why that post was town from Whemestar, you replied with:

Why do you think they can't make that post as mafia?

instantly talking about flavor as mafia is weird

Is there something different about Whemestar's post and the speculation on page 1?

[Alisae]

Someone convince me Cakez is scum because I'm inclined to think otherwise atm but I've been inaccurate on Cakez before

Also @Ali what kind of confidence do you have about Luka!town

I liked the reads they gave out when they gave them out

[Alisae]

Could be mafia tho luka hard to read

[Alisae]

Klick town

[Luka]

Is there something different about Whemestar's post and the speculation on page 1?

yah
the flavour on d1 doesnt apply to ones own self that they're discussing
also it's less natural

[ssbm_Kyouko]

I'm at the bottom of page 15, don't have time to finish catching up now - be back on the 26th. Merry Christmas!

[Dunnstral]

Is there something different about Whemestar's post and the speculation on page 1?

yah
the flavour on d1 doesnt apply to ones own self that they're discussing
also it's less natural

Alright, that makes sense.

[Luka]

Is there something different about Whemestar's post and the speculation on page 1?

yah
the flavour on d1 doesnt apply to ones own self that they're discussing
also it's less natural

Alright, that makes sense.

I also did give a town lean to what you said fwiw

[ssbm_Kyouko]

Someone convince me Cakez is scum

because I'm inclined to think otherwise atm but I've been inaccurate on Cakez before

Also @Ali what kind of confidence do you have about Luka!town

I didn't like this

KawaiiKame is my top townread

Why?

Kawaii is super engaged

, authentic, confident, and showing evidence of solving
I have no clue why you think Kawaii is the best vote you could place atm

How is Kawaii more engaged than, say, me, Alisae, or Gamma?

That's the issue
You're using the wrong lens
I don't care how engaged Kawaii is compared to other players

I care about how engaged Kawaii is compared to how engaged they'd be if they were scum

How is Kawaii more engaged than, say, me, Alisae, or Gamma?

That's the issue
You're using the wrong lens
I don't care how engaged Kawaii is compared to other players
I care about how engaged Kawaii is compared to how engaged they'd be if they were scum

viewtopic.php?t=92050&user_select%5B%5D=36997

Did you not play in this game,

where Kawaii was scum and was far more engaged than in this game?

That game is exactly what I am comparing their play here to

I'm assuming you've seen my case post on Kawaii in that game?

Basically everything I said about Kawaii there does not apply here

This doesn't match up with Kawaii being "super engaged" and being town for it.
I guess i could just be wrong about my thoughts on Kage, but this doesn't look like you're being honest.
VOTE: Klick

I did like this

[Cephrir]

I don't like the way Big Chungus Gaming is interacting with Klick slot, but do like the way they are interacting with T3

have you considered our lord and savior "sort by postcount" though?

VOTE: jjh

It often works but what does this have to do with the post you quoted? All I can come up with is that its just an open "look over there." And why aren't you passionately pushing anything you believe in?

[Klick]

Someone convince me Cakez is scum

because I'm inclined to think otherwise atm but I've been inaccurate on Cakez before

Also @Ali what kind of confidence do you have about Luka!town

I didn't like this

Y

[Firebringer]

To hone his technique he would engage in casual heroics at night. He would save countless but saving lives wasn't the true reason for these antics

Day 1 - Our Story Begins
Vote Count 1.05

Sir Cakez [4][E-5] - PookytheMagicalBear, Penguinpower, Save The Dragons, Alisae,
PookytheMagicalBear [2][E-7]- SirCakez, Cephrir
Klick [2][E-7] - ssbm_Kyouko, Sakura Hana,
Sakura Hana - [1][E-8]- KawaiiKame,
KawaiiKame [1][E-8]-- Gamma Emerald,
Penguinpower [1][E-8] - Dunnstral,
Dunnstral -[1][E-8]- Klick
Cephrir [1][E-8] - jjh927
jjh927 [1][-E8] - Big Chungus Gaming ,
Save the Dragons [1][E-8] Whemestar
Gamma Emerald - [1][E-8] - Luka

Lurking in Shadows (Not Voting - 1) : T3

With 17 Alive, It Takes 9 to Eliminate.
Deadline is (expired on 2024-01-07 15:45:00)

Mod Note: No prods. Merry Christmas.

[Big Chungus Gaming]

I don't like the way Big Chungus Gaming is interacting with Klick slot, but do like the way they are interacting with T3

have you considered our lord and savior "sort by postcount" though?

VOTE: jjh

It often works but what does this have to do with the post you quoted? All I can come up with is that its just an open "look over there." And why aren't you passionately pushing anything you believe in?

yes, yes it is

[Cephrir]

[Klick]

VOTE: jjh927

[T3]

VOTE: Chungus

idk

[Luka]

ssbm_Kyouko
pookythemagicalbear
Alisae
Whemestar
Dunnstral
T3
KawaiiKame
Sakura Hana

Cephrir
Penguinpower
Gamma Emerald
SirCakez

Save the Dragons
Luka
jjh927
Duelist Kage


it would be hilarious if the exact scumteam was the 2nd tier bc it would be extremely on brand for my d1 reads but here is where im at, actually fully ordered without forgetting anyone

Reads I disagree with are a crime

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

VOTE: jjh

merry christmas to all esp the mafia

[Klick]

Someone convince me Cakez is scum because I'm inclined to think otherwise atm but I've been inaccurate on Cakez before

Also @Ali what kind of confidence do you have about Luka!town

whats townie about cakez

He seems kinda confident and is saying things that make me go 'hm okay I could see you having this train of thought as town'

Whats scummy about cakez

[T3]

He seems kinda confident and is saying things that make me go 'hm okay I could see you having this train of thought as town'

Is he generally unconfident as scum?

Also my main issue with him is that I can't really see town having a lot of the trains of thought that he's had

[Klick]

Not really sure, it's been a while since I've thought about Cakez and I don't have a great record of reading him
That's why I was looking for why people think he's scum

[WhemeStar]

When is it my turn for ppl to follow me