Eminence in Shadow: Season 1 [Game Over]

[Save The Dragons]

its mostly a gut feeling, i don't think anything that she's done has been particularly townie or couldn't be replicated by scum

[SirCakez]

i don't recall u asking why i thought sircakez was scum

i feel like his takes are pretty bad and just kind of thrown out there

like the big chungus bussing me take seems kind of out of left field where does that come from

it was just a vibe thus the ???

[Save The Dragons]

okay

kyouko is scum???
sircakes is scum???

there we go

[SirCakez]

perfect

[Cephrir]

its mostly a gut feeling, i don't think anything that she's done has been particularly townie or couldn't be replicated by scum

Ok - that's kinda different from how strong it sounded but sure

[Klick]

It kinda feels like chungus might be bussing StD???

Yes I can see this

[Cephrir]

its mostly a gut feeling, i don't think anything that she's done has been particularly townie or couldn't be replicated by scum

Ok - that's kinda different from how strong it sounded but sure

This post is stupid, I do this all the time, w/e

[Klick]

Oh so you get to ask why but I don't? Hmm

I just don't think piling on there right now is the take you would have if you were town. Call it a feeling

I kinda think we should just vote Fen and call it a day tbh

[Cephrir]

i would need real conviction to vote him d1 and i don't have that

[Save The Dragons]

Oh so you get to ask why but I don't? Hmm

I just don't think piling on there right now is the take you would have if you were town. Call it a feeling

I kinda think we should just vote Fen and call it a day tbh

why

[ssbm_Kyouko]

his case/argument essentially boils down to;

[a] Well I think scum have to be

doing something

in this game

Since Pooky/STD/PP are the ones actively wagoning together in a unit, they must be scum because they are the ones

doing something

this game

This isn't true because in a stagnant game state where not a lot of threatening wagons have appeared and the thread is more or less lethargic because holidays/rl/whatever the scum

do not need to do anything because there is no threat to them

I think you know his point is complete garbage because in your last large theme as scum you didn't do anything and the scum team had no actual plan or tried to do anything and you're just kind of handwaving it to attack me for focusing on it like you expect town!me to not focus on a shitty argument when someone presents it and uses it to push me which is nonsensical.

To be clear, the more you loop back to this, the more I think you are mafia. It doesn't really matter to me whether the three of you voting together is a good way to catch you or not.

I think I did this with Pooky (hydra Smoke and Mirrors) in owners market blitz - I think he'd bring it up over and over again as town. Idk if I've played with scum!Pooky

[ssbm_Kyouko]

the entire premise of your argument is that the "scum team" is trying to "accomplish some goal" by "this point in the game"

here is a completed large theme with Dunnstral in it that finished

viewtopic.php?t=91817

you look at the first 32 pages of that game and you tell me what the fuck the scum team is trying to accomplish

You weren't in this game, is there a reason you brought this game up?

T3 wasn't in Hollow Knight as far as I could tell, is there a reason you

didn't

bring that up?

[Gamma Emerald]

@BCG

do you have any notes on my play so far?

no lmao

Okay. I didn’t completely expect you to but it would have helped me read you if you did.

[Klick]

Oh so you get to ask why but I don't? Hmm

I just don't think piling on there right now is the take you would have if you were town. Call it a feeling

I kinda think we should just vote Fen and call it a day tbh

why

memes

[ssbm_Kyouko]

Here's the situation as i understand it and why i think it's a misunderstanding, this will probably be the only post i make in the matter and only coz i wanna try and facilitate you guys understanding each other. I don't really want to add up to this "war" between i wanna end it instead.

Klick

: The argument here is that the 3 were voting together but are also

Independently scummy

is just another reason to think they are scum.

Pooky

: The argument here is that he's hyperfocusing on one thing, but that was also part of Klick's and Dunnstral's push of him so he was trying to understand the push to sort them.

Dunnstral

: On your case, I'm not sure i think it was just an engagement born of misunderstanding what Pooky was doing and so you ended up wrongly enphasising those points.

Did i get that right?

Yeah that's a decent summary of my perspective

I think Dunnstral genuinely believes Pooky is scum here though and doesn't want to *let go* on that basis

I agree that moving on in some capacity would be a lot better for thread health

I thought your whole thing was that

others are towny

, not that

Pooky, STD, and PP are independently scummy

?

[Klick]

'scummy' is relative

If we wanna get down to the nitty gritty, PenguinPower is probably my only true null between the three, I think the other two lean slightly towards +scum
But not to a level that I think is significant enough to talk about

[ssbm_Kyouko]

So what made you put ssbm_Kyouko as top townread never change by post 210 where you first made your list?

if koba were town and I were scum this game he'd know it by like page 5 tops

[ssbm_Kyouko]

If koba says I'm town, I'm town. I have the receipts to back it up if needed but if he ever flips town I'm basically IC

[ssbm_Kyouko]

I'm curious where the STD wagon came from
UNVOTE:

[ssbm_Kyouko]

Like everyone magically agrees Pooky/Klick/Dunn is all town and then votes STD and I dont see a connection

[PenguinPower]

VOTE: Big Chungus Gaming

now I can get behind this

why'd you call out my vote specifically?

[Luka]

why do you even feel the need to town case yourself already?

I mean, I don't think there's anything wrong with being cleared :p

[Luka]

@save the dragons
Hiya! Can you provide a bit of reasoning? Thank you!

[Save The Dragons]

no

[Klick]

I'm curious where the STD wagon came from
UNVOTE:

Like everyone magically agrees Pooky/Klick/Dunn is all town and then votes STD and I dont see a connection

What we're your thoughts on the Cakez and jjh wagons?